Farewell Brodie Grundy

[Ferghus31 45]

Melbourne are asking for a player and picks and have offered Sydney Pick 14 plus a future pick plus Grundy for Hadyn Mclean a Forward  would do that deal now 

[Jibroni 4,591]

9 minutes ago, DistrACTION Jackson said:

They will need two 2nd round picks, so maybe something like:

Grundy and pick 27 to swans for Roos future 2nd round + pick 46

I'd do that personally

 

I was hoping we can get a 2nd Rounder this year and package this to GC for Pick 10, otherwise I dont mind it.

[daisycutter 28,782]

3 minutes ago, Ferghus31 said:

Melbourne are asking for a player and picks and have offered Sydney Pick 14 plus a future pick plus Grundy for Hadyn Mclean a Forward  would do that deal now 

just grundy for mclean would do

[Jaded No More 61,844]

5 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

just grundy for mclean would do

Indeed, but Swans will want more for McLean.

 

[Gawndy the Great 8,240]

9 minutes ago, Ferghus31 said:

Melbourne are asking for a player and picks and have offered Sydney Pick 14 plus a future pick plus Grundy for Hadyn Mclean a Forward  would do that deal now 

No, that is overs by a long way.

[Jaded No More 61,844]

16 minutes ago, Gawndy the Great said:

No, that is overs by a long way.

Future picks don't need to come into this.

14 and Grundy for McLean is a very good deal and a win win for both teams  as they both get something they really need.

[IRW 1,339]

On 10/10/2023 at 2:59 AM, IRW said:

They treated him like [censored] why would he stay for  more of the same?

I am waiting to hear his story when  he wins a flag  with the Swans or maybe what May says about him next year

I am even more looking forward to what folks on here say about Tom Hawkins if he kicks 5 in the G/F to seal  the flag for the Dee's next season.

I season at $600 000.!

 

 

[Diamond_Jim 12,246]

Can someone remind me of the usual number of players taken in a draft. IIRC it's between 50 and 60 but I could be wrong.

Pick 44 if so is at the wrong end of the barrel especially when it's around 49 allowing for concessions

[daisycutter 28,782]

5 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Can someone remind me of the usual number of players taken in a draft. IIRC it's between 50 and 60 but I could be wrong.

Pick 44 if so is at the wrong end of the barrel especially when it's around 49 allowing for concessions

actually 44 probably becomes <44 because of all the multi picks for f/s and academy players beforehand

[Go the Biff 3,271]

Rubbish source I know but on SEN this morning there was talk of the AFL agenda items and that the 5 man interchange was in the mix again. 

If this comes to pass, I'm keeping Grundy. That gives us the flexibility to effectively run with 2 first rucks.

Club needs to get a look at the AFL crystal ball before we shunt him off

[jnrmac 19,751]

5 hours ago, Willmoy1947 said:

So we got a "not even goodwill" out of handing JJ to them amicably, you know what i mean.

JJ was a free agent

[monoccular 16,922]

2 hours ago, Wells 11 said:

Is holding on to Brodie a realistic option? Can whatever was broken be mended? 

Great question.  Answer TBA

16 minutes ago, Go the Biff said:

Rubbish source I know but on SEN this morning there was talk of the AFL agenda items and that the 5 man interchange was in the mix again. 

If this comes to pass, I'm keeping Grundy. That gives us the flexibility to effectively run with 2 first rucks.

Club needs to get a look at the AFL crystal ball before we shunt him off

MFCSS tells me that the AFL will wait to see what we do before announcing anything.   If we part ways they will extend the interchange: if he stays they will change the rule that no ruckman can ever be named on the interchange. 🙄😱MFCSS +

 

PS straight swap for Guerdion (?spelling) would be ok 🤗🤗

Edited October 11, 2023 by monoccular

[jnrmac 19,751]

5 hours ago, Macca said:

If you want someone that badly do you offer pick 46?

They know we want to offload

Could just be poor negotiating on their behalf. Softening us up in the hope we accept pick 33 later

[Mickey 4,266]

Grundy done for 46 and future Sydney 2nd rnd pick 

 

Edited October 11, 2023 by Mickey

[Salems Lot 2,418]

2 minutes ago, Mickey said:

Grundy done for 46 and future Sydney 2nd rnd pick

Never as exciting as one hopes for...Thanks for your service though Brodie

[Wells 11 5,100]

2 minutes ago, Mickey said:

Grundy done for 46 and future Sydney 2nd rnd pick

So, thats 46 and probably a pick in the mid 30's if the swans finish somewhere between 4 -8

[demoncat 688]

6 minutes ago, Mickey said:

Grundy done for 46 and future Sydney 2nd rnd pick 

 

Haven’t done the maths but probably similar value to the pick 27 we paid for him? 

Currently leaves us with 6, 11, 41 and 46 for this year, with our own future picks, Sydney’s future second and Dogs future third 

A bit to play out yet…

Edited October 11, 2023 by demoncat

[titan_uranus 23,613]

A future 2nd is in the 20s, if Sydney struggle next year, or the 30s if they do well. 

I’m comfortable with it given we clearly didn’t consider him part of our future.

And so ends one of the more interesting player trades we’ve engaged in. I reckon Grundy will do really well at Sydney, and I actually hope he does. 

[Nascent 8,093]

Haven't seen confirmation on it yet but based on this years ladder position it would have been 31 and 46.

Was 29 but pushed back 2 spots for north compo picks.

F2 Can fall anywhere between 21 and 39.

 

[Nascent 8,093]

@adonski

A 2nd death ride calls.

[binman 40,495]

7 minutes ago, Wells 11 said:

So, thats 46 and probably a pick in the mid 30's if the swans finish somewhere between 4 -8

A very mild death ride next year.

Perhaps a slow decline ride?

[Swooper1987 2,943]

Fair deal. 

[Demonland 67,237]

 

[BangBnagBang 545]

4 minutes ago, Nascent said:

Haven't seen confirmation on it yet but based on this years ladder position it would have been 31 and 46.

Was 29 but pushed back 2 spots for north compo picks.

F2 Can fall anywhere between 21 and 39.

 

based on points

21 & 46 = equivalent pick 14

39 & 46 = 25

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

He’ll do very well at Sydney, they again will be right up there in the mix to win a flag.

What debacle it has been since he arrived at the club, getting him was not the issue (replacement for Jackson) but what we did (and didn’t do more importantly) with him while the team yet again went out in straight sets was a disgrace.

We had Petracca in the ruck while Grundy sat in the stands.