My 3 word player analysis V Carlton

[joeboy 3,166]

Jones - gave his all

Vince - not a defender

Tyson - prolific possession waster

Viney - couldn't get involved

Gawn - had little influence

Hogan - kick the goals!

Kent - frustrating to watch

Bugg - a limited player

vandenBerg - not a forward

Watts - hates the wet

Stretch - little to commend

O.McDonald - continued to impress

T.McDonald - outstanding all game

Weidemann - light years away

Hunt - gave a damn

Jetta - great before injury

Petracca - occasionally lost focus

Brayshaw - constantly looked lost

Oliver - has no engine

Frost - hold your breath

Michie - signed death warrant

Neal-Bullen - no redeeming quality

 

[Deemented Are Go! 3,683]

MFC - don't deserve finals.

 

 

 

 

 

yet

[DeeZee 7,399]

Jones tried but fumbly, lacked skill

[Buzzy 992]

Tyson was so frustrating today.  You summed him up well.

Hogan...  When will he kick the important goals.  His marking was so good, but it's almost at a point where you'd second guess kicking it to him in the 50, knowing he probably won't finish it.  His field kicking has also been average this year at best.  He should realistically ask for $700K tops and be happy he's getting that.  Doubt that'll happen though.

Insipid performance Dees!  Our low footy IQ was on display for all to see.

[ickey_11 145]

I think you are spot on with Bernie! this is why they want Hibberdt

[Bang Bang Bang 5,826]

Pretty good assessment this week joeboy. Tyson's stats look good but I thought he was absolutely terrible after a good month. That speculative shot he missed in the third quarter with three players free close to goal was unforgivable. 

Vince is terrible in defence. If Luke Beveridge was coach he'd probably be dropped next week. 2017, he needs to go back to the guts where he won a B&F.

[Bobby McKenzie 2,385]

21 minutes ago, Sylvia Saint said:

Pretty good assessment this week joeboy. Tyson's stats look good but I thought he was absolutely terrible after a good month. That speculative shot he missed in the third quarter with three players free close to goal was unforgivable. 

Vince is terrible in defence. If Luke Beveridge was coach he'd probably be dropped next week. 2017, he needs to go back to the guts where he won a B&F.

Bit tough on Michie Joeboy. 20 possessions at 90 per cent is hardly signing his death warrant.He at least gave a damn today.

[Maldonboy38 6,403]

Tyson - first option please. 

Petracca - error-riddled talent 

Hogan - goal kicking yips. 

N Jones - tried but average

Wiedeman - little defensive ability  

Kent - what a shocker

Gawn - surprisingly poor game

Watts -  a mere shadow

TMac - steady and reliable

OMac - good with errors

Jetta - outstanding, brave, effective

Hunt - decision flawed effectiveness 

Michie - in wrong position

ANB - fumbly, poor decisions

Viney - weak, fumbly, lazy

Frost - error riddled dash

Oliver - some atrocious decisions

Vandedberg - hardly touched ball

Bugg - unpressured atrocious skills

Stretch - unpressured atrocious skills

Brayshaw - did he play?

 

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

Melbourne Football Club - Jesus F***in' Christ!!!!!!

[buck_nekkid 5,876]

At the start of the game, Kent was in the city end goal square, already limping.  Why did we carry him into the game ffs?  Looked like his ankle was shot, and he struggled to run even at the first bounce.

where did Jesse start?  Down back somewhere?

[ox_5 163]

TOO MANY PASSENGERS

[rjay 24,943]

35 minutes ago, Maldonboy38 said:

Tyson - first option please. 

 

 

Not sure if you were at the game but the couple of times he got caught, one glaringly in the 3rd Q there were no options ahead or either side of him.

I think it told a bit about how we played today that pretty much the whole team was in the back half and no one worked up to at least give him a let out kick on the wing.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,396]

Read the newspapers/

[beelzebub 23,380]

Didn't turn up

[Return to Glory 8,443]

Just got back. Hunt - clearly our best.

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,841]

Nineteen eighty six?

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,841]

3 hours ago, Sylvia Saint said:

Pretty good assessment this week joeboy. Tyson's stats look good but I thought he was absolutely terrible after a good month. That speculative shot he missed in the third quarter with three players free close to goal was unforgivable. 

Vince is terrible in defence. If Luke Beveridge was coach he'd probably be dropped next week. 2017, he needs to go back to the guts where he won a B&F.

I agree in so far as I'm not sure that Bernie is that suited to being a full time defender, though I think he pinch hits OK down there at times and is a good long kick out from full back.

But I'm not sure that he still has it in him to play on ball all day.  It would have been worth giving him a crack on ball in spurts today in a tagging role on Crisps, although Patrick could well have destroyed Bernie, the way they were both playing.

I really love Bernie and what he has done for the club since his arrival, but I fear that his best footy may now be behind him (would love him to prove me wrong).  Just my view, but I think he'd be best used in the forward line, as he has great goal sence and a great hoof on him.  He could be used sparingly in the middle in bursts when we need a bit of impact there 

[The Stewster 220]

Vince - career worst form!

[1 red eye 1 blue eye 771]

Isn't it embarrassing

[Demon Jack 6,920]

2 hours ago, The Stewster said:

Vince - career worst form!

Seems a shadow of the player he was in the opening half of this year. I'm sure he'll respond next year and but it's certainly been a disappointing drop in form. Hopefully we can land Hibberd over the pre-season so Bernie can move back into the midfield considering he seems rather incompetent as a defender.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,054]

4 hours ago, Return to Glory said:

Just got back. Hunt - clearly our best.

Can't agree.  Jetta was BOG by a mile for us. 

[Gator 17,381]

Still very young

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,811]

15 hours ago, buck_nekkid said:

At the start of the game, Kent was in the city end goal square, already limping.  Why did we carry him into the game ffs?  Looked like his ankle was shot, and he struggled to run even at the first bounce.

where did Jesse start?  Down back somewhere?

At the opening bounce and after many (but not all) goals we start with an extra forward running from the defensive side of the centre square. Hogan was the designated forward at the opening bounce.

It's a tactic I quite like. 

 

[nutbean 8,838]

15 hours ago, rjay said:

Not sure if you were at the game but the couple of times he got caught, one glaringly in the 3rd Q there were no options ahead or either side of him.

I think it told a bit about how we played today that pretty much the whole team was in the back half and no one worked up to at least give him a let out kick on the wing.

Too static with not enough intelligent running.

[ArtificialWisdom 4,045]

13 hours ago, The Stewster said:

Vince - career worst form!

An example should be made of him this week. As was with Watts last year. Dropping him for the last game may just be the reminder he and the other senior players need going into pre-season. Right now he is not deserving of a spot over a number of others.