Rivers, Sylvia, N Jones given MFC Life Membership Awards

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

I get there are criteria/rules to follow but ...

 

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2015-12-17/life-membership-for-country-boy-col

On the other hand, congrats to big Riv and Jones. But Col ... seriously.

[Lucifers Hero 37,524]

Given comments elsewhere DL's have varied views about 2 of the 3 (Nathan is universally loved).

Whatever one's view I'm glad the Club can welcome back players that have chosen to leave.

Congratulations to Rivers, Col and Nat!

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2015-12-17/rivers-honoured-to-become-life-member

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2015-12-17/life-membership-for-country-boy-col

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2015-12-17/award-will-sink-in-postcareer-jones

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

"Cheers [censored], celebrating with the boys already!"

[chook fowler 18,588]

For services to the preseason 

[John Crow Batty 8,376]

Must  be a shortage of Life Membership material. 

[Adzman 2,086]

Col and Rivers were a big part of our past. I think a life membership is a nice touch.

[Friday 71]

100 games = life membership?

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Sylvia.. surely this is a joke

[spirit of norm smith 13,635]

10 years at the footy club. Yes they all deserve the life membership.

Hopefully Rivers does some development coaching at the Pies then comes back to the Dees

[McQueen 17,864]

2 hours ago, Curry & Beer said:

Sylvia.. surely this is a joke

Indeed.

Can someone please give a summary of the criteria required?

Wow, length of service only?

[dazzledavey36 49,795]

150 game is basically the criteria that gets you a life memberships. Regardless of what these player did in the past some of the comments are a bit uncalled for and silly. 150 games is still a mighty effort in AFL footy especially at one club now days.

 

Well done to Riv and Col and looking forward to seeing these guys at the past players bar barracking for us in the near future.

[Gator 16,921]

It's a fantastic honour.  Well done, Col.

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,654]

39 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

150 game is basically the criteria that gets you a life memberships. Regardless of what these player did in the past some of the comments are a bit uncalled for and silly. 150 games is still a mighty effort in AFL footy especially at one club now days.

 

Well done to Riv and Col and looking forward to seeing these guys at the past players bar barracking for us in the near future.

Call me petty but while happy for Chunky and Rivers, can't say I get any joy in seeing Col get life membership. Got selected more on potential than performance, was a lazy selfish footballer who would have been shown the door from a real football club years before he was by ours.

 

that said, half of those bagging him now vigorously defended him when each year the few of us called for the clown to be traded

[jackaub 1,402]

9 hours ago, Adzman said:

Col and Rivers were a big part of our past. I think a life membership is a nice touch.

Yes and thank god for that!!! If only Col managed a pre - season would have been a gun . What a joke!

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,646]

I shudder to think what the comments around here might be if Jack Watts ever gets a life membership.

[Cranky Franky 1,593]

Colin leaving resulted in us getting Bernie Vince.  We are forever in his debt.

Mind you Tom Scully jumping ship got us Jesse Hogan so maybe Tom deserves Life Membership as well. 

 

[Dee Dee 1,060]

1 hour ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

I shudder to think what the comments around here might be if Jack Watts ever gets a life membership.

More deserving than Sylvia I would expect!

However as life membership is given for 10 year service (I believe) Jack's still a few years away.

[Bossdog 2,002]

Col Sylvia played 157 games and kicked 129 goals for the Melbourne Football Club in probably the worst period for the footy club. (Tanking..Lack of money....Poor admin....Poor team)

It is interesting that so many people love to stick the boots in to a player that did not meet their expectations.

He also gave 10 years service.

People say he was a party boy, lazy, injured, not up to it.   It takes all types to make up a footy team or else we should just use robots.

It is so easy to sit in the stands or watch on TV and think we are so much better. (usually after a few beers)

So.....I say well done Col on your life membership and you are always welcome at the footy club 

 

[old dee 23,256]

18 minutes ago, Bossdog said:

Col Sylvia played 157 games and kicked 129 goals for the Melbourne Football Club in probably the worst period for the footy club. (Tanking..Lack of money....Poor admin....Poor team)

It is interesting that so many people love to stick the boots in to a player that did not meet their expectations.

He also gave 10 years service.

People say he was a party boy, lazy, injured, not up to it.   It takes all types to make up a footy team or else we should just use robots.

It is so easy to sit in the stands or watch on TV and think we are so much better. (usually after a few beers)

So.....I say well done Col on your life membership and you are always welcome at the footy club 

 

Agree Bossdog a little gracefulness by some people would not go astray.

[DubDee 21,985]

hopefully next time we announce life memberships they will be 3 one-club players and 3 players that got the most out of themselves

Col never put in the effort that is why people arent keen on him getting life membership - not cause he left.  him getting one cheapens the honour for the likes of Jones

[rpfc 27,692]

No problems with this - it's not like they are in the team of the century...

Only pettiness would keep them from what should be theirs because of how they left, or because of what they didn't fulfil. 

[binman 39,612]

26 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Col never put in the effort that is why people arent keen on him getting life membership - not cause he left.  him getting one cheapens the honour for the likes of Jones

I can't agree. Life membership is for 10 years service. Col played for the dees for 10 years. Its not a value based award and doesn't cheapen the honor for Jones, or any one else, in the slightest. And jeez louise its not as if Col is an axe murderer

[AzzKikA 2,371]

Mixed feeling about his one, while i appreciated the services of both (not even mentioning Jones, well deserved), Im not sure only time should be the factor for getting life membership.  I would think that being a club man first would be more fitting than how many games you have played for how many years you played them for.  I do not class either of them to be club men.

 

 

[Bossdog 2,002]

47 minutes ago, AzzKikA said:

Mixed feeling about his one, while i appreciated the services of both (not even mentioning Jones, well deserved), Im not sure only time should be the factor for getting life membership.  I would think that being a club man first would be more fitting than how many games you have played for how many years you played them for.  I do not class either of them to be club men.

 

 

Having played for a club for 10 years and over 150 games?   Why does that not qualify you for a life membership?

Who then should qualify?    How can you tell who, are club men and who are not.? 

Is it just the vibe? or because they left due to free agency?

Just wondering.   

[old dee 23,256]

50 minutes ago, AzzKikA said:

Mixed feeling about his one, while i appreciated the services of both (not even mentioning Jones, well deserved), Im not sure only time should be the factor for getting life membership.  I would think that being a club man first would be more fitting than how many games you have played for how many years you played them for.  I do not class either of them to be club men.

 

 

So then it becomes a value judgement made at the time by someone. Does not work like that you do the time you get the award it is that simple unless of course there were serious problems with you at the club and then it might be withheld. Simply not liking someone ain't grounds to withhold the award.

In all honest how do you know what sort of "clubman" either player was at the time they  played for the MFC? 

From the outside they appeared fine to me.