-
Posts
17,743 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
31
Binmans PA last won the day on October 15
Binmans PA had the most liked content!
About Binmans PA
- Birthday 23/06/1987
Previous Fields
-
Favourite Player(s)
Oliver, Langdon, Petty, Lever, Petracca, Gawn, Rivers and Kozzy
Profile Information
-
Gender
Male
-
Location
Melbourne
Recent Profile Visitors
Binmans PA's Achievements

Legend (6/10)
25.3k
Reputation
-
They're not a waste of money, because they create jobs and create revenue for local businesses, but when governments are imposing austerity in most other sectors of the economy, spending on stadiums and infrastructure for the Olympics does feel like the wrong value proposition. But we lost our way on many of our values many decades ago, so this is merely a continuation of this.
-
Welcome to Demonland Kynan Brown
Binmans PA replied to dazzledavey36's topic in Trade, Draft & Free Agency
The club media department really need to do some work on their interview questions. Great little video as both of them seem so happy, but as an interviewer you've got to ask some broader questions that aren't likely to elicit the same sort of responses. -
Change coming to the Academy System
Binmans PA replied to Whispering_Jack's topic in Trade, Draft & Free Agency
I think the view that the AFL would take is they haven't had enough concessions until they're winning constant premierships. -
Welcome to Demonland Kynan Brown
Binmans PA replied to dazzledavey36's topic in Trade, Draft & Free Agency
I reckon Dogga Brown Jnr looks a beauty. More pace to add to Caleb Windsor too. I wonder what his tank and aerobic ceiling is. He's a fraction small perhaps for the wing, but probably no smaller than Hunter, and much quicker, with a strong ability to win the contest and release by hand, and neat by foot. Lots to work with. A bit of a steal as a rookie IMO. -
Welcome to Demonland Koltyn Tholstrup
Binmans PA replied to Mach5's topic in Trade, Draft & Free Agency
Because we have an elite midfield and elite defence, and need a much better forward half cohort. We've gone about addressing that by giving ourselves options. Koltyn is explosive, McAdam has x factor, Billings has ball use, and Windsor has run, carry and ball use to keep Hunter and Langdon honest on the wing, or play half back and allow a Bowey or McVee to play higher up the field. -
In October, I was asking what trading in pick 11 left us with picks wise...
-
Welcome to Demonland Koltyn Tholstrup
Binmans PA replied to Mach5's topic in Trade, Draft & Free Agency
Thanks mate. I like the idea of someone like him playing defensive forward and allowing a McAdam a bit more room to play as a flair player. That said, no idea how we fit everyone in that 7 string forward half when Koltyn is finally ready to play seniors for us. -
Welcome to Demonland Koltyn Tholstrup
Binmans PA replied to Mach5's topic in Trade, Draft & Free Agency
He reminds me of Caddy when he's forward and Sparrow when he's in the midfield. It's that power type player that has the ability to win or halve big contests in the middle or in the forward half. He's a very 'Melbourne' pick. At least, a JT type. I'm intrigued what the wraps on him were at the end of last year to make him worthy of a top 5 selection, @Gator. Any insight there? Obviously, he's fallen down the order a bit due to injury, but to be worthy of top 5 talk, you'd have to have some elite attributes outside of mere power. -
Apparently, every club in the top 10 needs to do a better job then, because it played out almost exactly like most phantoms. And why are you whinging? We got the two guys we wanted...
-
FWIW, his aunty and uncle are huge Melbourne fans.
-
Welcome to Demonland Caleb Windsor
Binmans PA replied to adonski's topic in Trade, Draft & Free Agency
I mean, I'm not convinced we'll take Caleb, so we'll see. -
Welcome to Demonland Caleb Windsor
Binmans PA replied to adonski's topic in Trade, Draft & Free Agency
Daicos is pretty light. It's more about Caleb's aerobic ability to play wing at this stage. And giving us some competition for wing spots would be very welcome. -
Welcome to Demonland Koltyn Tholstrup
Binmans PA replied to Mach5's topic in Trade, Draft & Free Agency
He wasn't picked by JT... -
Welcome to Demonland Caleb Windsor
Binmans PA replied to adonski's topic in Trade, Draft & Free Agency
Agreed. I think the game has changed a bit again, to enable uncontested players to play a bigger role. My concern on that sort of player is that the game will invariably shift again to a greater need to win contests. That said, if JT and co pick him early, then I'll trust them. -
I still really like O'Sullivan, but I'm warming to Curtin.