MFC injury list - 2015

[CHF 2,738]

Hunt is training so hopefully he is able to play VFL in a week or so. And where is ANB? Is he ready to go all of a sudden?

ANB played in the Casey 2's last week and went ok on 50% playing time from reports.

[Earl Hood 6,086]

ANB played in the Casey 2's last week and went ok on 50% playing time from reports.

Yes good point CHF he did play the development league and hopefully Hunt can gear up this week. Any idea how ANB went?

[Whispering_Jack 30,165]

Interesting comments in the Herald Sun Barometer: We look at every team after Round 4 and how they are shaping up in The Barometer

MELBOURNE

INJURIES

Jayden Hunt (back) 1-2 weeks

Christian Petracca (knee) season

Jack Trengove (foot) season

Sam Frost (foot) 4-6

Dean Kent (hamstring) 10-12 weeks

Neville Jetta (concussion) Test

ON THE BLOCK: Its hard to see Paul Roos making any forced changes after such a spirited win. Dean Kent will miss 10 to 12 weeks after he elected to have surgery on his injured hamstring. Jack Watts lifted his intensity after a disappointing performance against the Crows and laid four tackles along with 14 disposals and a goal.

ON THE CUSP: Jack Grimes was named best on ground for Casey in their loss to the Bulldogs, while Jimmy Toumpas gathered 28 touches and applied seven tackles. Toumpas for Kent would make sense, while Grimes has certainly done enough at VFL level.

ADAM BALDWINS FORECAST: While Melbournes win on Friday night surprised the competition, those within the walls of Demonland were quietly confident going into the match. The Demons now have the attacking weapons to compliment their pressure game and made Richmond look second rate. Jesse Hogan, Aaron vandenBerg, Christian Salem, Ben Jacobs and Viv Michie have changed the look of the side and even the most cynical Dees must acknowledge the worm has turned. Fremantle is one of the form sides of the competition, but as St Kilda proved last year, it can be done.

I don't know who this Ben Jacobs is but Ben Newton says "hello".

[Red and Bluebeard 2,084]

Interesting comments in the Herald Sun Barometer: We look at every team after Round 4 and how they are shaping up in The Barometer

I don't know who this Ben Jacobs is but Ben Newton says "hello".

Not to mention Adam Baldwin reading these forums ...

[spirit of norm smith 16,460]

I would like to see Max Gawn back to assist Jamar v Sandilands & Zac Clarke

[Lucifers Hero 39,817]

Ouch! 'Rookie Mitch White missed last rounds VFL due to a toe injury. He had an accident on the gym, where he dropped a 50kg dumbbell on his toe, which didnt tickle, he said'.

Understatement!

Extract from Misson report: Jetta to miss more than one.

In summary:

Sam Frost (fractured toe) 8 weeks

Jayden Hunt (back) 2 weeks

Neville Jetta (concussion) 1 week

Dean Kent (hamstring) 12 weeks

Christian Petracca (knee) season

Jack Trengove (foot) season

Jack Viney (fractured fibula) 2-3 weeks

Mitch White (toe) available

Looks like Frost will be out longer than expected. Impressed that White is available after dropping that 50kg on his toe!

[SaberFang 7,151]

Geez, if only White can deliver the goods as VDB has. Here's hoping!

[Jaded No More 68,916]

Viney already at just 2-3?

Good news.

[Demon Jack 6,909]

Jetta set to miss again

Can't be too careful I suppose.

Hopefully Neville pulls up ok for the Hawks clash next week.

Melbourne injury list: round six

Chris Dawes (calf) – test
Sam Frost (toe) – 4-6 weeks
Jayden Hunt (back) – available
Neville Jetta (concussion) – test
Dean Kent (hamstring) – 10 weeks
Christian Petracca (knee) – season
Jack Trengove (foot) – season
Jack Viney (fibula) – 2 weeks

[Bang Bang Bang 5,826]

It's a bit disappointing to see Frost still listed at 4-6.

[Sir Why You Little 37,039]

Jetta set to miss again

Can't be too careful I suppose.

Must have been a big whack.

No wonder Footballers from the 60's-90's are now having problems.

[jnrmac 20,080]

It's a bit disappointing to see Frost still listed at 4-6.

For a big toe injury...

[Stu_Dee 2]

Have to say I'm a bit confused with the concussion guidelines. Didn't that Adelaide player (forget who) get knocked out, carted off the field and then played the next week against us a few weeks ago? My understanding is that they judge the recovery by doing the concussion test that is judged on responses by the player taken from his baseline answers, is that correct? If so I think you may need to be look at Nev's baseline data?

[stuie 7,374]

Must have been a big whack.

No wonder Footballers from the 60's-90's are now having problems.

Have to say I'm a bit confused with the concussion guidelines. Didn't that Adelaide player (forget who) get knocked out, carted off the field and then played the next week against us a few weeks ago? My understanding is that they judge the recovery by doing the concussion test that is judged on responses by the player taken from his baseline answers, is that correct? If so I think you may need to be look at Nev's baseline data?

Nev's had a handful of concussions since Christmas, hence the conservative approach. It's not from just the one incident.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,396]

Have to say I'm a bit confused with the concussion guidelines. Didn't that Adelaide player (forget who) get knocked out, carted off the field and then played the next week against us a few weeks ago? My understanding is that they judge the recovery by doing the concussion test that is judged on responses by the player taken from his baseline answers, is that correct? If so I think you may need to be look at Nev's baseline data?

I thought Roos said a couple of weeks ago that Jetta had sufferers a couple of knocks over a short timeframe.

[Watts Jurrah Dunn? 735]

Given Bail and Jetta seem to get concussed running through the banner, why don't either of them wear a helmet? Just crazy.

[TheoX 1,222]

Given Bail and Jetta seem to get concussed running through the banner, why don't either of them wear a helmet? Just crazy.

Probably because there's no evidence to say they prevent concussion.

[Nasher 33,616]

Given Bail and Jetta seem to get concussed running through the banner, why don't either of them wear a helmet? Just crazy.

They don't help much, apparently.

[Sir Why You Little 37,039]

Helmets make it worse in many cases

The brain bounces around even more...

[poita 3,902]

Probably not a bad week to miss. Sydney aren't really blessed with quality small forwards, particularly if McGlynn doesn't play. Hawthorn on the other hand ...

[Watts Jurrah Dunn? 735]

Thanks guys. I find that really surprising. From memory Jetta's recent one was Howe sailing through for a mark and his knee glanced Jetta across the temple. Would have thought some padding there would have helped enormously.

[Stu_Dee 2]

Thanks guys. I find that really surprising. From memory Jetta's recent one was Howe sailing through for a mark and his knee glanced Jetta across the temple. Would have thought some padding there would have helped enormously.

I think the issue is more the "wobbling" of the brain rather than the actual impact, this is why a helmet may not help as you would still get the wobble if you know what I mean

[M C 221]

I think the issue is more the "wobbling" of the brain rather than the actual impact, this is why a helmet may not help as you would still get the wobble if you know what I mean

A helmet would make the impact longer though which would decrease the impulse. Then surely the brain would be 'wobbled' less?

[whatwhat say what 22,764]

with he and salem likely to miss too, we're looking pretty light on for defensive run.

perhaps this is toumpas' opportunity to come in and play a role as a rebounding flanker.

[Demon Disciple 12,130]

Must have been a big wack.

It was actually a result of Howe taking that high grab against Richmond. Poor Nev got the knee in the face and will now miss 2 games for being in the wrong place at the wrong time.