AFL NATIONAL DRAFT - Pick 9

[Demon_Tingles 211]

Kade Kolodjashnij

National Carnival Stats:

• Round 1 - 37 disposals, 2 clearances and 5 rebound 50′s.
• Round 2 - 24 disposals and 4 rebounds.
• Round 3 - 27 disposals, 9 marks, and 1 goal.
• Round 4 - 34 touches, 10 marks, 5 inside-50′s and 2 goals
• Round 5 – 15 disposals, 3 marks, 2 clearances and 3 rebound 50′s.

Edited October 21, 2013 by Demon_Tingles

[Go the Biff 3,214]

Kade Kolodjashnij

National Carnival Stats:

KK's video was the most impressive I viewed. I particularly liked his intercept marking & his left foot is a gem. Hit targets both long & short. My question is where does he fit with MFC

Loved everything about Freeman except his kicking. Even in the clear he was missing targets. But his attack on the ball & his speed is tantalising. I'd be interested to hear from someone who'd seen him play a bit whether his disposal efficiency is a concern

Lennon was very impressive but again I wonder if he is a type we need immediately. Really liked his kicking & he seemed to have that little bit of time that good players have

As I watched Sheed's video I began to picture him on the MCG in a Demon jumper, about to pump the ball inside 50. He to me looked like what we need right now. He looked equally at home receiving the ball through running to the right spot as he did going in & getting it. He's not Usain Bolt but he's quicker than I'd been led to believe.

Based on the video (which I acknowledge is a poor means of assessment) that's my four candidates with Sheed slightly ahead in my preference. I would be happy with any of them though

[Demon_Tingles 211]

KK's video was the most impressive I viewed. I particularly liked his intercept marking & his left foot is a gem. Hit targets both long & short. My question is where does he fit with MFC

Quite simple. As I have stated we have no backline players who can consistently hit targets. Kolodjashnij's left foot is a weapon and we can definitely use that coming out of the backline. IMO our rebounding from defence was poor at times last year and he would shore it up a bit.

[Satan 2,828]

Cross

Vince

Tyson

+

Pick 9

+ Hogan

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Cross

Vince

Tyson

+

Pick 9

+ Hogan

+Michie

[Machsy 2,858]

Why did they trade pick 6 then?

Because of 2 reasons...

A. They are not desperate for him, that is hyperbole.

B. He isn't good enough to go at pick 6.

[InVINCEable 358]

I'll be happy if we pick up Sheed, Freeman, Lennon or Kolodashinj

Be stoked with Freeman though.

[Machsy 2,858]

On the comparison between Patrick Dangerfield and Nathan Freeman, "Danger" was drafted by the Crows as a bottom ager in the 2007 national draft when it was still possible to draft 17 year olds (they had to be born between 1 January and 30 April) i.e similar in age to O'Meara, B Crouch, Martin and Hogan. He initially stayed home and played mainly for the Geelong Falcons but I think he got a couple of games for the Crows in late 2008.

Freeman is basically at an equivalent stage to where Dangerfield was at the end of 2008. He's also a fair bit shorter than Dangerfield who is 189cm.

Bang on WJ.

"Dangaz" (as he is called) was played at FF at times also, when playing for the falcons back in Geelong, in his first year on the crows list.

I vaguely remember him kicking 10 goals in a match, before they put a stop to him playing & created a rule that prevented kids on AFL lists from playing TAC Cup. Wasn't expected to on being drafted, but did play a few games for the crows. He lived in Moggs Creek near Angelsea with his family and only went over to Adelaide to train on school holidays.

Also was school captain & gave a graduation speech where he joked about how that year he'd been paid more to muck around in class than any of his teachers were paid to teach him.

A fair smartarse, as his dad was a teacher at the school.

[Lord Travis 10,335]

I'll be happy with any of the mentioned options. They are all talented kids with the potential to add to our midfield.

I'd be happiest if we drafted Freeman though, as I think his pace offers something different to our midfield. We don't have much pace through the middle, and even though he has spent more time at underage level winning inside ball, he clearly has the attributes to be a link up player too. He could become a very well rounded midfielder and feel that speed adds something more for us.

[Dees2014 2,377]

I have a feeling we will go for a midfielder/flanker with height. KK is a big chance to be picked up by us. Left footer who is so clean by foot and can take a mark. Fyfe is a similar player with his height also kolodjashni is a better kick.

You describe Lennon perfectly. I agree with you choice.

[mdemonski2 403]

I had a look at them all and I thought freeman's kicking was ordinary. Not sure we need another turnover merchant at the club.

I loved the look of sheed. Looks tough and a real leader - would play in the guts straight away and I thought his skills looked pretty clean as well.

Lennon and kk both look smooth movers with lovely skills but not sure they will help with our midfield problems straight up.

Sheed for mine. Future co-captain with Viney no doubt.

[tonatopia 278]

I think many of you are tripping. The viney/roos mould of player befits crouch and Freeman, maybe Lennon.

[blue and red in the head 95]

Sheed freeman couch in that order

[dazzledavey36 49,910]

From watching the footage I would go Sheed, Freeman and Dunstan.

Edited October 21, 2013 by dazzledavey36

[Bingo 254]

I think out of all of these probable available players mentioned for pick 9, for me at least, highlights how well we've done in trading pick 2.

Dom Tyson would still be right up there in this draft if he was on the open market. For us to still be able to grab a quality player at pick 9 in a draft where the order of players after Tom Boyd is still basically unknown and the players are so even, is in my eyes a big tick to the Melbourne recruiting staff.

With our midfield taking shape, I wouldn't be surprised if we take a big leap forward nest year.

The KPP's are always the hard ones to replace, and we have a pretty good spine.

I'll be intrigued to see if our instant midfield gels and hope that we all see the results that we have been craving for the last 7 years.

[spirit of norm smith 13,664]

Picks 1 & 2 are Boyd & Scharenberg for me. Then I think its very even for the next dozen.

Aish, Kelly, Billings, Crouch, Sheed,(mcdonald), Freeman, Kolodashnji, Bontempelli, Lennon, Dunstan and Salem. And Lewis Taylor will be very very good as well. We are well placed for pick 9.

[whatwhat say what 20,536]

I agree that gws must recruit Scharenberg, otherwise there was no point to getting pick 2...

Unless of course they on-trade it, which has been mooted.

They have plenty of a similar ilk to Aish, Kelly, Billings etc.

Boyd and Scharenberg is the only deal that makes sense.

[H_T 2,941]

I would not know who the club would pick, this thread is good to read and along with my limited viewing of draftees - that's all I've got to go on. Based on some of the posts here I gather we will be well placed come pick 9, and it will add to our influx of incoming mids into the team.

You can't help but be buoyed at the significant changes, soon it will be up to Roos and his assistants to knuckle down and mould them into a well synergised midfield unit.

Michie, Vince, Tyson and p9 will be welcome additions to that of Jones, Toumpas and Trengove heading up the midfield. And I expect the likes of M.Jones and Kent to have improved significantly on their first year at the club.

[dee-luded 2,958]

That's my thinking. Plus we could really use a flanker with a lethal boot. Helps our defence clear the ball as a few of our defenders don't know how to kick to a target.

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2013-07-15/tassie-twins-prime-draft-prospects

we do, we have to improve markedly off HBF & thru the mids equally.

[Young Dee 1,303]

Its probably already been posted but: This is a really good AFL webpage with a whole lot of Draft analysis etc. (looking forward to the draft machine)

http://www.afl.com.au/2013-draft/draftees/midfielders/

[monoccular 16,731]

I haven't has time to look at all the clips, but I liked the looks of:

Bontempelli - seems to have the ball on a string, and a good left foot kick

Koladjashnij - imaging having a tall left footed HB who can actually kick with precision? Could play off HB or through the guts I reckon. Tasmanian. so no return home factor. :-)

[Young Dee 1,303]

Everyone here seems to have pretty mixed views - I haven't studied this years draftees much but it seems we did the right thing acquiring pick 9 if the top 10 are very similar.

Won't name a player because I don't know enough to say but I would like a player who is both inside and outside mid and have and someone with some pace/height. (I think thats what we lack).

I would also like someone who could come on quickly - not a long term prospect that we could stuff up (Morton) but thats purely because I can't be bothered waiting not because I don't trust Roos.

Who ever we draft I will be comfortable knowing they have a midfield around them that can protect and guide them.

Edited October 22, 2013 by Young Dee

[Vitamin Dee 849]

I think out of all of these probable available players mentioned for pick 9, for me at least, highlights how well we've done in trading pick 2.

Dom Tyson would still be right up there in this draft if he was on the open market. For us to still be able to grab a quality player at pick 9 in a draft where the order of players after Tom Boyd is still basically unknown and the players are so even, is in my eyes a big tick to the Melbourne recruiting staff.

With our midfield taking shape, I wouldn't be surprised if we take a big leap forward nest year.

The KPP's are always the hard ones to replace, and we have a pretty good spine.

I'll be intrigued to see if our instant midfield gels and hope that we all see the results that we have been craving for the last 7 years.

Agree Bingo, and, if we can fly higher than the Hawks, Swans, Magpies, Crows or even the Eagles we will be sprinkling seeds of happiness all around town.

[DeeSpencer 23,695]

Anyone else checked out and liked Blake Acres' highlights. To me he looks every bit as good as Scharenberg and might be the best big bodied midfielder in the draft. He's got strength in the air, composure and neat skills. I'd say he's the reason why West Coast went back to 11 because they'll be happy to get either one of him or Sheed

[dee-luded 2,958]

Anyone else checked out and liked Blake Acres' highlights. To me he looks every bit as good as Scharenberg and might be the best big bodied midfielder in the draft. He's got strength in the air, composure and neat skills. I'd say he's the reason why West Coast went back to 11 because they'll be happy to get either one of him or Sheed

liked the look of him from the Vid'.