Demonland Player of the Year - Round 8

[Billy 2,544]

8 hours ago, dee-tox said:

Your votes shouldn't count if you don't have Salem in there somewhere.

Your votes shouldn't count if you don't have TMac in there

[Vineytime 854]

Oliver

Petracca - 2nd half Wow

Viney

 

 

daylight.....

Hibberd

Pedo

[Biffen 12,947]

6.Pedo

5.Petracca

4.Vince

3.Salem

2.Oliver

1.Jones

(the midfielders take my votes in our most even performance in years.)

[Bitter but optimistic 22,246]

A pleasantly tough task this week

6. Viney

5 Hibberd

4. Salem

3. Petracca

2 Vince

1. Jetta

[Deeoldfart 8,061]

22 into 6 won't go, but on a more serious note:

6.  Viney

5.  Hibberd

4.  Oliver

3.  Pedersen

2.  Vince

1. Salem

That was a seriously difficult assignment, and probably doesn't do justice to the likes of Truck, TMac, Jetts and Jonsey.  On any other weekend, they would have been in my bests.

Edited May 14, 2017 by Deeoldfart

[Nasher 33,617]

6. Oliver
5. Viney
4. Petracca
3. Hibberd
2. Salem
1. Pedersen

Had trouble putting them in order, but think they were the best 6.  Wanted to squeeze in Jones, Vince, Tom Mac and Jetta but couldn't.

[Deespicable 2,886]

6 Oliver (hard for me not to give him this after criticising him lately. Not once did he turn backwards and compile stats with an easy unrequired handball. Brilliant and what a goal)

5 Hibberd (how good was he! Plenty of tricky moments to cope with - the Wags handball over his head etc - but he was beaten only in one of them - Eddie's magic goal).

4 Viney (he's back. I just feel sorry for his girlfriend. Imagine him coming at you all the time!)

3 Petracca (when you are Mr Cool in the cauldron that we witnessed, then you've made it. He has. We now have two young superstars and a host of other goers).

2 T-Mac (I know some of you don't get it with his kicking. But if you actually watch his impact, he's in everybody's votes. I just wish Jesse would take note.)

1 Salem (Started our regroup in the second with a courageous handball to Lewis and was precise and clever from then on. Why he's been playing midfield is beyond me.)

Apologies:

Jones and Pedo - Hard to believe that they could kick five between them, do their roles, and miss votes, but I stand by my choices.

Vince - A serial pest in Adelaide. Sometimes we need to tag and the element of surprise helps. Normal role next week please though.

[Gator 17,449]

Viney

Petracca

Oliver

Hibberd

Vince

T. McDonald

[DeeZone 10,101]

6- Viney

5- Hibberd

4- Oliver

3- TMac

2- Petracca

1- Pedo

[spirit of norm smith 16,588]

6 Hibberd

5 Viney

4 Oliver

3 Vince

2 Salem

1 Petraccaaaaaa

 

[jane02 3,749]

6. Viney

5. Hibberd

4. Petracca

3. Oliver

2. Vince

1. Salem

Apologises to Pederson, Jetta, Tom McDonald, Jones

[leehow 303]

15 hours ago, Petraccattack said:

6) Viney - dominant, fearless, inspirational

5) Hibberd - if he played for any other team would be being talked up as unanimous AA selection

4) Petracca - looked like a Dangerfied clone when he went on to the ball. That contested mark and goal just screamed confidence. Total beast.

3) Clayton Oliver - made Jacobs hitouts look worthless. A genius reader of the play.

2) TMac  - his move forward helped turn the game.   Goodwin is a proactive coach.

1) Bernie Vince - obliterated Sloane

Unlucky - Salem, Jetta, Pedersen, Jones, Frost

Hibberd has been fantastic, but he has played three games, so wouldn't be in AA contention at the moment. The fact that he plays for the MFC rather than someone else has nothing to do with it. 

Other than that, pretty accurate I reckon.

Edited May 14, 2017 by leehow

[titan_uranus 25,043]

6 - Hibberd
5 - Oliver
4 - Viney
3 - TMac
2 - Petracca
1 - Vince

[sydneydee 689]

Oliver 

Petracca

Viney

Hibberd

Vince

Salem

 

 

 

 

[dee-tox 4,835]

11 hours ago, Billy said:

Your votes shouldn't count if you don't have TMac in there

Sorry Billy. Couple of useful things in the third doesn't cut it for me compared to the six chosen.Two goals, two excellent contested marks and two goal assists were good though.

Edited May 14, 2017 by dee-tox

[deeflog 679]

6- hibberd

5- viney

4- oliver

3- petracca 

2- frost

1- vince

 

frost and vince gets votes for completely nullifying their 2 most important players

[CanberraDemon 214]

Tough week to choose, but mine are:

Viney

Oliver

Hibberd

Petracca

Pederson

Jones

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

6. Viney;  5.2 / 4th (weighted score / rank)

5. Cool Hand Clarry;   6.25 / 1st

4. Salem;  5.43 / 3rd

3. Hibberd (4.63 / 5th)

2. Pettracca;  4.60 / 6th

1. Mr Vince;  1.78 / 20th

Apologies to The Jones Boy (5.70 / 2nd), Lewis (4.03 / 7th) and Pedders (3.63 / 8th ... no hit outs/ruck work included!)

Edited May 14, 2017 by Rusty Nails

[3Dee 1,153]

6 Petracca

Oliver

Hibberd

Jetta

Viney

Jones

[DubDee 26,117]

Viney

vince

hibberd

petracca

salem

oliver

[Dee Dee 1,117]

6: Viney

5: Hibberd

4: Oliver

3: Petracca

2: Salem

1: Pedersen 

[Deestroy All 14,266]

6 - Viney. Complete game. Drove us forward always (and through them).

5 - Vince. His role was so important, Sloane drives them, Vince took the keys. 

4 - Petracca. Forward and mid he was great. Too strong, too good. 

3 - Hibberd. Mops [censored] up, gets us out of pickles, strong and smart, ripping game. 

2 - Oliver.  Because Oliver. 

1 - I really can't decide between Tmac and Pedo. Both structurally important. Both played equally well. .5 each. 

That was difficult. lol look at the players that missed out. 

[Happeninghunts 7]

Viney 

oliver 

hibberd 

frost 

Jetta 

petracca 

[Demonland 73,140]

Clayton Oliver's amazing season continues ...

92. Clayton Oliver
57. Jack Watts
52. Nathan Jones
39. Jack Viney
33. Jayden Hunt
28. Michael Hibberd
24. Jeff Garlett
23. Christian Petracca
22. Jordan Lewis
17. Christian Salem
16. Sam Frost 
15. Dom Tyson Tom McDonald 
11. Max Gawn 
9. Bernie Vince          
7. Neville Jetta  Alex Neal-Bullen
6. Jesse Hogan Cam Pedersen 
5. Dean Kent Billy Stretch 
2. Jake Melksham

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Viney has gone from zero votes to fourth in about four weeks.

Jetta's position is also not reflective of how good he has been.