So, where to from here with pick 2?

[Bitter but optimistic 22,241]

Cross is very important in this equation. If we we get him it makes taking a kid more palatable. But, if we get him and a ready made (ie Sloane, Swallow) then, all of a sudden, we have a midfield. Then we'll see.

[drdrake 3,178]

Unfortunatly picking up Cross will cancel out thr Sylvia compo

No it won't, we can pick up Cross as a delisted free agent which means no compensation as his previous club has removed him ffrom their senior list.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Cross is very important in this equation. If we we get him it makes taking a kid more palatable. But, if we get him and a ready made (ie Sloane, Swallow) then, all of a sudden, we have a midfield. Then we'll see.

Cross might only be on the list for 12 months, the player at pick 2 needs to be a 10 year premiership player whether it be a fresh kid or one that has just started cooking.

I would hope and expect that it would have no bearing on the decision.

Edited September 24, 2013 by dandeeman

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,396]

Do we think Aish is a certainty? What would be the outcome on here if we took kelly?

If we do keep it Kelly is my choice.

[bing181 9,240]

Unfortunatly picking up Cross will cancel out thr Sylvia compo

Even if this was true, the primary determinant re compo is the terms of the contract (salary, length). It's why we got so much for Scully (OK, not FA, but similar principal), and so little for Moloney.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

If we do keep it Kelly is my choice.

Interested to hear your reasoning for this, as to me Kelly is the sort of player we don't need. Not saying you're wrong by any stretch, just curious.

[Arrow 1,257]

Pick 2 for Adams and pick 10.

Pick 10 to Collingwood for Heath Shaw and their second rounder.

Pick 20 and Collingwood second rounder on best available midfielder. Done

Edited September 24, 2013 by Demon Land 7

[dees64 104]

unless its ablett material,,,,dont give up a pick 2

[Maldonboy38 6,403]

So many variables and computations. The foundation stones for this draft/trade period are :

1.Our desperate need for a massive and immediate increase in midfield class and ability.

A ready-to-go primed midfielder (Swallow, Sloane etc...)

A young potential young midfielder (Aish etc...)

Watts being hinted as a midfielder

Cross as a possible DFA

2. The possible trade of Sylvia, Jamar and maybe Blease, Tapscott, others...

3. We need to look back and see Roos' history at the draft/trade.

How did he go about getting Richards, Shaw, Mattner, etc...? What did he let go to get them?

Players like Hanneberry, Luke Parker, Reid - what number were they drafted or were there other draft trades involved?

[jabberwocky 2,301]

unless its ablett material,,,,dont give up a pick 2

Yep.

Don't give up pick 2 unless it's for the best midfielder of all time.

[Ouch! 2,263]

Pick 10 to Collingwood for Heath Shaw and their second rounder.

Wow really? you think Shaw is worth a mid first round pick plus change?

I'd be amazed if Shaw gets traded for much more than a late second rounder,... he is 28 years old, has had injuries over the journey, and isn't the most solid character. I do rate him as a player when fit though, but no way he is that good.

[Little Richard 6,262]

I apologise if I've missed something but why do GWS have pick 10? All these deals involve pick 2 to GWS for Adams and pick 10...

[Roger Mellie 4,032]

I apologise if I've missed something but why do GWS have pick 10? All these deals involve pick 2 to GWS for Adams and pick 10...

They've activated a compensation pick (couldn't tell you which, probably traded from another club)

[olisik 4,060]

Did cremeri use the loophole to leave the bombers?

So we should get into tje ears of zaharakis

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,396]

Interested to hear your reasoning for this, as to me Kelly is the sort of player we don't need. Not saying you're wrong by any stretch, just curious.

To be honest I've never seen Aish or Kelly or any of them play. I'm only going on what I've read and heard, and how reliable is that...who knows. Have a good mate who coaches under 16's for a TAC side and says he goes alright. Under 16's is not 18's but all the coaches talk and watch lots of games of differant age groups. As we know early picks can go either way. There was a mindset that kids that are from WA or SA are more developed because they have already played against men, that hasn't always been the case. I hope we can land a player during trade week. Who ever we take I won't be rushing into an early judgement like the Wines/Toumpas debate that has raged on here.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Did cremeri use the loophole to leave the bombers?

So we should get into tje ears of zaharakis

No, he used the 'out of contract' loophole.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

To be honest I've never seen Aish or Kelly or any of them play. I'm only going on what I've read and heard, and how reliable is that...who knows. Have a good mate who coaches under 16's for a TAC side and says he goes alright. Under 16's is not 18's but all the coaches talk and watch lots of games of differant age groups. As we know early picks can go either way. There was a mindset that kids that are from WA or SA are more developed because they have already played against men, that hasn't always been the case. I hope we can land a player during trade week. Who ever we take I won't be rushing into an early judgement like the Wines/Toumpas debate that has raged on here.

Fair enough - to be honest I'm merely going by much of what you have written above. Seen some clips, read plenty of stuff but nothing more than that. The only assumption I can make is that many believe Kelly will be purely an outside mid, while Aish has the ability to win his own footy as well as being an outside running type as well, something that stands out to me a little more.

I just hope that whoever we choose is the right player for our club going forward.

[Little Richard 6,262]

They've activated a compensation pick (couldn't tell you which, probably traded from another club)

Ah okay, thanks!

[spirit of norm smith 16,462]

Pick 2...

option 1 - James Aish (ND#2)

or option 2 - trade ND#2 to Suns for David Swallow (Suns get Scharenberg)

or option 3 - trade ND#2 to Giants for Taylor Adams and Pick 10. (Giants get Scharenberg)

or option 4 - trade ND#2 to eagles for Scott Selwood and pick 25. (Eagles get Aish)

[Ted Lasso 19,518]

Pick 2...

option 1 - James Aish (ND#2)

or option 2 - trade ND#2 to Suns for David Swallow (Suns get Scharenberg)

or option 3 - trade ND#2 to Giants for Taylor Adams and Pick 10. (Giants get Scharenberg)

or option 4 - trade ND#2 to eagles for Scott Selwood and pick 25. (Eagles get Aish)

It's as simple as if David Swallow is on the table that's where pick 2 is going imo

pick up Swallow for pick 2

lose Sylvia and gain pick 21 as compo

trade that and Mark Jamar for Taylor Adams with the threat of PSD

pick 20 - Zak Jones

pick 38- Anthony Miles

DFA - Daniel Cross, Mav Wellar, Darren Jolly

team suddenly looks very different.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

I hear pick 2 could be traded to a club like hawthorn for two or more second tier mids.

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

If it's to be Adams (my preference), I'd send pick 2 and Jamar to GWS for pick 9 and Adams.

I know Jamar has minimal currency, but with Jolly expected to come on board, we need to move him, and I think GWS will want him to replace Brogan.

Jamar has NO currency. he had about 3 touches in 4 games this year. hes done.

[dazzledavey36 54,947]

I hear pick 2 could be traded to a club like hawthorn for two or more second tier mids.

You have good inside sources. Any names mentioned?

[Wilson7 2,670]

I hope not, why trade pick 2 for 2nd tier players. Kennedy & McGlynn went for picks 39, 46 and 76.

I hear pick 2 could be traded to a club like hawthorn for two or more second tier mids.

[PaulRB 6,366]

Which of the Hawks kids played well in the middle for their recent VFL premiership?