Melbourne’s Mount Rushmore

[Demonland 72,217]

SEN have been choosing the all time best/favourite 4 players for every team over the lockdown period. 

Who makes your Mount Rushmore? 

 

[In Harmes Way 7,793]

Hard to argue those four

[dl4e 5,851]

Nietz instead of Stynes.

[Demon Disciple 12,160]

Dominance in time of prosperity is one thing, dominance in times of extreme hardship is something else.

Robbie the greatest demon for me.

[rjay 24,940]

Checker Hughes?

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,808]

Four Cordners. 

 

(Sounds like a TV show with a head cold.)

[Sir Why You Little 37,046]

Frank Adams is stiff

6 Flags

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Clint Bizzell, Shane Valenti, Phil Read and Bayley Fritsch in the forward line.

[Deemented Are Go! 3,680]

5 hours ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

Four Cordners. 

 

(Sounds like a TV show with a head cold.)

Post of the year...just brilliant ???

[tiers 2,840]

After Robbie and RDB does is matter?

[chook fowler 19,459]

Joe Gutnik

Cameron Schwab 

Mark Neeld 

Cuddles Connolly

Tom Scully 

[spirit of norm smith 16,468]

18 hours ago, chook fowler said:

Joe Gutnik

Cameron Schwab 

Mark Neeld 

Cuddles Connolly

Tom Scully 

That’s the crew of the titanic (perhaps harsh on Joe G) 

[daisycutter 29,616]

49 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

That’s the crew of the titanic (perhaps harsh on Joe G) 

i dunno, always wondered why he self reported over the salary cap fiasco when his own personal business ethics were so questionable 

[Pennant St Dee 13,190]

Checker Hughes - changed culture brought 4 flags and made us Demons

Norm - needs no explanation 

Robbie Flower- shining light through dark times along with god given football ability 

Jim Stynes - club stalwart on the ground and driving force behind the debt demolition, which sees we still exist 

Missing out

RDB - great player but can't single him out from those great sides, his coaching greatness was elsewhere 

Neiter - most games, most games as skipper and most goals 

 

[MyFavouriteMartian 572]

 

Mike Sheahan

Gazza Lyon

Dennis Commetti

Bobby Skilton

[DEE fence 5,018]

By era:

Warne-Smith- bias here, but until the 80's he was in all the top ten lists, 50 years after he played, Bunton, Coventry etc described him as their best opponent. Hard as nails and then there is his time as Chairman of Selectors working with Smith in the 50's

Barassi-Our Michael Voss but better. Obviously there is unanimous consent on this so i won't bore further...

Flower- Supremely skilled, lay down flush. Again consent on RF.

Stynes- Lion heart, what an amazing human. He could've the bloke from 'unbroken', just never gives up...

Smith and Hughes would obviously get gigs as coaches, I went players only.

Stiff: Many; Neitz, Adams, Allan La Fontaine - Captain of a hat trick of premierships ffs.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,808]

16 hours ago, DaisyDeeciple said:

By era:

Warne-Smith- bias here, but until the 80's he was in all the top ten lists, 50 years after he played, Bunton, Coventry etc described him as their best opponent. Hard as nails and then there is his time as Chairman of Selectors working with Smith in the 50's

Barassi-Our Michael Voss but better. Obviously there is unanimous consent on this so i won't bore further...

Flower- Supremely skilled, lay down flush. Again consent on RF.

Stynes- Lion heart, what an amazing human. He could've the bloke from 'unbroken', just never gives up...

Smith and Hughes would obviously get gigs as coaches, I went players only.

Stiff: Many; Neitz, Adams, Allan La Fontaine - Captain of a hat trick of premierships ffs.

I think you've identified the real problem. Mt Rushmore is just not suitable. We need something that allows greater representation. Something that would enable many more MFC luminaries to be chosen. Something like the Terracotta Warriors.

Mind you, a funerary tomb might send the wrong message.

[Laughing Goat 308]

Stynes: Greatest football story....Brownlow, 4 x Bluey's, 2 x AA, Hall of Fame & 244 consecutive games.....rediculous!

Flower: Super skilled in very difficult times but more importantly, loyal to the red & blue, Capt 81-87, 1 x Bluey, Hall of Fame & 2 x AA

Barassi: 6 Premierships, 2 Bluey's, Capt 60-64 & Hall of fame

Neitz: Capt 2000 - 08, 1 x Bluey, Coleman 02, 2 x AA, Hall of Fame & 7 time leading goal kicker

 

 

 

[faultydet 7,594]

Agree with those 4. Flower had no right to be as brave as he was with a build like that.

 

Injury probably stopped Schwarz and maybe even Jakovich being up for consideration. Amazing footballers early in their careers.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,226]

Smith, Barassi, La Fontaine, Flower

Edited June 5, 2020 by Dr. Gonzo

[daisycutter 29,616]

to me ivor warne-smith was the greatest demon of all time. Maybe not the greatest player (though pretty close).

his life was like something out of a boys' own almanac.....he did everything....literally

I won't go through all the detail......you can read for yourself at wikipedia - ivor warne-smith

 

no wonder norm smith had such success with a team of him, jimmy cardwell, Ivor warne-smith and checker hughes

Edited June 6, 2020 by daisycutter

[Sir Why You Little 37,046]

1 hour ago, daisycutter said:

to me ivor warne-smith was the greatest demon of all time. Maybe not the greatest player (though pretty close).

his life was like something out of a boys' own almanac.....he did everything....literally

I won't go through all the detail......you can read for yourself at wikipedia - ivor warne-smith

 

no wonder norm smith had such success with a team of him, jimmy cardwell, Ivor warne-smith and checker hughes

Yes, we could do with I.W. Smith right now

Quite a man. I miss the Ivor Warne doors at the Members Entrance...