WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - JOSHUA WAGNER

[DemonLad5 1,642]

Who are some names that went undrafted tonight who may get picked by us in the rookie draft?

James Parsons, Will Snelling come to mind.

[Whispering_Jack 29,174]

Jesse Glass-McKasker (WA), Nicholas Coughlan (GWS Academy), Daniel Capiron (VIC), Nick Dodge (TAS) and Christopher Jansen (SA).

Liam Jeffs (VIC) trained with us early in the season.

[Fat Tony 5,072]

Have we got any picks other than for Michie?

[Redleg 40,040]

Have we got any picks other than for Michie?

We have 2 picks, with one promised to Michie, if he is there.

[Roger Mellie 3,873]

Nick O'Kearney

[sydneydee 684]

Who is the fastest with good foot skills?

[spirit of norm smith 15,104]

surprised James Parsons missed out. Should get a rookie spot and MFC a good option.

Nash Holmes also very unlucky.

[Wilson7 2,616]

We have 2 picks, with one promised to Michie, if he is there.

I hope we don't use our first pick on Michie

[monoccular 17,312]

Best available. Does vanders have a twin hiding in NEAFL somewhere?

[CBDees 3,165]

I hope we don't use our first pick on Michie

I think that you can relax!

[CBDees 3,165]

Question: Would there be a benefit in paying out M. Jones and Terlich's contracts at this late stage and promoting King and White? We could offer to recruit them both into Casey (where realistically is where they will both spend all their time next year, whereas White may be a chance in getting a run and is better depth). If we did this it may allow us to look at anybody of interest in the PSD or selecting three rookies. At the very least, it would significantly strengthen Casey and provide MFC more depth (c.f. retaining M.Jones and Terlich when we have different needs to when they were drafted)!

[Dee-licious 1,947]

We've been heavily linked to Sam Murray. Assume that we are taking him.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Will be really disappointed if Michie is not on the rookie list next year.

I still think he can make it.

[MadAsHell 4,209]

Reckon we need some outside run off half back with good kicking skills. Someone who can play tall & small. Pretty much another Mitch White.

So for me the two best options are:

Jack Watson (Swan Districts) - 191cm, 81kg or

James Parsons (Eastern Rangers) - 189cm, 85kg

Other peoples thoughts and suggestions of who we may look at?

[whatwhat say what 22,086]

jake lovett?

[TheoX 1,218]

Just take Michie

[Mad_Melbourne 872]

O'Kearny, i was surprised that we didnt pull the trigger on him with one of our later picks, hopefully he could come through the middle, massive accumulator and worth the punt.

Possibly Callum Moore too, athletic talent, a couple years to develop on the rookie list could be alright.

[old55 22,775]

Think we still need a mature ruck back-up.

[Optimus D 283]

I feel a need for speed

[DeeSpencer 24,686]

O'Kearney just has no AFL traits. I can't see us being interested. He's without a position in modern AFL.

I'd go wing/half back for sure. Parsons' looks a nice type for a needs based selection.

Greg Clark could be an option. I like him as a tall outside runner. If he does have top line endurance then running up and down the wing at that size would make a nice bail out kick even if he doesn't have particularly great pace or skills.

Reuben William, Thomas Glen, Sam Murray seem likely types.

Some combination of athleticism and skills seems right, just a matter of finding someone who has as much as both.

[DeeSpencer 24,686]

Think we still need a mature ruck back-up.

If both Gawn and Spencer go down then I think we just make do with a combination of King's and Frost/Pedersen.

If we were confident in a mature ruck who would be good enough to be a long term back up I don't think we would've taken Mitch King. Judging from clubs trading the likes of Giles and Curry and North keeping Daw I think the state leagues are pretty bare this year. Heck teams were apparently in to Jamar.

[mo64 5,479]

Hulett and King strike me as your typical rookie list player because they need a few years of development. That seems to suggest that the club didn't rate the mids on offer at those picks. I'd say we may go for someone outside the TAC Cup.

Edited November 25, 2015 by mo64

[rpfc 28,046]

Think we still need a mature ruck back-up.

Spencer is adequate.

[rpfc 28,046]

And if ever you don't worry about 'needs' it is at the Rookie Draft.

You try and get whatever speculative talent you can and hope they take to it like Vanders.

[Left Foot Snap 2,319]

Fifty-5, on 25 Nov 2015 - 08:45 AM, said:Fifty-5, on 25 Nov 2015 - 08:45 AM, said:

Think we still need a mature ruck back-up.

I agree 55. Someone who can play next year if required. I think only two 'available' Ruckmen is leaving a lot to chance. The beauty of doing this through the Rookie draft is you only have to keep them one year. If better options open up you are not so locked in. If they show they are good enough then great. You can't really do that with an 18 yr old who you know will take time. Also don't think many of the DFA ruckmen would have been thrilled by a one year contract and they were probably seen as NQR to offer an extended timeframe and clog the list. I don't see developing talls as clogging the list. You have to invest in them sometime and you need a few through the journey. List clogging with someone who has developed and shown to be deficient is far worse in my eyes. If the Rookie list is used in this way I think it would be a very shrewd move by the club.

Edited November 25, 2015 by Left Foot Snap