The Trade/Draft Rumour Mill

[DeeSpencer 26,083]

one finals win?

I'm referring to 2006. And of course what I'd give for a final right now!

Just saying the Daniher years culminated in 1 finals win and left Dean Bailey in 2008 with a senior playing group of McDonald Bruce, Green, Moloney and Davey. Throw in a chunk of debt and poor facilities.

Then people describe the recruiting of one particular player or the retirement of McDonald as the problem. Bad decisions sure, but not a drop on the surface of a bigger mess.

[Dees2014 2,377]

IMO you underestimate how difficult it is to play in a diabolical side, particularly at half forward. Sylvia will be a star at Freo because the ball will be in their forward half more than 25-30% of the time.

Judging the two on average Supercoach points per year, which IMO is a very good objective measure, shows the two are close, with Sylvia having a slight edge.

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pu-melbourne-demons--colin-sylvia

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pu-adelaide-crows--bernie-vince

It will be interesting to see how Vince goes in a poor side and I hope you are right.

Edit: Formating

Well Tony, let's hope we are not a poor side next year. Most of us on here are anticipating with competent coaching and leadership we will at least be a competitive mid list combination. Some of us (like me) think we may even sneak into the 8. We certainly will be very much better than last year (which wouldn't be hard admittedly).

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

As a player, I think Sylvia will be a loss. I think he'll do really well at Freo.

As a player type, I think Vince will perhaps offer more to us than Sylvia.

That said, I would've liked to have retained Sylvia and got Vince, Cross, Tyson, pick 9 and Michie.

Quite simply, our midfield is coming from a very long way behind the pack. And we need quality mids/half backs/half forwards.

[beelzebub 23,383]

Im quite frankly glad Sylvia has gone. His parting words indicate to me he was never capable of realising his ability at Melbourne. Its as though he doesnt respect Melbourne and never has, but instantly respects Freo. careful what you wish for....lol

Bernie...still a lad, actually has a much greater work ethos. Cross has a fantastic attitude. Dont know enough about Michie but its quite likely he'll grab the opportunity to play with gusto.

if theres a singularity about the trading its to get decent footballers who work hard, all day. What a change it will be.

[Vitamin Dee 903]

Personally, I think Colin's lack of defensive running will be exposed on the larger ground.

[Ungarie boy 233]

Just saying the Daniher years culminated in 1 finals win and left Dean Bailey in 2008 with a senior playing group of McDonald Bruce, Green, Moloney and Davey. .

Not sure how he managed a Grandfinal, with just "1 finals win", Daniher is clearly a genuis!

[olisik 4,060]

Question- Any chance our pick 40 would be a pick 37 or 38 if a few teams like GWS pass some picks due to only wanting to use 3?

[jnrmac 20,189]

Not sure how he managed a Grandfinal, with just "1 finals win", Daniher is clearly a genuis!

You might want to look up 'culminated' in the dictionary

[Dees2014 2,377]

Yes quite possible, but I doubt it would make all that much difference.

[PJ_12345 1,098]

Question- Any chance our pick 40 would be a pick 37 or 38 if a few teams like GWS pass some picks due to only wanting to use 3?

Fat chance as they would have tried to something them for a lower pick and historically I don't think anyone has passed that low, but you never know!

[PJ_12345 1,098]

Question- Any chance our pick 40 would be a pick 37 or 38 if a few teams like GWS pass some picks due to only wanting to use 3?

Fat chance as they would have tried to something them for a lower pick and historically I don't think anyone has passed that low, but you never know!

Actually you might be onto something! http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-10-28/draft-numbers-set-to-fall

[dee-luded 2,959]

I think the thing people need to remember about Junior being axed and the angst that ensued is that we wouldn't have Tom McDonald if he'd stayed. Yes, it was handled very badly and led to a great deal of bad blood between the senior players and the management, but he was 33, he looked to be breaking down and we needed to clear space on the list for some young players. His spot was taken by our last live draft pick in Tom McDonald, who could be on his way to being an AA CHB. I still think it was the right call to make. It could have been done a lot better simply through better communication from all parties, but it was still the best call for the team.

breaking down, or made to appear that way??? as the brains trust steered us too deeply into the youth alone push.

No I think Jnr could have gone on playing & leading the Club for 2 more. I would have traded Green or Davey or one of the other bigger names out, for a pick & taken in a hard headed player from somewhere. (the hawks pelchen model)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Melbourne_Football_Club_season#Squad_for_2011_season

[mauriesy 7,357]

It will be interesting to see how Vince goes in a poor side and I hope you are right.

I'm hoping that Vince (among others) will be one of the catalysts to drag Melbourne up from being a 'poor side'. Clearly Sylvia couldn't, or didn't want to, hence why he went somewhere else.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

breaking down, or made to appear that way??? as the brains trust steered us too deeply into the youth alone push.

No I think Jnr could have gone on playing & leading the Club for 2 more. I would have traded Green or Davey or one of the other bigger names out, for a pick & taken in a hard headed player from somewhere. (the hawks pelchen model)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Melbourne_Football_Club_season#Squad_for_2011_season

He was having some nasty problems with his hamstrings that year. I know I'm not the only one who thought he was on his last legs and should make the call himself. If he had done that, or the club had handled things better with pushing him we might have kept him on as a development coach/mentor for the young group Bailey was bringing in, which would have been a huge advantage.

[Demon Jack 6,930]

Interesting to see that the MFC website has posted the draft prospect article on Matt Crouch. I don't recall them doing this for any other likely draftees. Maybe the club is considering him as an option for number 9.

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2013-10-29/draft-prospect-matt-crouch

[olisik 4,060]

Interesting to see that the MFC website has posted the draft prospect article on Matt Crouch. I don't recall them doing this for any other likely draftees. Maybe the club is considering him as an option for number 9.

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2013-10-29/draft-prospect-matt-crouch

I saw that to. Maybe its to bait Collingwood into taking him at 6 instead of 10

[Machsy 2,858]

Interesting to see that the MFC website has posted the draft prospect article on Matt Crouch. I don't recall them doing this for any other likely draftees. Maybe the club is considering him as an option for number 9.

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2013-10-29/draft-prospect-matt-crouch

I very very very much doubt the recruiting dept has been in touch with the digital media dept on this.

It's more a lack of content at this time of year, and it's possible Crouch could be taken around pick 9 (most probably 10 picks later).

[demonoid 317]

Clisby magner and stark delisted leaving us with 4 picks on senior list. One reserved for psd imo and four new rookies

[demonoid 317]

Sorry here's the link

http://m.melbournefc.com.au/news/2013-10-29/melbournes-2014-list

[demonoid 317]

Clisby magner and stark delisted leaving us with 4 picks on senior list. One reserved for psd imo and four new rookies

sorry again clisby upgraded and taggert magner and stark delisted

[binman 43,815]

sorry again clisby upgraded and taggert magner and stark delisted

Phew, i hope Clisby isn't a DL regular! I was going to say he'd be unlucky to be cut given his form in the handful of games he played

[binman 43,815]

sorry again clisby upgraded and taggert magner and stark delisted

Iron Man not playing footy? He'll be annoyed, but perhaps he can become a major sponsor

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

12 gone out of a list of 44. It is a brutal sport. I'll never complain again that footballers are paid too much

(Unless Dan Nicholsons kicking doesn't improve over pre-season)

[Outside fifty 967]

Disappointed to see Taggert delisted. Thought the kid had some potential, still i've always been a crap judge of talent.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Just out.

http://www.scpaige.com.au/phantom-draft-october-edition/

The more i look into it the more i am falling for Freeman.

Quick, can use the footy well, find the goals, break lines and is already 85kgs!