My 3 word player analysis V Collingwood

[joeboy 2,775]

Gawn - was constantly influential 

Viney - relentless and inspiring 

May - brilliant until last

Lever - outstanding and reliable 

Rivers - brave and creative 

Brayshaw - wonderful after first

Spargo - no influence again

Pickett - what’s up Koz?

Chandler - had some moments 

Fritsch - classy in bursts

vanRooyen - disappointingly little influence 

Langdon - brave and important 

Hunter - disposal surprisingly iffy

Tomlinson - important and consistent 

Petracca- not as influential 

Salem - some amazing interceptions 

Smith - an important addition 

McVee - steady all game

Hibberd - great defensive efforts

Jordan - performed as expected

Grundy - important around ground 

Sparrow - important tagging job

Neal-Bullen - a true workhorse 

 

 

Edited June 12, 2023 by joeboy

[I'va Worn Smith 852]

Jordan.  Keep him in. 

He is way ahead of Spargo, but behind and in front of the ball.  A greet kick and has grunt.  If we keep dropping him, we will lose him.

[Wodjathefirst 2,285]

Team - Well done lads 

Football department- Well done lads 

Forwards - Choco kicking academy 

GO DEES!!!!

[Wells 11 4,745]

Pickett. engine just running . 

He’s a A grader playing like a B grader. what’s happened to him? 

[dee-tox 4,827]

4 minutes ago, Wells 11 said:

Pickett. engine just running . 

He’s a A grader playing like a B grader. what’s happened to him? 

Think you are generous with the B grade. Regular six possession games don't cut it...

[Dee Zephyr 17,508]

1 minute ago, dee-tox said:

Think you are generous with the B grade. Regular six possession games don't cut it...

Pickett is leading the league for tackles inside 50. We have no idea what they’re asking him to do, low possessions by a half forward doesn’t mean squat. Yes, he should be nailing those set shots though. 

[dee-tox 4,827]

2 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

Pickett is leading the league for tackles inside 50. We have no idea what they’re asking him to do, low possessions by a half forward doesn’t mean squat. Yes, he should be nailing those set shots though. 

He is a much better player than just someone that lays tackles...He can do it all, but at the moment is doing very little.

[leave it to deever 15,381]

I thought this was hard on Trac.

[BLWNBA 353]

21 minutes ago, Wells 11 said:

Pickett. engine just running . 

He’s a A grader playing like a B grader. what’s happened to him? 

He's close to one of the most overrated players in the league. He does the impossible once every 10 games and somehow this results in this totally mythical perception of him. He's done nothing to suggest he was worthy of being a first round draft pick. 

You can pick up a player that has his output with shrewd drafting in the rookie draft. 

[Jaded No More 57,957]

Totally disagree on JVR. He was very good. Rarely lost an aerial contest and nailed the most crucial kick for goal of the match. He is a baby. This was a very good game from him playing near and sometimes on one of the best FBs in the game. 

[Wells 11 4,745]

1 minute ago, BLWNBA said:

He's close to one of the most overrated players in the league. He does the impossible once every 10 games and somehow this results in this totally mythical perception of him. He's done nothing to suggest he was worthy of being a first round draft pick. 

You can pick up a player that has his output with shrewd drafting in the rookie draft. 

2 years kicking 40 plus goals for a small forward is outstanding. imo he’s a star in a bad patch. 

[jumbo returns 6,488]

43 minutes ago, I'va Worn Smith said:

Jordan.  Keep him in. 

He is way ahead of Spargo, but behind and in front of the ball.  A greet kick and has grunt.  If we keep dropping him, we will lose him.

Lose him to who? 

[I'va Worn Smith 852]

34 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

Lose him to who? 

He will walk.  We will lose him to another club.  JJ still has currency and whoever picks him up, will get a good player, to our cost, if that happens.  In my view, he is way ahead of Spargo and far more versatile.

[Tarax Club 2,934]

joeboy a great team performance! Goody V Flea? Our system prevailed despite the yipes.

[monoccular 16,074]

Chocko - do your magic. 

[spirit of norm smith 12,920]

Spargo - obviously Goodys lovechild 

Spargo - not doing enough 

Chandler Pickett Spargo - can’t play all

Chandler Pickett Spargo - zero goals today 

Chandler Pickett Spargo- one must go

Umps - need new specs 

JVR - nearly nearly nearly 

Dees - improve goalkicking please 

Trac - get new boots 

Tommo & Mcvee & Riv & Hibbo & Jake & May - fantastic defence today 

Max - must do more 

Jack Viney - we love you 

Grundy - we love you 

Neale Daniher - we love you 

big freeze fundraiser - find a cure

 

[Jibroni 4,058]

Jack Viney Mancrush

[picket fence 15,171]

Lachy Hunter........ so many important touches...

RECRUIT OF THE YEAR

[Rednblueriseing 654]

1 hour ago, Wells 11 said:

Pickett. engine just running . 

He’s a A grader playing like a B grader. what’s happened to him? 

Since he signed on thinks he has to take moy every time the ball comes in high... and constantly burns players in better positions when i50. Just need to go back to basics of a crumber,  stay front and centre and apply pressure 

[demon3165 1,918]

50 minutes ago, Tarax Club said:

joeboy a great team performance! Goody V Flea? Our system prevailed despite the yipes.

Thought Goodwin out coached Craig McRae today which was good to see, hope to see it more often, we'll done.

w all

 

[58er 5,608]

5 hours ago, dee-tox said:

Think you are generous with the B grade. Regular six possession games don't cut it...

Agree 

someone needs to have a frank  and personal chat to Kossie on what ability he has and how he  is going about it using that ability. 

In round terms he has one more chance and faces dropping after the Cats game if he can't get more disposals and affect the game with goals tackles and run and carry plus some crumbing in front and square and also behind the pack. And NO MORE flying for impossible marks ( unrealistic in fact) until he regains his form and composure. 

That we got a win and really humbled the Pies ( who were poor and off their game)  much due to our 2021 style defence. And in fact that really Kossie  and Trac were with JVR our poorest players ( no not trying they did try) with all others contributing all the attributes we ask if our players to be a flag contender. I was so proud of them today as they really put Freo and Port behind them and given some normal front of goal conversion would have embarrassed them no end. 

And we supported their efforts against a very lack lustre Pies fan base who seemed almost bored and assumed the Pies would wipe out their deficit any moment they chose. 
But it didn't happen and no way did they deserve to be any where near us than over 5/6 goals. 

We take the four points and agsin must display the same great character at the Cattery in 10 days time, along with some accuracy traits. 

We are  back to our eyeballs with defence and mids gaining confidence with Clarry to put some icing Into this very fruity cake as long as we get some forward connectivity and confidence.

Now Maysie Rick Salo Fritta and Gawny are back in form Trac had a mulligan and Kossie needs to find his best. Petty due back soon and Smithy if not suspended showed some  ability  that he may develop also to contribute a valuable role to that forward mix. 

Time to keep the momentum going and use our 2021 as the bench mark to improve and kick scurry to ensure no costly lapses. 

I really believe we can get a double chance and gain a home finals run if we take this next step. No doubt today was the best game all season with most systems firing and in the biggest challenge of the year from the best team and exposure to pressure from the crowd and the Pies ability to invest in and outrun us being  chopped off beautifully nearly all day. 

 

[binman 38,146]

4 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Spargo - obviously Goodys lovechild 

Spargo - not doing enough 

Chandler Pickett Spargo - can’t play all

Chandler Pickett Spargo - zero goals today 

Chandler Pickett Spargo- one must go

Umps - need new specs 

JVR - nearly nearly nearly 

Dees - improve goalkicking please 

Trac - get new boots 

Tommo & Mcvee & Riv & Hibbo & Jake & May - fantastic defence today 

Max - must do more 

Jack Viney - we love you 

Grundy - we love you 

Neale Daniher - we love you 

big freeze fundraiser - find a cure

 

Stream of consciousness 

[waynewussell 4,091]

6 hours ago, BLWNBA said:

He's close to one of the most overrated players in the league. He does the impossible once every 10 games and somehow this results in this totally mythical perception of him. He's done nothing to suggest he was worthy of being a first round draft pick. 

You can pick up a player that has his output with shrewd drafting in the rookie draft. 

Some posters have it and some just don’t …

[jumbo returns 6,488]

9 hours ago, I'va Worn Smith said:

He will walk.  We will lose him to another club.  JJ still has currency and whoever picks him up, will get a good player, to our cost, if that happens.  In my view, he is way ahead of Spargo and far more versatile.

I don’t think that comparing him to Spargo is equitable, based on their respective roles

He’s an ok player - not quick, not great below his knees, but he’s a nice kick

[Billy 1,966]

JJ had a real impact when he came on in the middle, really hope we can find a spot for him as a starting 22

Has 10 years of solid footy in front of him