Match Preview and Team Selection - Round 7

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

Pfft.......We will smash them like guitars...

[Garbo 1,559]

Goodwin confirmed in his interview that both hogan and petracca will be named but will have to pass a fitness test on Saturday 

[McQueen 17,867]

I'll wait for the final teams to be released tomorrow arvo before making a call on our chances.

No Hogan and Petracca will be a substantial blow to our arsenal.

Let's hope they pull up and can contribute to another win.

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

2 minutes ago, McQueen said:

I'll wait for the final teams to be released tomorrow arvo before making a call on our chances.

No Hogan and Petracca will be a substantial blow to our arsenal.

Let's hope they pull up and can contribute to another win.

I think Hogan will play. Would have been pretty sore during the week. His fitness levels should be ok you would think with the 2 games in the shortened period.

[sisso 2,588]

3 hours ago, pinkshark said:

My views on Goodwin are unaltered.  He is admirably and luckily bluffing his way through.  He is consistent only at inconsistency.  Results this weekend will prove this.    When we lose, its always in the same manner.  Over the top, out the back, Lever and McDonald looking stupid, inept forward entries to outmanned contests, exhausted from attack, and no energy and or structure to defend.  Week in week out.  This suggests he is not learning.  Just occupying, collecting a cheque, satisfying and fulfilling an ego and desire to one day be the coach of an AFL footy side.  Thus, it will be a loss this week and Goodwin, since taking over will have coached us to 16 wins and 16 losses.  In 5 weeks time the Jesse Hogan is returning to WA bandwagon will start rolling.  For make no mistake, if we are not at least two games above .500 in 5 weeks time then it will be obvious to all, pundits, Jackson, Bartlett, the board, that Goodwin is not cut out for it.  So, Goodwin's future head coaching career will be determined  by mid jun.  And so it should be.  He should be very worried.  

[DSP 1,488]

A must win, plain and simple. If tracc and hoges are both outs, we still have to find a way.

[Satyriconhome 10,880]

23 minutes ago, McQueen said:

I'll wait for the final teams to be released tomorrow arvo before making a call on our chances.

No Hogan and Petracca will be a substantial blow to our arsenal.

Let's hope they pull up and can contribute to another win.

Trac was fine at training this morning, train on Saturday to see if he can handball, mark etc, assume he will wear a guard

Hogan can train tomorrow and then Saturday, the fact he completed the game was a good sign, again though wait to see him run out on Sunday

Confirm what Goodwin said about Viney,  oustanding today, some pics tonight

Highlight today one on one battle between ANB and Nev Jetta, got a bit willing

Lot of emphasis today on contested work

Edited May 3, 2018 by Satyriconhome

[The Chazz 4,077]

10 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

Trac was fine at training this morning, train on Saturday to see if he can handball, mark etc, assume he will wear a guard

Hogan can train tomorrow and then Saturday, the fact he completed the game was a good sign, again though wait to see him run out on Sunday

Confirm what Goodwin said about Viney,  oustanding today, some pics tonight

Highlight today one on one battle between ANB and Nev Jetta, got a bit willing

Lot of emphasis today on contested work

I call BS on this.  He was always going to come back on - a rolled ankle can get needled up pretty quick when part way through a game, and a player can finish the game off.  It's the next morning when he wouldn't have been able to put any weight on it (after the juice wore off) that will be the test.

Personally, I wouldn't risk Hogan this week.  I'd bring in T Smith for him, and have the rotations of Smith/TMc/Weid/Gawn.

Will be just like Viney the following week.  Goody said the High Performance Team will have him ready for AFL footy, probably next week.  Well, given the track record of the High Performance Team, the player himself, and the opposition we will face (and where we face them), I'd sit Jack out for one more and bring him back against Carlton.

[Satyriconhome 10,880]

11 minutes ago, The Chazz said:

I call BS on this.  He was always going to come back on - a rolled ankle can get needled up pretty quick when part way through a game, and a player can finish the game off.  It's the next morning when he wouldn't have been able to put any weight on it (after the juice wore off) that will be the test.

Personally, I wouldn't risk Hogan this week.  I'd bring in T Smith for him, and have the rotations of Smith/TMc/Weid/Gawn.

Will be just like Viney the following week.  Goody said the High Performance Team will have him ready for AFL footy, probably next week.  Well, given the track record of the High Performance Team, the player himself, and the opposition we will face (and where we face them), I'd sit Jack out for one more and bring him back against Carlton.

The MFC fitness/medical/ High Performance whatever are not fans of jabs, they can mask an issue

With the track record we have of mow taking no risks, Hogan would not have been allowed back on, let's see if he trains Saturday and what training, assume he will be named tonight with Goody announcing it at Presser

And the track record, they can't foresee setbacks with 44 individual physiologies

Edited May 3, 2018 by Satyriconhome

[Diamond_Jim 12,686]

Another squad night and a bye at Casey so selections will not mean much until tomorrow night.

May test the theory of ... named other than on interchange.. definitely play etc. ( cannot recall if we ever decided that this is a rule or a convention).

[Lucifers Hero 40,509]

"Melbourne will name Christian Petracca and Jesse Hogan and are confident the important duo will be fit to take on St Kilda at Etihad Stadium on Sunday". ?

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/demons-optimistic-petracca-and-hogan-will-take-on-saints-20180503-p4zd4e.html

"The Demons are also planning on a return to AFL football for gun midfielder Jack Viney next week".

Not sure if the AFL for JV is poetic license by the journo or was said by Goodwin.  Either way, looking good! 

[ignition. 1,478]

Another great write-up Whispering Jack.

Edited May 3, 2018 by ignition.

[Earl Hood 6,141]

48 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

Trac was fine at training this morning, train on Saturday to see if he can handball, mark etc, assume he will wear a guard

Hogan can train tomorrow and then Saturday, the fact he completed the game was a good sign, again though wait to see him run out on Sunday

Confirm what Goodwin said about Viney,  oustanding today, some pics tonight

Highlight today one on one battle between ANB and Nev Jetta, got a bit willing

Lot of emphasis today on contested work

Dropped by at training briefly today. I noticed Fritsch working with the mids with Gawn and Filpovic rucking against each other in boundary throw in simulations with 4 blues against 4 yellows trying to take the tap outs. The usual suspects, Clarrie, Jones, Viney, Lewis, Tyson, Harmes on the inside but Fritsch was playing an outside receiver role in the sims so maybe he will spend some time up on the wing? 

This group then moved to the centre to do simulated centre hit outs. For some reason a bloke carried a large step ladder and set it up near the centre bounces. What for I could not fathom. Anyway on about the third simulated bounce and tap down Clarrie ran into the ladder receiving a handball in traffic. The ladder was duly removed from the field??

 

[picket fence 17,968]

1 hour ago, Wadda We Sing said:

Pfft.......We will smash them like guitars...

Ritchie Blackmore says HI!!

[Deemania since 56 6,763]

1 hour ago, DSP said:

A must win, plain and simple. If tracc and hoges are both outs, we still have to find a way.

Maybe the new bloodlines and their pace will see us through and bring the older hands into the game for a change.

[DubDee 26,302]

Bad feeling about this one.  I think we'll be flat about the 2 games in 5 days and we will be carrying a few sore lads.  Saints will be fired up after being hammered in the media again.

Hope I'm wrong

[hemingway 7,633]

47 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

The MFC fitness/medical/ High Performance whatever are not fans of jabs, they can mask an issue

With the track record we have of mow taking no risks, Hogan would not have been allowed back on, let's see if he trains Saturday and what training, assume he will be named tonight with Goody announcing it at Presser

And the track record, they can't foresee setbacks with 44 individual physiologies

That is good to hear regarding the philosophy of no jabs and no risks. 

Playing sore or injured has always been....well... a short-term response usually with long term consequences.

Nevertheless, I wonder about the wisdom of playing Hogan on the concrete like surface of the G Hard. 

Who are the key people on the Medical/HP team other than Missen.

 

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

10 minutes ago, Earl Hood said:

Dropped by at training briefly today. ......

This group then moved to the centre to do simulated centre hit outs. For some reason a bloke carried a large step ladder and set it up near the centre bounces. What for I could not fathom. Anyway on about the third simulated bounce and tap down Clarrie ran into the ladder receiving a handball in traffic. The ladder was duly removed from the field??

If anyone is looking for a definition of "a very Melbourne thing to do" I think we have a contender. 

[Diamond_Jim 12,686]

7 minutes ago, FarNorthernD said:

If anyone is looking for a definition of "a very Melbourne thing to do" I think we have a contender. 

yep.. one week the dog and then next.. the ladder....not as good as the Geelong star missing the bus all those years ago !!

[ProperDee 1,698]

2 hours ago, BigFez said:

Melbourne FC‏Verified account @melbournefc 26m26 minutes ago

More

Goodwin: Jack Viney will be available to play next week. The high performance team has prepared him for AFL footy.

If they can prepare about 16 others we’ll be a huge chance.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,010]

38 minutes ago, Earl Hood said:

Dropped by at training briefly today. I noticed Fritsch working with the mids with Gawn and Filpovic rucking against each other in boundary throw in simulations with 4 blues against 4 yellows trying to take the tap outs. The usual suspects, Clarrie, Jones, Viney, Lewis, Tyson, Harmes on the inside but Fritsch was playing an outside receiver role in the sims so maybe he will spend some time up on the wing? 

This group then moved to the centre to do simulated centre hit outs. For some reason a bloke carried a large step ladder and set it up near the centre bounces. What for I could not fathom. Anyway on about the third simulated bounce and tap down Clarrie ran into the ladder receiving a handball in traffic. The ladder was duly removed from the field??

 

I expect a Herald Sun story claiming that WorkSafe is investigating, the AFL has commissioned a secret inquiry (which Gill will deny) and that Oliver has engaged the services of Slater and Gordon. 

[nosoupforme 3,085]

I don't want to look too far into the future only the next 3 games. St Kilda, Gold coast away, , no Tom Lynch and Carlton at the G away.

Assuming we win the next 3 games that will make us 6 wins 3 losses and Viney not far away or has played in  maybe one or 2 of those  games. That would be a great start to the season and on track for a finals berth.     Why not?  It can happen.

[What 18,810]

 

 

Sounds promising.

[Redleg 41,934]

1 hour ago, Satyriconhome said:

 

Highlight today one on one battle between ANB and Nev Jetta, got a bit willing

 

Pity ANB can't do that in a match.

[chook fowler 19,694]

32 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

I expect a Herald Sun story claiming that WorkSafe is investigating, the AFL has commissioned a secret inquiry (which Gill will deny) and that Oliver has engaged the services of Slater and Gordon. 

Also have heard the AFL have settled a harrassment  case on behalf of Petraccas dogs who accuse a Club official of indecent acts. A confidentiality   clause has been activated after the payment of several kilos of eye fillet.