Changes next week v The Saints

[What 18,810]

Wonder if Riewoldt will play next week? He wouldn't have played today with that calf injury if it wasn't Maddies match

[Forest Demon 4,681]

In - Grimes, Michie or other hardened mid like Newton or Riley

Out - JKH, ANB

I want a win. Grimes has had a good year apart from injury, and one more hardened body in as well for me.

Edited July 19, 2015 by Forest Demon

[Roger Mellie 4,103]

Yes he did but he attacked the game all be it turned it over a lot. We're not playing finals and have an easy draw, I'd like to see him get a run of games. Others have had their chances. He manages to find himself in space with the ball. Needs to work on awareness and disposal. Has potential.

I agree. To me it looks like they're trying to curb his instincts a little and he's caught between what he wants to do versus what he's required to do.

The only way he'll get the balance is with more game time and it won't be through lack of trying. Whether that's in the seniors or Casey is the question. I think he has a bit to offer.

[Pates 9,660]

Interestingly I actaully think Dawes is doing quite well in his second ruck role, he worked hard today and did a lot of team acts. Although he got smashed in the hitouts Gawn did some good things around the ground, tells me he is growing as a player.

I reckon the younger players need a bit of a spell, ANB or Stretch probably one of the first on the block for me. If Toumpas put in a good performance for Casey he should come in.

[Neitz the Great 555]

Outs: JKH (needs to find form at Casey), ANB (Needs a rest)

Ins: Grimes, Hunt (Replaces JKH as that small, quick, crumbing forward - this is provided the coaches think he's ready)

Stretch as sub

[Little Goffy 14,645]

I think we will need to add a little more attacking potential to our midfield, which to me says Newton in.

I'm also one of the few, it seems, who still think Grimes has something to offer.

Those two in for a couple of the lower performing or tired kids. Possibly and/or Toumpas in. Just to annoy the haters.

Going to be interesting to see where McDonald ends up next week, too.

[Skuit 10,031]

Like for like for me. No point bringing Grimes back in in my mind unless he can rotate in the middle. If the kids need a spell, then first and foremost mids in Michie etc. to replace. Grimes for Garland or Lamumba alone if we're that keen for his inclusion.

[whatwhat say what 22,948]

Grimes has been playing as a tagger at Casey hasn't he?

Might be a chance to run through the midfield in that mode, as opposed to sweeping off half-back.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

Brayshaw has struggled the past two weeks. I'm wondering if he could use a week off to recharge the batteries? Not playing at Casey but just taking a break. He's so good it's easy to forget that he's a first-year player and isn't really at the level same level of fitness as the older players.

JKH struggled a bit and was subbed off. He might be in line for a break too.

We've got three guys who are basically in there to get the feel of the game in Stretch, Harmes and ANB. None of them are in the side because they are the best available. Any of them could be removed without any great loss of impact.

That gives us a heap of room to reward whoever is playing well at Casey. I'd love to see Hunt get a run in the FP, but he might struggle. That being said he's at least as ready physically as Stretch was when he got the nod. Riley has been playing well as well, and his aggression could be a good addition against a young Saints outfit. Jamar of course is dominating at VFL level and could get recalled any time. I don't see Salem or Kent getting in after long lay-offs. They will need to work themselves back up at Casey.

We also have to factor in the fact that we won. You generally don't make drastic changes to a winning side. Should be interesting.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

I still question Michie's ability at AFL level. He's really good at stoppages in the VFL but I haven't seen him transition smoothly into the middle for us, his lack of versatility makes it hard for us to play him.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

what about Newton? Thought he was good for us at the start of the year, doesn't get a lot of possess over 20 but always scores 1 or 2 goals.

[Matt Demon 1,482]

Wouldn't mind seeing Hunt debut.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

I still question Michie's ability at AFL level. He's really good at stoppages in the VFL but I haven't seen him transition smoothly into the middle for us, his lack of versatility makes it hard for us to play him.

The thing I like about Michie is that he seems to be solid in every aspect of the game. He doesn't have anything spectacular about him, but he's calm and capable most of the time. He very rarely makes the sort of rage-inducing mistakes we see from MacDonald, Grimes or Toumpas.

[Fat Tony 5,272]

Grimes in for Neal-Bullen and Hunt for JKH.

[pitmaster 3,578]

Brayshaw copped a whack last week and was quiet today. I agree with those who think he is ready for a spell.

JKH struggled and is not as fast as he thinks he is. He is likely to miss but if Roos did not change a losing team last week two changes would be about the limit this week.

Ins; Newton for forward impact and Grimes for a hard(er) body.

[Earl Hood 6,101]

Time to have a good look at Fitzy, Mitchie, Riley, the Toump and Grimes over the next 4 weeks or so. We need to make some tough decisions end of year. So let's rotate some people through.

[monoccular 17,575]

Salem back??

No way. Not ready. Would be handy were he fit though.

[Skuit 10,031]

Grimes has been playing as a tagger at Casey hasn't he?

Might be a chance to run through the midfield in that mode, as opposed to sweeping off half-back.

Tagging seems to be one thing we have under control. Viney underrated with the scalps he's taken this year. Gone the days of McKenzie.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Time to have a good look at Fitzy, Mitchie, Riley, the Toump and Grimes over the next 4 weeks or so. We need to make some tough decisions end of year. So let's rotate some people through.

I reckon we've seen enough of them - next 4 weeks may see the end of some careers.

[Moonshadow 17,677]

MJones, Bail and Terlich in.

Relax, we've got this...

[picket fence 17,530]

Interestingly I actaully think Dawes is doing quite well in his second ruck role, he worked hard today and did a lot of team acts. Although he got smashed in the hitouts Gawn did some good things around the ground, tells me he is growing as a player.

I reckon the younger players need a bit of a spell, ANB or Stretch probably one of the first on the block for me. If Toumpas put in a good performance for Casey he should come in.

I thought Chris Dawes would have pleased the Coaching fraternity today! Did a lot of "Grunt Work" opened up play and had some crucial possessions! Also took a couple of marks! A very good game for a somewhat "Maligned " player on this forum!

[picket fence 17,530]

Also, Riley in for anyone of the younger brigade looking tired! JKH maybe!??

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,654]

I think we will need to add a little more attacking potential to our midfield, which to me says Newton in.

I'm also one of the few, it seems, who still think Grimes has something to offer.

Those two in for a couple of the lower performing or tired kids. Possibly and/or Toumpas in. Just to annoy the haters.

Going to be interesting to see where McDonald ends up next week, too.

Think you will find many of us see a future in the red and blue.

We just go around posting ten times a week on how he is finished, like some 'supporters' who do good impersonations of a scratched record

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

MJones, Bail and Terlich in.

Relax, we've got this...

***Shudders***

[picket fence 17,530]

Think you will find many of us see a future in the red and blue.

We just go around posting ten times a week on how he is finished, like some 'supporters' who do good impersonations of a scratched record

Are u reffering to Mc Donald? Toumpas? or Both