Post Match Discussion - Round 11

[titan_uranus 22,778]

titan - Jetta had the job on Wjngard, and won the battle convincingly.

That makes more sense, given Jetta was in most people's votes. He's really developing into an integral part of our side now.

Did Grimes run with anyone?

[beelzebub 22,342]

Did Grimes run with anyone?

His shadow by many accounts

[DemonOX 8,551]

A lot are saying bring on the pies but what concerns me is the toll this will take on our players.

Does anyone else have this concern?

[pantaloons 2,019]

If it's any consolation, our loss was only the second-most crushing loss by a Victorian team playing interstate who threw a game away by allowing its opposition to score the final four goals in the dying minutes today.

[T-34 409]

I wish we had of received a run of frees like Brisbane just had in the final quarter.

We would have pulled it off if we had of.

[P-man 13,277]

That makes more sense, given Jetta was in most people's votes. He's really developing into an integral part of our side now.

Did Grimes run with anyone?

Also went onto the Chad at times but he was lethargic, timid and second to the ball all day so it was hard to tell what he meant to be doing. When he did find himself in space, half the time he turned it over. He usually has one of those badly timed turnovers but today he had several.

Worth noting that Dunn also did a fantastic job on Schulz. He is going from strength to strength.

[What 18,810]

A lot are saying bring on the pies but what concerns me is the toll this will take on our players.

Does anyone else have this concern?

No

The game isnt until Monday and the Pies will lose Sidebottom and Maxwell

[beelzebub 22,342]

A lot are saying bring on the pies but what concerns me is the toll this will take on our players.

Does anyone else have this concern?

No

I should think theyd actually be rather buoyed by today ( and a good rest )

[Red and Bluebeard 2,049]

I love our team.

JUST BRING ON THE PIES.

I usually knock off a couple of pies on QB .. for once, I think our boys might do the same

[KLV 1,684]

Go Lions! I always enjoy a Carlton defeat!

[KingDingAling 3,622]

Christian Salem has an elite footy brain and the skills to match

What a gem

Has the balance, skills and class of great players.

Salem is still working into it, touch underdone and will get better.

I am one eyed Salem, I think he is the greatest thing since sliced bread.

[What 18,810]

Go Lions! I always enjoy a Carlton defeat!

that was awesome

cant wait for the Malthouse press conference to see him fuming and crying

[Demon Jack 6,388]

Just watched the highlights and oh my goodness does Salem have some class about him. Will be unlucky not to be considered for the rising star this week.

[Gorgoroth 12,362]

The passage where he and Toumpas worked together was top class.

[Late Draft Pick 48]

We don't know how lucky we were!! ( Alot of things went against Port today but luck didn't stlil quite go our way in the end.)

But lets not forget for those of us watching on Fox - we could have had Dwayne Russell commentating. Checking out the Brisbane- Carlton game I thought how it would have been with Dwayne Russell commentating, always stating the obvious and thinking that that is very exciting. I can imagine his

patronizing/sarcastic comments when Melb got 10 points up. But does he ever tell the listeners something they don't know or

just describe the game outside of telling us the scores and what it means to both clubs and yes, where both clubs are on the ladder

20 times a game. He doesn't realize that his commentary is all about him.

I thought as a team low on the ladder that the commentators were great today - Dermie and Shaw were always on about how fantastic Melboure were, brilliant in some cases.

We are really going somewhere with this team and there will be a massive crowd next week to see us v the Pies.

[jackaub 1,402]

The game was lost with 6 minutes remaining.

We had the ball at half-back, 1 point down. We chip it around half-back, against the most dangerous team in the league.

It was bound to go downhill from there. We turned it over and they scored a goal. Game over.

Ultimately, that moment was representative of the final 10 minutes: Port took the game on, Melbourne didn't.

Yes Cudi my heart sank then and I just knew that was the wrong play we should have attacked long but hopefully they are learning what to do to win

[Ethan Tremblay 28,541]

A lot are saying bring on the pies but what concerns me is the toll this will take on our players.

Does anyone else have this concern?

It depends on what toll you are talking about. Physically or mentally?

My concern is the effort without the reward of winning. I'm well into my second bottle of red after a few beers so I hope I'm making some sense. I just hope we can manage to win a couple of games over the next few weeks for the sake of the effort put in by the players.

[whatwhat say what 19,722]

I really can't understand the negativity. We matched it with, and for long periods were better than, the best side in the competition. And don't tell me they're 'pretenders' - they've convincingly beaten Hawthorn, Fremantle and Geelong and they continually play fast, skilful, strong football. They're the real deal. Meanwhile we have spent the most part of the last 7 years in the bottom four (didn't we read that the win against Richmond took us out of the bottom four for only the second time in 2.5 years?).

We're still going to have poor games, but we look more and more likely to win a game or two you never would have thought we'd be winning this year.

i think the thing is we now WANT to win. and we could've, should've, would've won this game in other circumstances.

heaps to be excited about tho, for sure.

[chook fowler 18,392]

The poor starts to games have been a problem for several years now. Something the coaching group need to work on. I swear they were asleep for the first 15 minutes. Hard to fathom.

[monoccular 16,408]

Christian Salem has an elite footy brain and the skills to match

What a gem

The passage where he and Toumpas worked together was top class.

I couldn't see the game but just watched a Salem highlights clip from the club website -- OMG what a find. Cool, calm, collected, skilled and smart.

The shepherd when Toump had the ball, then his second effort to take the mark was outstanding especially for one so young.

[Dingo 838]

I am not happy with some of the negative comments about Max Gawn's game.However I will agree he didn't do anything fantastic today.But we were playing the top team so their backline is pretty good.But didn't he kick our first goal?This seems to be omitted in some people's criticisms.And I reckon he played a pretty respectful game last week against the Tiges .How about that ruck tap out to Bernie Vince - who kicked a goal! Max has lost a lot of game time over the years due to injuries - two knee recos mainly.And this year I think he injured his hammy which has kept him off the pre- season training track.Give Max time - and support - because I think he will be a Champion Player for us in the future.Go Max!

[Dannyz 2,345]

I couldn't see the game but just watched a Salem highlights clip from the club website -- OMG what a find. Cool, calm, collected, skilled and smart.

The shepherd when Toump had the ball, then his second effort to take the mark was outstanding especially for one so young.

Agee that with the ball Salem is very classy but the highlights didn't show at least 3 poor defensive efforts. PR will be all over this.

[Deespicable 2,567]

Salems best game for the club by some distance

He's only played five games and three of them were as a sub, so it would be pretty hard for it not to be.

[godees 661]

No

The game isnt until Monday and the Pies will lose Sidebottom and Maxwell

They will gain Swan, Grundy (Jamar will smash him) and Ball though

[Deez 298]

disregard maxwell out, bit of nothing really.
swan and ball are two big ins.
jamar and peders can smash grundy.
gawny might get another crack also.

keen as for next monday!