Barrett...again...really?

[Ted Lasso 19,519]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-09-10/anger-threatens-to-boil-over

Seriously?

I haven't seen much of anything that suggests there is anything to this at all, seems as though he is making things up to try and pour cold water on the idea.

most seem unimpressed about the financial assistance, but 34 wins in 7 years, a new coach, president, Ceo, board completely flipped upside down, mostly new players, might be time for Barrett to pull his head out of his ass.

Discuss.

[beelzebub 23,380]

hes a [censored] of the highest order isnt he. A very biased and jealous [censored] at that

[Ted Lasso 19,519]

hes a [censored] of the highest order isnt he. A very biased and jealous [censored] at that

It drives me crazy, he squeels this crap at anyone who will listen, this is the fourth article i have read about exactly this in a month

he forgets PJ is in alot of ways an independent CEO, he isn't Melbourne through and through in the way Stynsey was, if he thinks we need a PP, it's because he is at ground zero every day and knows we do for 100 good reasons not just we want an extra pick.

[Bay Riffin 1,475]

hes a [censored] of the highest order isnt he. A very biased and jealous [censored] at that

supporters keep saying we will just stuff it up then vehemiently are against it.

Im sure Newbold at Hawthorn won't mind if Buddy wins them another premiership. They had two chances with priorities till they got Franklin.

Conveniently we can't go back and have another chance though.

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

Getting real sick of your [censored], Barrett...

[Ted Lasso 19,519]

If we don't qualify based on our record, noone does and the rule should be scrapped.

[mauriesy 7,299]

Love the total contradiction in this sentence:

"Melbourne has been given enough assistance in recent years, been a debilitating drain on the entire competition for too long."

[jazza 1,323]

hes a [censored] of the highest order isnt he. A very biased and jealous [censored] at that

you know when Damien barrett is translated into german ,and means whale virgina

Edited September 9, 2013 by jazza

[drdrake 3,178]

The other clubs must be prepared that if the MFC doesn't get a priority pick this year it basically mean the priority pick is dead. It's funny to listen to members of the media whose teams have greatly benefited from the priority picks in the past now come out dead against us getting one. Carlton for example has 3 priority no 1 picks, they shouldn't have been in the draft for 2 of those years due to cheating but found a loop hole that allowed them to get Gibbs and Murphey followed up with the tank year to get Kruzer. Of the top 8 teams I think 5 have benefited from priority picks.

We have had 7 bad years and received 2 priority picks. The media are making it out that we have a heap of proirity picks, the other early picks we have had are due to trading, losing a No1 pick to an expansion club and our National draft picks.

[rjay 24,940]

Love the total contradiction in this sentence:

"Melbourne has been given enough assistance in recent years, been a debilitating drain on the entire competition for too long."

That's it isn't it, as Jackson has stated the club has been a drain on the competition. The commission will act in the best interests of the competition and I'm sure they will be interested in the propaganda campaign being run by the other clubs and not necessarily swayed by it one way or another.

[Whispering_Jack 30,206]

The reason the AFL is run by a commission and not by the individual clubs is exactly for this.

There's a rule on the AFL's books that allows for draft assistance to clubs with poor records. The AFL has to consider that rul on the basis of the here and now and not upon anything else.

Quite frankly, if the clubs can have a say in the way the AFL is run then I say scrap the prospective compensation to Hawthorn and Collingwood if Buddy and Daisy are taken as free agents.

What's good for the goose is good for the gander.

[TheoX 1,222]

The other clubs must be prepared that if the MFC doesn't get a priority pick this year it basically mean the priority pick is dead. It's funny to listen to members of the media whose teams have greatly benefited from the priority picks in the past now come out dead against us getting one. Carlton for example has 3 priority no 1 picks, they shouldn't have been in the draft for 2 of those years due to cheating but found a loop hole that allowed them to get Gibbs and Murphey followed up with the tank year to get Kruzer. Of the top 8 teams I think 5 have benefited from priority picks.

We have had 7 bad years and received 2 priority picks. The media are making it out that we have a heap of proirity picks, the other early picks we have had are due to trading, losing a No1 pick to an expansion club and our National draft picks.

Exactly. Hawthorn and Collingwood have both won flags directly through priority picks (and tanking).

[Jara 1,153]

Anybody else listen to 'rumour files' on 3AW breakfast?

Ross's rumour, this morning, was that we weren't going to get a PP. Hate to say it, but he's usually on the money.

As the rest of you have said, it's outrageous. Their argument just doesn't make sense. You're a basket case, so you don't

deserve a priority pick. That's exactly when you do deserve one.

Jeez, two wins all year...

Hawks get Roughy and Buddy (and are about to get a premiership) Pies get Pendlebury and Swan.

We get zip.

Edited September 10, 2013 by Jara

[Fat Tony 5,234]

The reason the AFL is run by a commission and not by the individual clubs is exactly for this.

There's a rule on the AFL's books that allows for draft assistance to clubs with poor records. The AFL has to consider that rul on the basis of the here and now and not upon anything else.

Quite frankly, if the clubs can have a say in the way the AFL is run then I say scrap the prospective compensation to Hawthorn and Collingwood if Buddy and Daisy are taken as free agents.

What's good for the goose is good for the gander.

Poor clubs like us will be hurt most if they take away the compensation for free agents. We will become a gateway for other clubs to pick off our best talent.

FWIW We should have delayed our request for a Priority Pick till the last minute.

[Ted Lasso 19,519]

Poor clubs like us will be hurt most if they take away the compensation for free agents. We will become a gateway for other clubs to pick off our best talent.

FWIW We should have delayed our request for a Priority Pick till the last minute.

I don't think so, let the other clubs know we want/are more than likely going to get one,

people need to remember this isn't about keeping others happy, this pick could have us going up the ladder quite abit if we use it right.

[BarnDee 287]

you know when Damien barrett is translated into german ,and means whale virgina

how did you work that out ? according to google translate , its not , but wish it did

[Choko 493]

He's a journalist with an opinion. Shock. Horror.

[Little Richard 6,264]

Wonder who's paying him?

[titan_uranus 25,020]

Sydney gets extra money for some sort of 'cost of living' allowance, which we all know isn't used on cost of living. Collingwood, Essendon, Carlton, Richmond get to avoid trips to Geelong. Hawthorn travels to fewer interstate clubs because it gets accommodated for its decision to play down in Tasmania.

In one way or another, many other clubs get some sort of leg up from the AFL.

We happen to be the biggest basket case the competition has ever faced. Unlike the other nice little advantages the other clubs get, ours is to help us out of the quagmire, to ensure we don't fall apart, that we don't continue to ruin their financial bottom lines.

A strong Melbourne is in everyone's best interests, whether Damien Barrett likes it or not.

Love the total contradiction in this sentence:

"Melbourne has been given enough assistance in recent years, been a debilitating drain on the entire competition for too long."

Was about to post the same thing.

Damien Barrett = AFL's biggest [censored].

[alias275 259]

Just another type writer geek who has never played the game. I reckon he would wet himself at the first sight of a brawl.

As they say, only important personalities in the AFL have their own wiki page. Sorry Damo, no one cares about you or what you say.

[rpfc 28,502]

Anybody else listen to 'rumour files' on 3AW breakfast?

Ross's rumour, this morning, was that we weren't going to get a PP. Hate to say it, but he's usually on the money.

As the rest of you have said, it's outrageous. Their argument just doesn't make sense. You're a basket case, so you don't

deserve a priority pick. That's exactly when you do deserve one.

Jeez, two wins all year...

Hawks get Roughy and Buddy (and are about to get a premiership) Pies get Pendlebury and Swan.

We get zip.

They may not give us a PP but still give us draft assistance...

Jackson will fight for it. These hacks can continue with their contradictory nose up in the air if they want to.

It is not relevant that we have drafted poorly to whether we get a PP but the AFL will want to tread lightly and Barrett thinks he is going to be the darling of the other clubs if he kicks up a stink about it.

Meanwhile, Hawthorn has its hypocritical hoof on our throat.

I hope we get it and I hope they hate us.

No apologies.

[Clintosaurus 7,852]

I think Brayshaw is loading the gun. Barrett is a North man. Loved it on Triple M on Saturday when he was outed for having two people working on audio packages to enter for the Walkley and other awards. Self promoting [censored].

[McQueen 17,865]

Pole. Smoker.

[Tony Tea 2,809]

Demetriou said on KB that GWS has a lot to look forward to "including Tom Boyd," which means we are not getting Pick 1.

[torpedo 33]

To be honest, I understand where people are coming from when they say 'MFC does not need handouts, MFC needs to stand on its own two feet.'

We have been stockpiling high draft picks, Priority Picks and compensation picks for years and we have gotten worse.

Our race to the bottom in 2009 clearly had an adverse effect on our club's culture, whether or not it is tanking is beside the point. MFC's naive reliance on draft picks in place of hard work is a major reason why we find ourselves where we do in 2013.

MFC must create a winning culture. Will another Priority Pick assist with this or will it simply continue the cycle of our playing list & club relying on others for success?