Scott Thompson - Would we welcome him back?

[Dante 2,739]

18 minutes ago, P-man said:

I think one of the issues faced in the next period of development is too much being left to too few in terms of leaders on the ground, exacerabted by the likes of Dunn and Garland being squeezed out of the side.

The Geelong game wouldn't have happened if we had more leaders to share the load and guide the younger crop. Hopefully Hibberd brings some leadership traits to the table but I don't think he's well known for that.

If Thompson was to take up the spot of someone like Harmes or Vanders in 2017 I'd be okay with it. Development at Casey isn't the worst thing in the world.

I think it's highly unlikely to happen though, given what we've seen this season with selections.

 

We are a middle of the road team, Geelong are going to challenge for the flag, we were no match for them and having Hibberd in the side wouldn't have made any difference.  They would have probably beaten any side in the competition last week and it was just unfortunate we happened to be the team that played them. 

If we are going to get an experienced plater to give us two years of leadership we need to look at someone younger than 34, he is going to be lucky to play out one full year let alone two.

 

 

[P-man 13,366]

24 minutes ago, Dante said:

We are a middle of the road team, Geelong are going to challenge for the flag, we were no match for them and having Hibberd in the side wouldn't have made any difference.  They would have probably beaten any side in the competition last week and it was just unfortunate we happened to be the team that played them. 

If we are going to get an experienced plater to give us two years of leadership we need to look at someone younger than 34, he is going to be lucky to play out one full year let alone two.

 

 

I wasn't suggesting having Hibberd in the side on the weekend would've changed the result. More senior leaders over the course of the year should however result in less players being totally spent by the end of it.

If we can find someone younger with suitable leadership qualities, great. I haven't seen many great candidates being thrown around as yet.

[Biffen 12,944]

No to Scott Thompson.

We are not a retirement home .

 

[Gator 17,385]

4 hours ago, P-man said:

Re that best 22. That forward line (bar Kent) with Hogan and Weed was trialled in the last two weeks. Against Geelong it operated at 35% efficiency from inside 50s and was equally lacklustre the week before.

Do you see it as being fully competitive come Round 1 2017 without a Pedersen type, i.e. a more experienced big bodied forward who can hold his own in marking contests and provide protection for Hogan and others? 

I agree with you. 

Weideman is the key and he's probably 4 years off being a week in week out dominant forward.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,242]

I haven't read this thread but FMD how did it get to 5 pages?

Surely we have got the message - our future is with YOUTH!

Let's stick to the path.

[Ethan Tremblay 30,894]

Saty would be a walking stiffy seeing Thompsons cannons up close in real life. 

[Bitter but optimistic 22,242]

1 minute ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Saty would be a walking stiffy seeing Thompsons cannons up close in real life. 

Actually once the smell of liniment kicks in Ethan, I think walking ( and talking  stalking ) stiffy is Saty's natural (unnatural) state.

[Demons11 7,032]

On 30 August 2016 at 9:46 AM, Petraccattack said:

Look what Stevie J has done for GWS this season.  And everyone though he was washed up. He looked cooked with the Cats last year.

Thommo could have the same impact for us.

The difference being Thompson will be 34 next year.  

[Little Goffy 14,583]

39 minutes ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

I haven't read this thread but FMD how did it get to 5 pages?

Surely we have got the message - our future is with YOUTH!

Let's stick to the path.

Wait... people were actually talking about bringing him over as a player?

I thought it was just one of those sentimental 'get them back to the club as a coach' things.

Shane Woewodin is still ahead of him on that count, anyway.

[Sir Why You Little 37,053]

Thompson would be great for a year IF he can still play topline footy. 

Is he still getting games now? ( i haven't seen much of the Crows this year) if he is still playing Football in the midfield this September then it is worth consideration. But at 34 it must be a very careful decision. 

We do need leaders for the next 2-3 years. 

[DV8 2,271]

12 hours ago, nutbean said:

This...

We are crying out for more leadership - but i dont think we should be looking at 34 year old leadership 

One year of Scotty Thompson playing won't hurt us.

7 hours ago, P-man said:

I get why the age puts people off. 

To my mind every year we can essentially plug wth senior players like this is another year of development into the Viney/Tyson/Brayshaw generation on their path to taking over rmantle which hopefully isn't far away. I think we have natural leaders at the club now. They are just young.

I don't see Thompson leaving but he'd be a great person and player to have at the club right now.

in 2 - 3 years time our maturity void in the 26yr, & 24 yr brackets won't be a concern.  But right now it is.  And the leadership at the top end is really low for us.

So One year as player & on-field generaling, along with Jonesy, would be very handy in the transition away from Roosy.  Our list is full of kids.

[DV8 2,271]

5 hours ago, P-man said:

I think one of the issues faced in the next period of development is too much being left to too few in terms of leaders on the ground, exacerabted by the likes of Dunn and Garland being squeezed out of the side.

The Geelong game wouldn't have happened if we had more leaders to share the load and guide the younger crop. Hopefully Hibberd brings some leadership traits to the table but I don't think he's well known for that.

If Thompson was to take up the spot of a player on the edge of the 22 in 2017 I'd be okay with it. Development at Casey isn't the worst thing in the world.

I think it's highly unlikely to happen though, given what we've seen this season with selections.

 

I think the issue is not age, but quality leadership.  I don't think Dunn & Garland deliver.

[spirit of norm smith 16,478]

One year of Scott Thompson would lift us into the finals. Selwood and Dangerfield smashed us. Thompson is tough and smart and still very good.

[DV8 2,271]

14 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

One year of Scott Thompson would lift us into the finals. Selwood and Dangerfield smashed us. Thompson is tough and smart and still very good.

Yes, we need more smarts around the middle. and another hard runner.

[Go the Biff 3,435]

The general consensus on Adelaide boards is that Thommo is cooked. Most would prefer he retired gracefully.

Strengths - still great under the ruckman getting clearances.

Weaknesses - Legs are shot. Doesn't spread anymore & defensively can be a liability as he can't keep up with the opposition

On that basis, as a player, a big no from me and I don't see how he fits. I'd rather Clarrie in the guts getting those clearances

[DemonWA 3,936]

No, because I couldn't handle the Burgo puff piece which would romanticise the return of the prodigal son ;P

I'd take him but wouldn't expect him to play too many matches to be honest

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

Take him for peanuts..just to have him around the place and on the track when fit. One year, what's the harm..everyone saying we have to follow the youth path...yeah right...did we learn nothing from the experience 8 years ago when we cleaned out all our experience and only played kids. All sides need a balance. Use GWS as the model. Look at the older guys they have brought in over their term to assist the development of young kids. We have a good lot of young fellas..they need some direction. I don't think Jones is a good talker on match days..he leads by example, which is a great quality..he could do with a hand. It's no risk as far as I am concerned. Rather have him in the side once in a while than Have Michie or Matt Jones. 

[Swooper 260]

Spotted Shane Woewodin walking in to AAMI Park in his suit.

[stuie 7,374]

6 minutes ago, Swooper said:

Spotted Shane Woewodin walking in to AAMI Park in his suit.

Hmmmm wonder if that's to do with a possible coaching role or something to do with the Lions? (Or neither of course)

 

[Ted Lasso 19,526]

On 9/7/2016 at 0:20 PM, Swooper said:

Spotted Shane Woewodin walking in to AAMI Park in his suit.

I heard at work he's one that the Tigers were keen to interview for an assistant coaching role so perhaps Goody invited him for a chat as well

[Dockett 32 1,239]

Cant see getting Thompson as a smart move by Goodwin. Rightly or wrongly could seem like a sweet  retirement journey for one of his mates.

His best is well behind him and could also irritate a number of Melbourne supporters who were annoyed at his departure in the initial instance.

Would expect an aspiring coach to be way smarter than this.

Where is the upside?

IMO would be an unnecessary , poorly executed, first move, should it eventuate. 

Lets hope it doesn't

[DV8 2,271]

Cross, Daniel

11 hours ago, Leoncelli_36 said:

Take him for peanuts..just to have him around the place and on the track when fit. One year, what's the harm..everyone saying we have to follow the youth path...yeah right...did we learn nothing from the experience 8 years ago when we cleaned out all our experience and only played kids. All sides need a balance. Use GWS as the model. Look at the older guys they have brought in over their term to assist the development of young kids. We have a good lot of young fellas..they need some direction. I don't think Jones is a good talker on match days..he leads by example, which is a great quality..he could do with a hand. It's no risk as far as I am concerned. Rather have him in the side once in a while than Have Michie or Matt Jones. 

Exactly chell.  The young guys need older heads to follow;  the old heads that will bend over the ball to pick it up, play physical, & run hard both ways, & show the right direction thru the week & game-days.

Chunk needs a chopout in the middle from another mature headed mid.  If we want to make inroads toward September next year, then all the best old Pro's are needed to help.

He would be following the footsteps of Daniel Cross & Bernie Vince in recent times, who we have used to help us, as we become harder workers & more professional.  One year I see as beneficial to us onfield & thru the week on training days.  And at Casey if needs be,

Edited September 7, 2016 by DV8

[junk 342]

Would be a good leader for the younger players. He would make a good assistant coach one day. But ………………………….?

[praha 11,240]

I believe we should recruit no one, and hinge all our bets on inexperienced potential, and experience in the likes of Garland, Dunn and Dawes...

[dieter 3,325]

After watching Scot fumble and get caught out of position and slipping and fumbling in the first half against North definitely NO THANKYOU.