Clarry better start than Judd?

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 6,632]

2 hours ago, Diamond_Jim said:

11 kicks ... 24 handballs

Needs to reverse that and then he will start getting the accolades he probably deserves from the commentators

what about the 15 metre handball to petracca out in space, who went long to Hogan in the Goal square. Thats worth double than a kick, dont over look the importance of a team releasing handball that leads to setting up attacking movements DJ.

[samcantstandya 1,035]

2 hours ago, chook fowler said:

Best hands since Deisel Williams and a better kick. 

I've always thought of him as a similar player 2 Diesel but a longer kick. He is a champ.

[Diamond_Jim 12,393]

54 minutes ago, Win4theAges said:

what about the 15 metre handball to petracca out in space, who went long to Hogan in the Goal square. Thats worth double than a kick, dont over look the importance of a team releasing handball that leads to setting up attacking movements DJ.

each to his own but I think you may find that I am not alone with how Oliver is perceived... a good player who could be so much better if he kicked it more

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Gotta have 4 goal games along with all the hard ball gets etc to say that. Judd is in a class of his own.

Still. Best mid we've had in my lifetime.

[jumbo returns 6,713]

Best mid since Brian Wilson

[RalphiusMaximus 6,013]

Clarry is a completely different player to Judd.  He has an appetite for contested ball and tackling that Judd never had, while Judd had that explosive burst to carry him into space and kick goals.  I rate Judd a little ahead for impact on games, but it's not a big margin. 

[P-man 13,366]

2 hours ago, ProDee said:

From the author of the top 10 under 23

Ben Guthrie‏Verified account @BenGuthrie_

FollowingFollowing @BenGuthrie_

More

Ben Guthrie Retweeted AFL.com.au

Clearly should have had Clayton Oliver on this list! The midfielder has been absolutely immense tonight. So clean in slippery conditions. #AFLLionsDees #thegameisingoodhands

 

At least he’s realised his mistake but it’s a crazy one to make in the first place.

[Dee Zephyr 19,250]

Won’t be long before we see a headline like this.

Is this kid the next Clayton Oliver?

Do all of you slap yourselves to realise he’s only 20?

 

[monoccular 17,357]

3 hours ago, Deemania since 56 said:

Remarkable player, ball clearances expert. Goes in, gets the ball and uses it to advantage nearly every time. Takes a tag or two with poise and takes a knock or two with maturity. Beautiful kicking emphasised last night. Handball wizard. Virtually unstoppable across a game. Needs to run special skills clinics with all other players, just to teach them to think and do. 

Seriously I doubt very much that what he does can be taught ...... but I get your drift. 

[Adam The God 29,680]

2 hours ago, RalphiusMaximus said:

Clarry is a completely different player to Judd.  He has an appetite for contested ball and tackling that Judd never had, while Judd had that explosive burst to carry him into space and kick goals.  I rate Judd a little ahead for impact on games, but it's not a big margin. 

Give Clarry another year or two and let's have the conversation again. In only his third year, Clarry's start has been every bit as good as Judd's. And statically, he's miles ahead of Judd at the same stage.

With more experience, Clarry's impact will be even greater. He's our most important player IMO.

[rumpole 514]

My info is that success has gotten to Judd’s head since his retirement and he’s not all that popular.

Happy for Clarrie to emulate his success but not at the expense of a balanced life.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,013]

13 minutes ago, A F said:

Give Clarry another year or two and let's have the conversation again. In only his third year, Clarry's start has been every bit as good as Judd's. And statically, he's miles ahead of Judd at the same stage.

With more experience, Clarry's impact will be even greater. He's our most important player IMO.

Judd won the Brownlow in his third year.  Will Oliver? 

[Adam The God 29,680]

37 minutes ago, RalphiusMaximus said:

Judd won the Brownlow in his third year.  Will Oliver? 

Oliver isn't playing in a team that is as dominant, so no, but that means little IMO.

[markc 975]

for me he needs to Kick more goals

but will be one of our best 

[Demonland 70,598]

[D4Life 2,412]

Totally different players , Judd was a jet, higher impact and pack escaping speed, Oliver is already a gun, ball magnet, great vision, clean, and Oliver seems to play well every week, can’t remember another Demon who has done that over the last 50 years.

I look forward to watching him star for Dees over the next decade. He has a few mates in Petracca, Hogan, Gawn and Viney.

[Ethan Tremblay 30,446]

Oliver v Judd’s averages at the same age https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?playerStatus1=A&tid1=12&pid1=4166&fid1=O&playerStatus2=I&tid2=4&pid2=109&fid2=O&type=A

Edited April 2, 2018 by Ethan Tremblay

[Jaded No More 68,692]

It’s such an odd comparison, because they are very different player. The only commonality between the two, is they are both exceptional players. 

Oliver is one of the best players I have ever seen in a Melbourne jumper. His hands are phenomenal. I can’t wait to see how far he goes. The sky is literally the limit for this kid. 

[Gator 17,261]

As others have mentioned it's a strange comparison.

Judd wasn't a huge accumulator, but had maximum impact from his possessions.  Judd was faster and his sheer brilliance was on another scale to Oliver.

Live at the G one day judd looked like an 18 year old playing against 12 year olds.  I doubt Oliver will ever give that impression.

That's not to say he won't be as valuable, or even more so, but they're just very different players.

[Gorgoroth 12,786]

9 hours ago, Demonland said:

Meters gained for each player would be vastly in Judds favour. 

Also wonder what the K-H ratio is opposed to overall disposals.

[durango 1,992]

Statistics can be read many different ways but the distance the  ball travels from hand and foot can also be misleading the other statistic and probably more important is the scoring assists and efficiency of disposal for instance a player who handballs to another play 10 meters away he kicks the ball 50 meters to another player on your side is better than a 60 meter kick which goes to the opposite team.

They are both good players but one has been measured on his whole career whilst the other has not even played 3 full season but has won the best and fairest at his club in his second season, when did Judd win the best and fairest of West Coast?

[Lord Travis 10,539]

15 minutes ago, durango said:

Statistics can be read many different ways but the distance the  ball travels from hand and foot can also be misleading the other statistic and probably more important is the scoring assists and efficiency of disposal for instance a player who handballs to another play 10 meters away he kicks the ball 50 meters to another player on your side is better than a 60 meter kick which goes to the opposite team.

They are both good players but one has been measured on his whole career whilst the other has not even played 3 full season but has won the best and fairest at his club in his second season, when did Judd win the best and fairest of West Coast?

Judd won the Brownlow, best and fairest, and was All Australian in his 3rd year as a 20-21 year old. He finished 2nd in his second year as a 19 year old... but was second to Ben Cousins, who was one of the best midfielders of the decade. 

Clarry is far ahead on pure numbers, but Judd definitely impacted games more. No one else has ever had as big an impact that early in their career as Judd did. 

Edited April 2, 2018 by Lord Travis

[daisycutter 29,450]

9 minutes ago, Lord Travis said:

Judd won the Brownlow, best and fairest, and was All Australian in his 3rd year as a 20-21 year old. He finished 2nd in his second year as a 19 year old... but was second to Ben Cousins, who was one of the best midfielders of the decade. 

Clarry is far ahead on pure numbers, but Judd definitely impacted games more. No one else has ever had as big an impact that early in their career as Judd did. 

actually there has been quite a few

just a few off top of head - Ian Stewart, Royce Hart, Carl Ditterich, Tim watson, Peter Hudson.......

Edited April 2, 2018 by daisycutter

[Adam The God 29,680]

I really think the most apt comparison to Clarry is Sam Mitchell. A stoppage genius with the handball, but also a beautiful kick. He scored 100% for kicking at the draft combine. As soon as he adds goals to his game, which he has started to do, he will be in the top 10 players in the comp. Mitchell was also perennially underrated.

[dees189227 12,299]

nup not until Oliver wins a couple of brownlows, helps his team to win a flag and be consistent every week. Oliver also needs to kick goals to add to his skill set. That is something Judd did.