GOODBYE MITCH CLARK

[Bitter but optimistic 21,607]

People with Depression are Not Just “Sad”

Just as cell growth is normal in a person, we call out of control cell growth an illness—we call it cancer. Depression is exactly the same. Depression is when a normal, human emotion gets out of control to the point where it is no longer normal. Considering someone with an illness merely to be “sad” is an insult to that person and minimizes an illness that takes thousands of lives every year.

That is both a poor analogy and a simplistic view of depression. Yet a "moderator" gives it a like. As I inferred above, the stupidity I post is one thing but the ignorance that is posted on this site is quite amazing. FMD - I'm going to watch some mindless television.

[Whispering_Jack 28,147]

C & B is kidding himself if he claims knowledge about mental illness. I do charity work for an organisation that looks after, helps feed, find housing and jobs for those unfortunate enough to suffer depression and other mental illness like schizophrenia. It's only when you witness the hardship such people endure and how lonely some of them are, that you can really appreciate that above all else, the well being of the person is paramount. I'm proud of my club for the way it's dealing with this and the other ordeals besetting us at the moment and in the recent past.

I don't feel let down by Mitch Clark's honest and elegant exit as a Demon who "will always consider myself a Melbourne player and a Melbourne person." Disappointed that we won't see him taking those big grabs or kicking goals for us but far more disappointed for Mitch and the pain of his ordeal.

As for clowns like C & B, he proves only that the buffoon is often the best benchmark against which we can judge civilized human behaviour by comparison with the garbage he's been spouting above.

Any more and he'll be facing a long holiday from this site.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

That is both a poor analogy and a simplistic view of depression. Yet a "moderator" gives it a like. As I inferred above, the stupidity I post is one thing but the ignorance that is posted on this site is quite amazing. FMD - I'm going to watch some mindless television.

C&B blew off clinical depression, the most severe form of the illness, as being 'sad'. Stupidity and ignorance all round into one. Stupidity may abound from others but your apparent defense of him, even asking us not to attack him, doesn't make one ounce of sense in this instance.

[JTR 2,698]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lynsu7ZaduE

Only 4 months ago....

Edited April 9, 2014 by JTR

[Little Goffy 13,115]

WCE's handling of Cousin's mental health won them both a premiership.

Or maybe it cost them another one either side of what they got?

I'm not arguing that Cousins should have walked away from football, obviously the circumstances and personal issues are very different. But I'll take 'facing the problem and setting out to do the right thing for the player's well-being' well ahead of 'pretend nothing is wrong, let it run and hope not too many of our players get hospitalised with overdoses'.

[Alcho Dee 269]

Depression is not a defined term, it's based on the individual. C&B is probably struggling to understand why Mitch, being the successful footballer, good looking popular man etc etc suffers from depression. And yes it is sad, a very sad situation. Trying to understand it will leave you even more confused.

[Bitter but optimistic 21,607]

C&B blew off clinical depression, the most severe form of the illness, as being 'sad'. Stupidity and ignorance all round into one. Stupidity may abound from others but your apparent defense of him, even asking us not to attack him, doesn't make one ounce of sense in this instance.

Just caught me. I'm not defending C+B That's his problem.The point I'm trying to make is that debate about such matters (it's not like arguing who is the fastest or can jump the highest) is pointless and should not be encouraged. For all we know C+B might be fighting his own demons. We just Don't know . So rather than misunderstand or hurt - leave it alone.

[old dee 23,292]

Just caught me. I'm not defending C+B That's his problem.The point I'm trying to make is that debate about such matters (it's not like arguing who is the fastest or can jump the highest) is pointless and should not be encouraged. For all we know C+B might be fighting his own demons. We just Don't know . So rather than misunderstand or hurt - leave it alone.

You have my vote bbo for whatever that is worth

[Alcho Dee 269]

C & B is kidding himself if he claims knowledge about mental illness. I do charity work for an organisation that looks after, helps feed, find housing and jobs for those unfortunate enough to suffer depression and other mental illness like schizophrenia. It's only when you witness the hardship such people endure and how lonely some of them are, that you can really appreciate that above all else, the well being of the person is paramount. I'm proud of my club for the way it's dealing with this and the other ordeals besetting us at the moment and in the recent past.

I don't feel let down by Mitch Clark's honest and elegant exit as a Demon who "will always consider myself a Melbourne player and a Melbourne person." Disappointed that we won't see him taking those big grabs or kicking goals for us but far more disappointed for Mitch and the pain of his ordeal.

As for clowns like C & B, he proves only that the buffoon is often the best benchmark against which we can judge civilized human behaviour by comparison with the garbage he's been spouting above.

Any more and he'll be facing a long holiday from this site.

Sorry mate but who are you to judge if C&B has knowledge about mental illness, just because he made a couple of poor comments......?

[Bitter but optimistic 21,607]

You have my vote bbo for whatever that is worth

Plenty!

[Biffen 12,567]

There was a good depression episode once-

when Jason Dunstalls eye socket was pushed into his skull from a Demon knee.

That was my favourite bit of AFL depression .

[Nasher 33,319]

Sorry mate but who are you to judge if C&B has knowledge about mental illness, just because he made a couple of poor comments......?

What sort of question is that? Of course you can question someone's knowledge on a topic based on what they say about it.

[Carlos Danger 380]

Or maybe it cost them another one either side of what they got?

I'm not arguing that Cousins should have walked away from football, obviously the circumstances and personal issues are very different. But I'll take 'facing the problem and setting out to do the right thing for the player's well-being' well ahead of 'pretend nothing is wrong, let it run and hope not too many of our players get hospitalised with overdoses'.

It comes across like you seriously underestimate the value of winning a premiership.

[Demon Head 257]

What sort of question is that? Of course you can question someone's knowledge on a topic based on what they say about it.

Especially when they say they work to help people who suffer from it.

[SaberFang 7,141]

Has there been any word from the playing group about this? I know it's a delicate situation but just hoping they're holding up ok. This is where the leaders in that club absolutely have to step up and unite the group.

[Kali666 3]

It comes across like you seriously underestimate the value of winning a premiership.

How is Ben these days?

[Elusive Tunbridge 795]

I've done nothing of the sort, I have made a prediction. Huge difference.

Not so. Your posts show you have virtually no understanding of depression, so your prediction is made in ignorance. It's just a fantasy of the future of a man you don't know, and like all fantasies it contains a strong element of wishful thinking. Go to the mirror, C&B.

[chook fowler 18,647]

Major depression is a life threatening illness and doesn't correlate with material possessions ir other externals. I think this discussion has gone far enough beyond saying we wish Mitch every happiness for the future

[Gorgoroth 12,447]

I think it's time to close this, too much derp is derp.

[Kali666 3]

Winston Churchill had the black dog depression. Did he give up?

[Demon Dynasty 16,422]

Enjoyed his presence and amazing efforts on the park. Thought he was our great white hope up forward. But alas, another MFC hope dashed yet again.

All the best to Mitch and family. I hope life is better whatever and wherever you head from here big fella.

[Kali666 3]

Enjoyed his presence and amazing efforts on the park. Thought he was our great white hope up forward. But alas, another MFC hope dashed yet again.

All the best to Mitch and family. I hope life is better whatever and wherever you head from here big fella.

yes agree

[Biffen 12,567]

Winston Churchill had the black dog depression. Did he give up?

He only gave up Northern Europe ,and he let the Italians give up the south as they had the experience.

[Guest]

And we are back to our regularly scheduled programming of self righteousness, poorly formed opinions and dark and disturbing thoughts that most sane people keep locked away in the deepest, darkest corners of their minds. All we need now is some incorrect spelling, mangled grammar and chaotically structured syntax and Demonland will be back to it's good old self.
In other news, researchers have discovered that it is possible to never develop an inner monologue!

Edited April 9, 2014 by Colin B. Flaubert

[hardtack 10,187]

Travel to India and observe the beggar children and the human beings living in the slums in their millions. Then talk on here about depression in those on 700,00 dollars per year.

Depression does not necessarily have anything to do with money or social status... it is a mental illness and as such can affect the wealthiest, most comfortably off as much as it can the poor and homeless... in fact, when I was in India, the kids I saw in the slums and the lepers were generally happier than many people I have seen here.

Edited April 9, 2014 by hardtack