A hypothetical.... Let's just say we continue along the path we are currently on and win the flag or come bloody close. Collingwood decide to trade out players with currency wherever they can for their rebuild. Collingwood are open to trading out Howe. Would you take him back?

Hahahaha

 

No

I absolutely wouldn’t, the bloke has done nothing but have cracks at the club since he left.  He deserves to finish out his career in the bottom 4 (hopefully with no crowds watching).

Not the way he left, the way he has conducted himself since he left nor on injuries either. 

Yep

Good question. No.

Our current glue is a selfless team ethos. That is not Howe's style. Let him stay at Collingwood to languish at the bottom if the ladder, where he can take his hangers before turning it over to the opposition and I don't have to care about it.

Hypothetical question. Nonetheless its a complete NO from me. 

On one hand you could argue it is hard to blame him - he escaped the club when it really wasn’t a great place to be. 
 

On the other hand you could argue he is a Judas. I’m with this hand.

Edited April 28, 20213 yr by The Jackson 6

No

left for his reasons, like Gerard Healey left when he was needed, 

No

Yes, on minimum wage as a forward for Casey reserves.

No DH policy at Melbourne for a while now. He just cost his club $20k for getting De goey to grab his phone for him. So a NO for me. 

Wouldn’t suit our defensive structure

?

We now are developing into to selfless team.  
Where would you play him anyway?

It has always upset me that Howe is playing for Collingwood. It has also always upset me that Collingwood is praised for turning Howe into a backman. I'm glad he missed a flag in 2018. He should still be at Melbourne, but would he fit into our system?

GFY

 

kidding of course.

11 minutes ago, monoccular said:

?

We now are developing into to selfless team.  
Where would you play him anyway?

Casey

Past his prime, superfluous to requirements and his ego would demand top dollar.

A no from me.....

He would struggle to get a game anyway....

Trade him back home to the Kangas, so he can play in front of packed stadiums of 10k

 Is the pope a Buddhist?

Would he be in our best 22?

Certainly not...had his chance and went to the filth

He was a reason to go to the footy when we weren’t winning to see another mark of the year contender. 
He also said some nice words ahead of Chunk’s 300th last week, so I’m not sure he’s a complete dh.
But now we’re winning. He won’t make us a better team, nor does he have the pressure attributes IMO. Absolutely a no from me.