The Jack Trengove is BACK Thread

[titan_uranus 24,863]

If Tyson is out this week as well, I'd have thought this is as good a chance as any to try Trengove out.

He's either going to play through the middle as an inside mid or he's going to play Vince/Lewis' role off half-back whilst they are put into the middle.

33 minutes ago, Razor said:

I wonder if the selectors are a bit chastened after the White selection last week?  In comparison selecting Trengove is much lower risk.

I doubt it. I think we now know that the JKH/Kennedy/Kent saga caused the FD to have to make something up on the run to cover for Garlett, and they tried using Hunt in that role and replacing him with White.

Failed, but probably wouldn't have happened if those others were available.

[Demons1858 1,725]

A club should never put a line through a player as they can sometimes surprise you with their development. Having said that it does feel like that is happening to Jack. It's gone from me being disappointed about the situation to a lower level of anger towards the club. CAN THE CLUB PLS EXPLAIN WHAT HIS AREAS OF DEVELOPMENT ARE!!! Plapp talks about the development of others at VFL but less so JT. If it's speed then say so !!!! I've had enough of it - members are entitled to know what he needs to improve on

Edited July 5, 2017 by Demons1858

[buck_nekkid 5,830]

27 minutes ago, Demons1858 said:

A club should never put a line through a player as they can sometimes surprise you with their development. Having said that it does feel like that is happening to Jack. It's gone from me being disappointed about the situation to a lower level of anger towards the club. CAN THE CLUB PLS EXPLAIN WHAT HIS AREAS OF DEVELOPMENT ARE!!! Plapp talks about the development of others at VFL but less so JT. If it's speed then say so !!!! I've had enough of it - members are entitled to know what he needs to improve on

No, only JT needs to be told what he needs to improve on.  Members are less 'entitled' than they think they are....

[Demons1858 1,725]

Yes to some extent l agree but we get nothing other than vanilla reports from Plapp e.g. JT is professional, JT is showing leadership blah blah blah. Just want an understanding areas of improvement its not that big a deal. If l was asking about the color of his jocks or his personal life then l would agree with you

[chookrat 4,215]

Tyson confirmed out and Trengove named in the Interchange. With Viney and Tyson out I'd say JKH and Trengove in, with Kent or Kennedy in for Bugg. Hogan in for  White.

[MudDogs Gawn Win.. someday 499]

10 minutes ago, chookrat said:

Tyson confirmed out and Trengove named in the Interchange. With Viney and Tyson out I'd say JKH and Trengove in, with Kent or Kennedy in for Bugg. Hogan in for  White.

You'll need to squeeze one more out to get Trengove in.

OUT Bugg Viney Tyson White Wagner??

IN Hogan Garlett Trengove JKH Kent 

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,389]

Be still my beating heart!

[jnrmac 19,928]

On 7/4/2017 at 9:24 PM, Razor said:

I wonder if the selectors are a bit chastened after the White selection last week?  In comparison selecting Trengove is much lower risk.

With Viney, Tyson and Jones out our only 'slow mid' is Lewis...maybe that's why Trengove fits in the squad?

[chookrat 4,215]

2 hours ago, Mud Dogs Gonna Win said:

You'll need to squeeze one more out to get Trengove in.

OUT Bugg Viney Tyson White Wagner??

IN Hogan Garlett Trengove JKH Kent 

Thanks mad dog, I got a bit excited. Still hoping Trenners slots in.

[Little Goffy 14,118]

Does anyone else think Jack's portrait in the 'ins' list looks especially happy.

I got a real glow in the heart, and instantly feel like we're going to win on sunday. It's like the world just turned a little more red and blue.

[DEE fence 4,963]

Is there a market where you can bet on trengove getting named in the best

[puntkick 325]

3 hours ago, Little Goffy said:

Does anyone else think Jack's portrait in the 'ins' list looks especially happy.

I got a real glow in the heart, and instantly feel like we're going to win on sunday. It's like the world just turned a little more red and blue.

I always struggled to understand your posts from Canberra but know they're from Sydney I'm REALLY CONFUSED !

[Skuit 10,002]

5 hours ago, DaisyDeeciple said:

Is there a market where you can bet on trengove getting named in the best

Yeah, the Stupormarket. Stupor being 'the lack of critical mental function' or a 'condition of greatly dulled or completely suspended sensibility'. Sorry Daisy - but please don't throw away your money to those blood-sucking bookies based on some sort of sentimentality. I'll send the club a cheque for $50 on your behalf if Trenners gets even close.

[DEE fence 4,963]

15 minutes ago, Skuit said:

Yeah, the Stupormarket. Stupor being 'the lack of critical mental function' or a 'condition of greatly dulled or completely suspended sensibility'. Sorry Daisy - but please don't throw away your money to those blood-sucking bookies based on some sort of sentimentality. I'll send the club a cheque for $50 on your behalf if Trenners gets even close.

I only ever bet for sentimentality or pride, betting for profit is by far more dangerous... but I take your point cheers 

[Lucifers Hero 39,041]

I thought it was poor form to take Jack to Perth on the bench in the pre season game vs Eagles and then not give him a run. If ever the club wanted to assess him at something close to AFL level that was the game - really not much at stake.   It amazes me how he keeps his chin up sometimes.  All credit to him.

Last year the club kept nominating Grimes in the squad but rarely got a game.  It became embarrassing.

Hope the same doesn't happen to Trengove - he deserves better, I wish the club would play him or not nominate him in the squad. 

Edited July 6, 2017 by Lucifer's Hero

[Tricky 341]

4 hours ago, Skuit said:

Yeah, the Stupormarket. Stupor being 'the lack of critical mental function' or a 'condition of greatly dulled or completely suspended sensibility'. Sorry Daisy - but please don't throw away your money to those blood-sucking bookies based on some sort of sentimentality. I'll send the club a cheque for $50 on your behalf if Trenners gets even close.

Agree, it's insidious S%^T. No offense Daisy.. to each his own.

[MudDogs Gawn Win.. someday 499]

6 hours ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

I thought it was poor form to take Jack to Perth on the bench in the pre season game vs Eagles and then not give him a run. If ever the club wanted to assess him at something close to AFL level that was the game - really not much at stake.   It amazes me how he keeps his chin up sometimes.  All credit to him.

Last year the club kept nominating Grimes in the squad but rarely got a game.  It became embarrassing.

Hope the same doesn't happen to Trengove - he deserves better, I wish the club would play him or not nominate him in the squad. 

Officially ruled out by Goodwin (quoted on twitter by the club). Said he has things to work on.. Those things namely being requesting a trade to a club that might give him a game, not just rub up against him while the club has its period.

[hemingway 7,615]

7 hours ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

I thought it was poor form to take Jack to Perth on the bench in the pre season game vs Eagles and then not give him a run. If ever the club wanted to assess him at something close to AFL level that was the game - really not much at stake.   It amazes me how he keeps his chin up sometimes.  All credit to him.

Last year the club kept nominating Grimes in the squad but rarely got a game.  It became embarrassing.

Hope the same doesn't happen to Trengove - he deserves better, I wish the club would play him or not nominate him in the squad. 

Agreed Lucifer.  Very disheartening for Jack. One can only imagine how discouraged he must be feeling and what it must be doing to his psyche and confidence levels. It does seem similar to the Grimes situation.  Coaches and selectors have to make tough decisions but it seems harsh. There are no rumours about Jack's attitude to it all, so it either says a lot about the man or the nature of the interpersonal relationship between coach and player. 

[Tricky 341]

Verbatim from Twitter

Quote

Goodwin: Jack Trengove will leave no stone unturned in his quest to come back.

Goodwin: Jack Trengove won't play on Sunday, although he's getting close. We know what he brings. We want to see some things at VFL level.

Poor bugger...

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,293]

Why name him in the extended bench if he has things to work on,  are we that bereft of depth that we just need to put names on the Team sheet for the AFL.??

Edited July 7, 2017 by Hell Bent
Grammar

[deanox 9,770]

what are those things???????

[samcantstandya 1,031]

10 minutes ago, Tricky said:

Verbatim from Twitter

Poor bugger...

I'm sick of seeing White Wagner JKH etc getting games b4 Jack he might be slow but he has a bigger skill set than most on the list. Goodwin obviously doesn't like him. I reckon if Sam Mitchell can play AFL then Jack can & should 2.

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,389]

14 minutes ago, deanox said:

what are those things???????

Exactly. It's the same line wheeled out every time.  We don't even have a general idea what they want him to work on.  Is it attack, defence, disposal, decision making..?

[Tricky 341]

3 minutes ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Exactly. It's the same line wheeled out every time.  We don't even have a general idea what they want him to work on.  Is it attack, defence, disposal, decision making..?

Let's hope they are being a tad more specific with their feedback to Jack.

[beelzebub 23,241]

Its the Vibe...Mabo..and now "Things"