Demonland Player of the Year - Round 10

[deeflog 679]

6- jones

5- garlett 

4- hibberd

3- harmes

2- frost

1- hannan

[IvanBartul13 2,564]

6. Jones

5. Garlett

4. Hibberd

3 Oliver

2 Melksham

1 Lewis

[Deestroy All 14,262]

7 - Sportsbet

6 - Jones. Thought his teammates made him look like [censored] in the first half. He killed the 2nd half  

5 - Garlett. Perfect small forward game and racked up touches. 

4 - Oliver. I'm confused why he wasn't in the middle/on the ground more. 

3 - Hibberd. 

2 - Harmes.

1 - Pedo. For effort and for being the only bloke that could hit a target in the first half. 

 

Special mention to ANB for playing footy like Dane Swan for 10 minutes and driving momentum. 

[The Swimming Dee 1,904]

First time poster very long time reader but here goes:

6 - Garlett. 5 goals, enough said

5 - Jones, turned the game

4 -Hibberd, not sure he had a bad disposal. His awareness is first class

3 - Melksham, easily his best game for us. He was fantastic and loved his aggression

2 - Oliver, in 30 years of following our great club I have never seen a better kid. Unlucky to only get 2 votes.

1 - Pedersen. Massive effort around the ground and great delivery into the forward line. A re-born footballer.

Edited May 27, 2017 by The Swimming Dee

[Bates Mate 4,468]

Only 2nd half

Jones

Hibberd

Garlett

Melksham

Tyson

 

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

I`m staggered at the amount of people that left Oliver out of their best 6.

21 of his 28 possessions were contested (next best on the field was 14)

Also the most clearances of all players with 11. (Lyons had 9, next best was 5!)

 

[JV7 2,350]

6- Jones

5- Garlett

4 - Hibberd

3 - Melksham

2 - Oliver

1- Tyson

[Pennant St Dee 13,118]

6. Jones

5. Hibberd

4. Garlett

3. Melksham

2. Oliver

1. Viney

Unlucky Hannan and Tyson

[Gator 17,281]

Some posters must subscribe to the view that Oliver's disposals are overrated, as many (most) don't include him in their votes.  

With 3 games left for the round he has the most contested possessions, most centre clearances, second most total clearances, and equal second most disposals.  He gets us going with contested footy and clearances, and is pivotal to the hard run and spread.  

6 Jones

5 Garlett

4 Oliver

3 Hibberd

2 Hannan

1 Melksham 

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

6. Jones

5. Garlett

4. Oliver

3. Hibberd 

2. Hannan

1. Pedersen

 

[Lucifers Hero 39,600]

The blinkers seem to be on today. 

Of the possible 714 votes cast, Lewis gets 8 and Watts gets 1. 

They were as instrumental in turning the game in the 3rd qtr as was Jones.

Edited May 27, 2017 by Lucifer's Hero

[Skuit 10,031]

10 minutes ago, ProDee said:

Some posters must subscribe to the view that Oliver's disposals are overrated, as many (most) don't include him in their votes.  

With 3 games left for the round he has the most contested possessions, most centre clearances, second most total clearances, and equal second most disposals.  He gets us going with contested footy and clearances, and is pivotal to the hard run and spread.  

I can't fathom Oliver's common omission. Slow to work his way into the game (and started on the bench?), but was instrumental in turning it from the middle. 21 contested possessions and 11 clearances - along with opening up space for numerous scoring chains - what team has everyone been watching to think this is some sort of luxury? 

[Gator 17,281]

AFL.COM.AU Summary.  Oliver given best.

MELBOURNE    2.1   4.8   9.10   18.14   (122)
GOLD COAST   4.5   7.7    9.8     13.9     (87) 

GOALS
Melbourne: Garlett 5, Jones 3, Harmes 3, Hannan 3, Tyson, Petracca, Neal-Bullen, Watts
Gold Coast: Matera 3, Lynch 2, Wright 2, Barlow 2, Sexton, Lemmens, Kolodjashnij, Hall 

BEST 
Melbourne: Oliver, Jones, Hibberd, Lewis, Garlett, Melksham
Gold Coast: Hall, Swallow, Kolodjashnij, Leslie, Matera 

INJURIES 
Melbourne: Nil
Gold Coast: Nil 

Reports: Nil

[Stingray 157]

6. Jones

5. Garlett

4. Hibberd

3. Oliver

2. Watts

1. Lewis 

[Demonland 71,622]

Clayton Oliver holds a good lead but Nathan Jones is rising.

98. Clayton Oliver
78. Nathan Jones
59. Michael Hibberd 
57. Jack Watts
44. Jack Viney
39. Jeff Garlett
33. Jayden Hunt
23. Jordan Lewis Christian Petracca
21. Dom Tyson
18. Sam Frost 
17. Tom McDonald Christian Salem        
14. Cam Pedersen          
13. Mitch Hannan                                 
12. Neville Jetta  
11. Max Gawn                                                  
9. Bernie Vince          
7. Jake Melksham Alex Neal-Bullen
6. Jesse Hogan 
5. Dean Kent Billy Stretch 
1. James Harmes                                     

[Gator 17,281]

2 hours ago, Demonland said:

Clayton Oliver holds a good lead but Nathan Jones is rising.

98. Clayton Oliver
78. Nathan Jones
59. Michael Hibberd 
57. Jack Watts                                                 
44. Jack Viney
33. Jayden Hunt
28. Michael Hibberd
24. Jeff Garlett
23. Jordan Lewis Christian Petracca
21. Dom Tyson
18. Sam Frost 
17. Tom McDonald Christian Salem        
14. Cam Pedersen          
13. Mitch Hannan                                 
12. Neville Jetta  
11. Max Gawn                                                  
9. Bernie Vince          
7. Jake Melksham Alex Neal-Bullen
6. Jesse Hogan 
5. Dean Kent Billy Stretch 
1. James Harmes                                     

The omnipresent michael Hibberd.

Edited May 28, 2017 by ProDee

[Dee Dee 1,105]

6: Jones

5: Hibberd

4: Garlett

3: Oliver

2: Harmes

1: Hannan 

 

[TRIGON 4,783]

6 Jones

5 Oliver 

4 Garlett

3 Hibberd

2 Lewis

1 Melksham

(hard to gauge a game on tv)

 

[Deeoldfart 8,005]

6.  Jones  -  Led from the front and turned the game.

5.  Garlett  -  Excellent small forward game with goals and pressure.  Probably best game for the Dees.

4.  Hibberd  -  Has become a mainstay of our defence.

3.  Oliver  -  Another top-notch performance.  Not far off being the clearance king of the comp.

2.  Frost  -  Held (arguably) the best KPF in the game and is becoming a weapon off HB.

1.  Hannan  -  X factor and growing in confidence each week.  Another tick for our recruitment team.

Apologies:   Lewis, Melksham, Harmes, Tyson

Edited May 29, 2017 by Deeoldfart
Typo

[Happeninghunts 7]

6 - Jones

5 - Garlett

4 - Hibberd

3 - Oliver

2 - Hannan

1- Melksham

[dieter 3,325]

6 Garlett

5 Oliver

4 Hibberd

3 Jones

2 Watts

1 Lewis

[Demi Dee 578]

4 hours ago, Deeoldfart said:

6.  Jones  -  Led from the front and turned the game.

5.  Garlett  -  Excellent small forward game with goals and pressure.  Probably best game for the Dees.

4.  Hibberd  -  Has become a mainstay of our defence.

3.  Oliver  -  Another top-notch performance.  Not far off being the clearance king of the comp.

2.  Frost  -  Held (arguably) the best KPF in the game and is becoming a weapon off HB.

1.  Hannan  -  X factor anf growing in confidence each week.  Another tick for our recruitment team.

Apologies:   Lewis, Melksham, Harmes, Tyson

I'm also loving what Frost is bringing to the table. However, it was our midfield's ability to deny GCS forward entries that helped Frost keep Lynch quiet in the second half. However, his trajectory is looking positive. 

[rolling fog 1,207]

6 - Jones 

5 - Jeffy

4 - Hibberd

3 - Oliver

2 - Hannan

1 - Tyson

Apologies to Watts, Pedo, Frost and Melky

[ProperDee 1,698]

Voting is very subjective and people are always,looking to give their favourite a vote but I see Oliver didn't rate a single vote with some? Either I was watching the wrong game or know nothing about footy. The Brownlow votes will probably be 3. Jones, 2 Oliver, 1. Garlett but wouldn't be surprised to see Oliver get the 3.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,693]

I'm glad my votes are too late to be included because my viewing platform was worse than TV - it was streaming on my phone. But I guess that's better than nothing.

6 - Garlett

5 - Jones

4 - Melksham

3 - Oliver

2 - Hibberd

1 - Lewis

Watts and Tyson were also in consideration.