Saints v Dees Rd 1

[brendan 3,437]

Lol at us getting ahead of ourselves, what the hell would Gary Lyon know these days, and even if they are getting ahead of themselves I don't care as long as they can back it up need a bit of arrogance to become a good side 

[Watts Jurrah Dunn? 735]

I think Goodwin will opt for fit NQR's like Harmes and Neal-Bullen over underdone regulars like Tyson and Kent.

We've heard Roos say several times they rushed Brayshaw back from his knee in Round 2 last year against Essendon.  We lost the match and he never regained the match fitness due to the concussions in the VFL.  I think the FD have that decision fresh in their memories and we'll see Tyson, Kent, Hibberd and Frost in about round 3 or 4.

[John Crow Batty 8,864]

I am really hoping for a big effort to bury once and for ever this emabarrasing losing streak. Don't want to see another Harlem Globetrotters Vs Washington Generals game.

Edited March 21, 2017 by america de cali

[greenmachine 21]

worried about this game they always seem to go up a gear vs us

 

[rjay 24,929]

3 hours ago, stevethemanjordan said:

Tyson will not be picked for Saturday's game and here is why:

- Positionally speaking, he offers the least when compared to most of our mids and given he's played one awful JLT match and one Casey game in which he hardly dominated, I'm not sure why everyone thinks he's a lock for round 1. He is both out of form and underdone and is competing against a young midfield brigade who have had full summers and played the majority of the JLT with at least one really good performance.

- We don't need another slow two-way running ball extractor injected into an already fairly one-paced midfield against a fast St Kilda side on a fast deck. Especially when he has no form behind him.

- Tyson would have been a lock a couple of years ago in this particular position due to the lack of depth and talent our midfield had. Clearly we're a completely different midfield and it's now our strength.

I honestly don't know why most have him locked. 

It will be nearly as big a mistake leaving Dom out as it is putting Spencer in...

Our midfield on JLT form comprises of Oliver, Gawn and some inconsistent support performances.

You are getting way ahead of yourself if you think our midfield is up to scratch without Tyson...

[Wiseblood 24,637]

If deemed fit enough to play, Tyson, Kent and Garlett should all be automatic inclusions.  They make the side better.

I'm still very skittish about the potential selection of Spencer.  I don't think he'll suit the ground or the style of play we want at all, not to mention the time he takes away from Gawn in the ruck, plus I don't really rate Gawn as a forward.

It will be fascinating to see selection on Thursday night.

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

14 minutes ago, rjay said:

It will be nearly as big a mistake leaving Dom out as it is putting Spencer in...

Our midfield on JLT form comprises of Oliver, Gawn and some inconsistent support performances.

You are getting way ahead of yourself if you think our midfield is up to scratch without Tyson...

Viney's first and second games were fine.

Jones, Lewis, Oliver, Salem and Viney have had uninterrupted summers. Brayshaw and Petracca will roll through there.

I just don't see Tyson making the team based on what I said earlier.

 

[rjay 24,929]

9 hours ago, stevethemanjordan said:

Viney's first and second games were fine.

Jones, Lewis, Oliver, Salem and Viney have had uninterrupted summers. Brayshaw and Petracca will roll through there.

I just don't see Tyson making the team based on what I said earlier.

 

He may not but he will be missed.

Viney for one plays much better footy when Tyson is around...and he's (Viney) struggled this preseason. Needs to pull the finger out.

Edited March 21, 2017 by rjay

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Tyson looked like a young Pendlebury when he came to the club a few years ago but he hasn't really progressed. His decision making is quite poor, I have him in the best 20 to 30, no lock for best 22.

[Demons11 7,025]

4 hours ago, stevethemanjordan said:

Tyson will not be picked for Saturday's game and here is why:

- Positionally speaking, he offers the least when compared to most of our mids and given he's played one awful JLT match and one Casey game in which he hardly dominated, I'm not sure why everyone thinks he's a lock for round 1. He is both out of form and underdone and is competing against a young midfield brigade who have had full summers and played the majority of the JLT with at least one really good performance.

- We don't need another slow two-way running ball extractor injected into an already fairly one-paced midfield against a fast St Kilda side on a fast deck. Especially when he has no form behind him.

- Tyson would have been a lock a couple of years ago in this particular position due to the lack of depth and talent our midfield had. Clearly we're a completely different midfield and it's now our strength.

I honestly don't know why most have him locked. 

You're kidding aren't you???? The kid is a star.  He was our 2nd best mid last year behind Viney 

Edited March 21, 2017 by Demons11

[picket fence 17,170]

We have lost 14 straight vs Aints, We are playing at Shitihad!  I am not confident about our iffy backline, but having said, that the game will be won ( or lost out of the center!) I am tipping us by the narrowest of margins 1 point  but with some skepticism!

Aints are a good team! Dare I say it almost season defining game!!

 

Edited March 21, 2017 by picket fence

[brendan 3,437]

Anyone watch the raise hell video got in an email, got me pumped for Saturday 

[Wells 11 5,406]

4 minutes ago, picket fence said:

We have lost 14 straight vs Aints, We are playing at Shitihad!  I am not confident about our iffy backline, but having said, that the game will be won ( or lost out of the center!) I am tipping us by the narrowest of margins 1 point  but with some skepticism!

Aints are a good team! Dare I say it almost season defining game!!

 

It does feel big doesn't it. Round one always feels that way,  but we're also  playing another side who may be battling for the same ladder spot. Huge 14 game hoodoo to break, Goodys first regular season game a the helm with us and Vineys first as co captain. So...re season defining.... If we win I agree, if not I'll scoff at it. 

[Engorged Onion 10,215]

Season defining eh? I love this site, and at times it's amusing (Stevetheman and ProDees little flamewar for example) but bloody hell, the amount of handwringing blows my little mind out the back of my head. Yep, if we lose to the Saints, Goodwin, the coaching staff will effing pack it in eh? That's it, here is concrete evidence that we are ahead of ourselves etc etc. As a supporter  a win might make you feel good, a loss might make you feel shite, but to think that the professional outfit that is the 2017 MFC model would buy into that [censored] means you're still thinking about this as a prepubescent snot nosed kid would -  about their first dance or first farrk with someone and how it will impact on their life... 

[Engorged Onion 10,215]

4 minutes ago, brendan said:

Anyone watch the raise hell video got in an email, got me pumped for Saturday 

Great, what a little gem of a video - mind, has anyone mentioned that we STILL don't have a back of jumper sponsor yet?

[John Crow Batty 8,864]

7 minutes ago, brendan said:

Anyone watch the raise hell video got in an email, got me pumped for Saturday 

I'll watch it after the game but won't bother if we lose.

Edited March 21, 2017 by america de cali

[brendan 3,437]

Anyone savvy enough to put the video up

[Demons11 7,025]

20 minutes ago, brendan said:

Anyone watch the raise hell video got in an email, got me pumped for Saturday 

It is very good 

[Deeoldfart 8,033]

31 minutes ago, brendan said:

Anyone savvy enough to put the video up

Here it is:  Season 2017 is here

I love it ......... just wish it was longer

[demoniac 1,333]

Video fairly average.

I am cautiously optimistic re Rnd 1 but they burned us on the outside last year. Hibberd's run will be missed. Hopefully Kent and Garlett are fit and in the 22. We look better on paper than the Saints. Anyway its Rnd 1 so hope springs eternal!

[puntkick 325]

I hope that we are sending someone with some balls down to Adelehad Stadium to inspect the surface before we commit to playing there Saturday and risking our players on the new surface.

Meanwhile Richmond,( Carlton ) Collingwood, Hawthorn,(Essendon ) get to play on their home ground round 1 !

[Akum 2,660]

2 hours ago, Danelska said:

Season defining eh? I love this site, and at times it's amusing (Stevetheman and ProDees little flamewar for example) but bloody hell, the amount of handwringing blows my little mind out the back of my head. Yep, if we lose to the Saints, Goodwin, the coaching staff will effing pack it in eh? That's it, here is concrete evidence that we are ahead of ourselves etc etc. As a supporter  a win might make you feel good, a loss might make you feel shite, but to think that the professional outfit that is the 2017 MFC model would buy into that [censored] means you're still thinking about this as a prepubescent snot nosed kid would -  about their first dance or first farrk with someone and how it will impact on their life... 

Agree in general. If we turn in any sort of reasonable performance, this is probably the game that winning or losing means the least for our prospects for the season.

On the other hand, would be hugely frustrating to lose in exactly the same way as every time before. Let's at least show that we've learned something.

[Demon Disciple 12,141]

14 minutes ago, puntkick said:

I hope that we are sending someone with some balls down to Adelehad Stadium to inspect the surface before we commit to playing there Saturday and risking our players on the new surface.

Meanwhile Richmond,( Carlton ) Collingwood, Hawthorn,(Essendon ) get to play on their home ground round 1 !

Don't complain about the draw, we've got a pretty good one this year. Could've definitely been a lot worse

 

[Demon Jack 6,911]

Why the Tyson hate? Despite a slow start, he was superb for pretty much all of last year. 

[What 18,810]

19 minutes ago, Demon Jack said:

Why the Tyson hate? Despite a slow start, he was superb for pretty much all of last year. 

Was about to ask the same thing.. some ridiculous posts in this thread, wow.

Tyson is a gun and will be one of the first picked each week.