Stuff drafting a kid, poach a key forward.

[leucopogon 1,468]

On 10/3/2023 at 4:51 AM, YearOfTheDees said:

Anyone can make a guess any truth ti it.

 

 

This guy can't kick, will fit in perfectly.

[Demonland 65,434]

Another one bites the dust

 

[whatwhat say what 19,077]

1 hour ago, Demonland said:

Another one bites the dust

 

Trade at the end of 2025, then?

[spirit of norm smith 12,974]

On 9/22/2023 at 5:15 PM, spirit of norm smith said:

Still think a phone call to Tom Fullerton (Lions) might be worth a go.  He kicked 30.22 in the VFL as a ruck/forward.  He is a big bodied ruck/forward that could relieve Maxy in the 6-7 minutes a quarter but also be capable ahead of the big sticks. Means we’d let JVR be a permanent forward and potentially cover if Petty was delayed in his return.  

And on 6th October …

Brisbane Lions ruck/forward Tom Fullarton has requested a trade to Melbourne.

24-years-old | 19 games | 200cm | 97kg

[spirit of norm smith 12,974]

On 9/21/2023 at 6:04 PM, spirit of norm smith said:

Yes. I agree. Tom Fullerton on a 3 year deal.  Could carry the load to assist Gawn and also play forward when needed.  Has the physical ability and knows how to use his strength.  Wouldn’t be a high cost imv.  

And snap … 

[DistrACTION Jackson 6,425]

4 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

And on 6th October …

Brisbane Lions ruck/forward Tom Fullarton has requested a trade to Melbourne.

24-years-old | 19 games | 200cm | 97kg

Tim Lamb is that you?

[Nascent 7,314]

On 9/21/2023 at 4:32 PM, Nascent said:

Tom Fullarton maybe as another cheap option. Out of contract I believe but haven't heard about any specific speculation around him.

 

13 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

And on 6th October …

Brisbane Lions ruck/forward Tom Fullarton has requested a trade to Melbourne.

24-years-old | 19 games | 200cm | 97kg

We're built different.

[monoccular 16,118]

On 10/1/2023 at 9:45 AM, Redleg said:

Clearly we hoped BBB and Tom Mac would be ok until the end of their contracts next year and that Schache would somehow improve from his disclosed AFL form.

 

and, as well as none of those scenarios working, there were the additional issues of Fritfoot, Pettyfoot, and Melknee.

How many hits can a team take in a key area, and survive - in retrospect we did bloody well to finish H&A 4th, and to come very close in two finals.

Edited October 10, 2023 by monoccular

[dazzledavey36 48,858]

The Hawkins late bid means we've had no other options that we were looking into and I think we were hoping Hawkin was willing to jump on board.

[Ted Lasso 16,819]

26 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

The Hawkins late bid means we've had no other options that we were looking into and I think we were hoping Hawkin was willing to jump on board.

I think we kind of knew that though, the reality was to sign anyone close to A grade we would need someone contracted to decide they wanted out, and the club to be willing to do the trade. 

I do think we're building up a war chest of cap space for next year however and that's when we will be looking to make a splash 

[spirit of norm smith 12,974]

44 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

The Hawkins late bid means we've had no other options that we were looking into and I think we were hoping Hawkin was willing to jump on board.

Agreed.  Maybe a touch of desperation.  
We have JVR (good but developing) and probably Petty (backman turned forward) as the preferred tall forwards.  Then it’s a mixed bunch of the aged/frail BBB & TMCD, cheeselike Schache, young Jefferson has potential and is about 2 years away, and maybe Fullerton as a ruck/forward support for Gawn. Mixed lollies options !!! 

Edited October 10, 2023 by spirit of norm smith
X

[titan_uranus 22,444]

52 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

The Hawkins late bid means we've had no other options that we were looking into and I think we were hoping Hawkin was willing to jump on board.

No it doesn’t. It means, at most, we have no locked in trade. 

If we’re exploring other forwards but nothing locked in, and then we hear Hawkins might want a phone call, it’s not surprising that we called. If the other options don’t come off, it’s worth having tried. Imagine if he was interested, we didn’t ask, and then the big fish we are seeking fell through.

Plus no doubt someone on here in 2024 will say “did we even pick up the phone and ask Hawkins?”.

[dino rover 624]

I’m still banging on about Liam Reidy at Fremantle 

https://www.fremantlefc.com.au/players/4806/liam-reidy

He he is behind Darcy and Jackson 

originally a fwd converted to ruck

beautiful left foot kick

23 yo 204 cm 104 kg

provides a fwd and ruck option 

comes from Melbourne 

I’m not saying Reidy as the the main play

go after Hawkins lynch et al but as depth Reidy would be cheap 

Edited October 10, 2023 by dino rover
Wrong link

[SPC 2,826]

41 minutes ago, dino rover said:

I’m still banging on about Liam Reidy at Fremantle 

https://www.fremantlefc.com.au/players/4806/liam-reidy

He he is behind Darcy and Jackson 

originally a fwd converted to ruck

beautiful left foot kick

23 yo 204 cm 104 kg

provides a fwd and ruck option 

comes from Melbourne 

I’m not saying Reidy as the the main play

go after Hawkins lynch et al but as depth Reidy would be cheap 

Is he Zach Merritt’s taller twin brother? 

[JimmyGadson 3,455]

I don't understand Demonland's obsession with a key forward. 

Look at what Collingwood just did. They had Cox and Mihocek as keys. 

Unless it's Naughton, nobody is going to be able to mark the majority of ball we have coming in. 

I don't know what the club will do this trade period, but my view is that we've got to get finishers and users both in the forward half and through the midfield. 

ANB, Langdon, Spargo, Chandler and all of Trac, Oliver and Viney starting in the midfield next year isn't going to win us a flag. Sure, it'll have us competing. But the same issues will arise, guaranteed. 

 

Edited October 10, 2023 by JimmyGadson

[spirit of norm smith 12,974]

Thanks @dino rover unfortunately we’re 12 months too late.  Reidy had a good 2022 season at Frankston.  He was available last year and we had the opportunity.   

[DeeSpencer 23,187]

1 hour ago, JimmyGadson said:

I don't understand Demonland's obsession with a key forward. 

Look at what Collingwood just did. They had Cox and Mihocek as keys. 

They had McStay make a huge difference in 2 finals that were tougher scoring match ups. And Billy Frampton doing his best Billy Frampton (somewhat ok job on Harris for 3/4s).

If you can guarantee JVR, Petty and maybe Joel Smith are healthy come crunch time we are in with a chance.

But geez it would be nice to have someone with a pulse to turn to so we don’t have to pick between Schache, T Mc and BBB. 

That said, the draft will inject some fresh legs but I’d love to see one addition of pace and/or skill just as much as a tall forward. In fact, given we’ve added Fullarton and McAdam I’d say pace and skill takes priority one.

 

[sue 8,444]

A club can try to fix current deficiencies and build for the future simultaneously.

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 5,818]

I have no intel behind what I'm about to say, but i have a sneaking suspicion we are secretly after a key forward who's current training ground is not to far away from the MCG.

One of the reasons we are clearing the decks for cap space.

Edited October 11, 2023 by YesitwasaWin4theAges

[JimmyGadson 3,455]

16 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

They had McStay make a huge difference in 2 finals that were tougher scoring match ups. And Billy Frampton doing his best Billy Frampton (somewhat ok job on Harris for 3/4s).

If you can guarantee JVR, Petty and maybe Joel Smith are healthy come crunch time we are in with a chance.

But geez it would be nice to have someone with a pulse to turn to so we don’t have to pick between Schache, T Mc and BBB. 

That said, the draft will inject some fresh legs but I’d love to see one addition of pace and/or skill just as much as a tall forward. In fact, given we’ve added Fullarton and McAdam I’d say pace and skill takes priority one.

 

Haha. 

Soooo what are you saying? 

McStay was a free agent and the pies went hard after him. So many pundits laughed at Collingwood's aggression to land him. I don't know what you're saying? 

They got Billy Frampton for peanuts who ended up playing a pivitol role on Andrews in the granny. 

All of this backs my point which is that supporters have nfi by wanting to hold onto players because they're emotionally attached. 

Everyone thought Collingwood would be cooked both culturally and list-wise when Treloar and Stephenson left. And last year everyone laughed at them for their inclusions and the fact they pushed Grundy out. Look what happened? HELLLLOOOOO. 

I think the MFC need to take a leaf.

Time to look FORWARDDDDDDD. Not just next year and the year after. 

We've wasted two finals campaigns by staying stagnant. 

Edited October 11, 2023 by JimmyGadson

[DeeSpencer 23,187]

13 minutes ago, JimmyGadson said:

McStay was a free agent and the pies went hard after him. So many pundits laughed at Collingwood's aggression to land him. I don't know what you're saying? 

They got Billy Frampton for peanuts who ended up playing a pivitol role on Andrews in the granny. 

 

I wanted McStay, thought the price was great. Thought Grundy for McStay when they had 2 competent rucks was great. I’ve got 100 posts last year bemoaning us getting Grundy rather than being all in on McStay.

All I’m saying is McStay with Mihocek got them to a flag. Frampton with Mihocek won them a flag. No Tom McDonalds or Ben Browns.

Hopefully Fullarton is our Frampton although I’m doubtful. We could still do with one more strong athletic body.

They traded Treloar from their overstocked midfield. They traded a stunted and ordinary Stephenson (and Phillips). Moves more akin to letting go Harmes and JJ than trading a key forward. 

Freshened their midfield and small forward mix.

Find me a McStay and I’ll trade Petty. Otherwise the Pies kept Moore (through significant injury issues), Howe, Mihocek, Cox. The only quality tall they moved on was a massively overpaid ruck for which they already had a replacement in Darcy Cameron.

[Deemania since 56 6,160]

On 10/4/2023 at 4:33 PM, TRIGON said:

Interesting argument looking at the statistics in isolation. However, between Collingwood and Melbourne there is a stark contrast in how the ball is being delivered into the forward 50; their system suits forwards who are leading into space. Our system is different and I think requires a strong tall contested KPF to make it more effective.

Our 'system' that is 'different' is guaranteed to stifle and crowd our scoring opportunities (as evidenced week in, week out); it is only through spacemakers, space exploiters, space finders merging with intent from the forward line feeders that we will nail goals, more frequently, more unexpectedly, more comprehensively, more accurately. Bang, bang, bang. Bang.

[TRIGON 4,719]

19 minutes ago, YesitwasaWin4theAges said:

I have no intel behind what I'm about to say, but i have a sneaking suspicion we are secretly after a key forward who's current training ground is not to far away from the MCG.

One of the reasons we are clearing the decks for cap space.

Tigerland or the Lexus Centre?

[TRIGON 4,719]

3 minutes ago, Deemania since 56 said:

Our 'system' that is 'different' is guaranteed to stifle and crowd our scoring opportunities (as evidenced week in, week out); it is only through spacemakers, space exploiters, space finders merging with intent from the forward line feeders that we will nail goals, more frequently, more unexpectedly, more comprehensively, more accurately. Bang, bang, bang. Bang.

I also think that our 'system' sucks. However, I have no influence in being able to change it.

[bandicoot 1,395]

4 minutes ago, TRIGON said:

Tigerland or the Lexus Centre?

Tom lynch