Changes v Richmond R5

[Deemented Are Go! 3,677]

Out: Weed, melksham, hannan

In: Hogan, Hibberd (if fit), t smith

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,833]

Can we please let Demonland do the selections next week - couldn't [censored] it up any more than the professionals did this week against Freo.

[Forest Demon 4,681]

Would like to see the Casey results first, but Weideman almost certainly to go back. Melksham has been ok this year imo, but was shocking today. Hannan probably due to go back for a few as well.

Hogan > Weideman

Hibberd > Melksham

Brayshaw if he plays well a chance to replace Hannan.

Just as the op suggested.

[Dee-licious 1,951]

Backing up the other posters. I'd like to keep Weid because he looked promising in the first 2 matches with Hogan. But it all depends on Casey and if Hibbard is ready to go 

[spirit of norm smith 16,462]

Yes agree

1..Hogan IN  Weideman OUT

2. Hibberd (if fit) IN  Melksham OUT

3. Either Brayshaw/Kennedy  IN  Hannan OUT

jetta  t.mcd  hibberd/melksham

salem  frost  hunt

stretch  viney  vince

kent  watts  petracca

garlett HOGAN anb

Spencer Tyson Jones

Oliver bugg harmes brayshaw/kennedy

emerg. trengove  t.smith  brayshaw/Kennedy

[monoccular 17,431]

1 hour ago, Deemented Are Go! said:

Out: Weed, melksham, hannan

In: Hogan, Hibberd (if fit), t smith

Agree with first two

  Weed looked injured as well as lost - time to reset

  Melksham ? another Essendon Trojan Horse?  Turns over far too much. Hopefully Hibberd may be different

  Hannan - depends on whom is pressing from Casey. Let's see how Tim Smith goes, and Brayshaw and even Trengove

[Lord Byron 32]

Corkie or not, Weed can stand around watching his team mates contest at Casey.

What's with Jake? His field kicking has been ok up to now.

[Adzman 2,154]

A brayshaw or Trengove in for Hannan would have given Goodwin some more flexibility. Against the tigers we will need this.

In: Hogan, Hibberd, Trengove 

out: Weed, Melksham, Hannan 

 

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Big chance for some players at Casey this weekend - Brayshaw, Pedersen and Kennedy to name a few.  Their performance will go along way to deciding the changes for next weekend.

You would think Weideman has used up his chances for the time being and will be straight out for Hogan.  Will Hibberd be right to go after one week at Casey?  Most of us would hope so but we know what happens when you take in a player who is underdone.  Hannan is another who might be on the chopping block and if one of Kennedy or JKH can impress then they may get a run as well.

[Deemented Are Go! 3,677]

20 minutes ago, monoccular said:

Agree with first two

  Weed looked injured as well as lost - time to reset

  Melksham ? another Essendon Trojan Horse?  Turns over far too much. Hopefully Hibberd may be different

  Hannan - depends on whom is pressing from Casey. Let's see how Tim Smith goes, and Brayshaw and even Trengove

Indeed that last spot is a toss up. Quite right to see what happens at Casey 

Edited April 15, 2017 by Deemented Are Go!

[dl4e 5,851]

Lets wait until Casey have played. Still can't understand the dropping of Brayshaw last week.

[DemonLad5 1,642]

In: Hogan, Pedo, Hibberd

Out: Melksham, Weideman, Hannan 

[titan_uranus 25,020]

Will need to see what happens at Casey but I'm currently favouring bringing in Hogan and Hibberd for Weideman and Melksham.

[John Dee 445]

Hannan was a very good contributor today. He will not be dropped.

[dazzledavey36 54,947]

Just saw Melkshams stats..

10 disposals 0 contested 10 uncontested 3 tackles and 7 turnovers.

Under Paul Roos he wouldn't get a game with those numbers. Will Goody drop his mate?

[3Dee 1,153]

I really been trying to get behind Melksham but alas, he's a potato.

[Beetle 4,660]

7 minutes ago, DemonLad5 said:

In: Hogan, Pedo, Hibberd

Out: Melksham, Weideman, Hannan 

This with Bugg out and Brayshaw in.

[Older demon 2,741]

Look to this weeks emergencies first and see how they go on Monday as this has been the hint each week as to who is next in line for promotion.

Trengove, Oscar and Smith were this weeks emergencies so I would not be at all surprised to see Jack back. I expect Hogan to replace Weed. It may be Weed and Melksham for Hogan and Trengove and hope there are no further injuries.

[Dante 2,739]

7 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Just saw Melkshams stats..

10 disposals 0 contested 10 uncontested 3 tackles and 7 turnovers.

Under Paul Roos he wouldn't get a game with those numbers. Will Goody drop his mate?

If I remember correctly, he had zero contested and 18 uncontested possessions last week, bit of a pattern there. 

[rjay 24,929]

As much as I want to see Hibberd in, just can't see it yet.

The one JLT game he had, he was way off his best.

Probably needs a few runs after missing a season.

[What 18,810]

Cant wait to get Hibberd into the side, but I doubt one Casey game will be enough especially if he doesnt play a lot of game time

Hope I am wrong though.

[MudDogs Gawn Win.. someday 499]

Out

Weikaspissernam Melksham Tyson Hannan

 

IN

Hogan Pedersen JKH/Kennedy Hibberd

 

IMO a lot of people are fooled by Tyson irrelevant touches.. he is a slow accumulator who's foot skill are ordinary and too slow to actually use it..

[Roger Mellie 4,032]

2 hours ago, Mud Dogs Gonna Win said:

 

IMO a lot of people are fooled by Tyson irrelevant touches.. he is a slow accumulator who's foot skill are ordinary and too slow to actually use it..

Agree, plus toss in the lack of defensive pressure.

But being an ins and outs thread:

Out Weid,, Tyson

In: Hogan, Brayshaw

Hibberd in next the following round for Melksham 

[The heart beats true 18,128]

This week:

Hogan for Weid. Thats it.

BECAUSE then you've got Jordy and Hibberd ready the following week, and Brayshaw hopefully in touch and knocking down the door. He's too good for the 2's.

I also think our midfield need to be held accountable for that loss and be given a chance to atone. They were nowhere near it in the 3rd and they owe us a 4 quarter effort.

Still not convinced about Hannan, but if Hibberd and Lewis go back, Vince and Salem can go to the wings and everyone rolls forward one spot pushing Hannan and Melksham out.

I still wish we had another forward target. Watts and Hogan are good, but that 3rd versatile forward option is what we lack. I think the long term need for that and the Hogan suspension is all thats kept Weid and Hannan in.

[Wrecker45 3,378]

I've been a massive Weid critic and wanted him dropped last week. I wasn't able to make it to the game yesterday but on the radio they were reporting he copped a heavy corcky to his right leg in the first quater.

Wouldn't be surprised if he is out injured rather than ommitted. He's normally an accurate shot for goal and he couldn't even strike it from 25m out.

He is defenintly more effective when Hogan is in the team but i don't think he'll get the chance to prove that next week.

Could Kelty come in for Melksham?