WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - JACK VINEY

[Geddy Lee 582]

3 days....

So when we get Viney can we scrub all the Viney threads which are 90% speculation and start off fresh, with a new Viney thread, heralding all that is our new savior, or what?

He's a culture changer apparently.

[Jonesbag 487]

Not sure I'd say that's a reliable source, even though I'd like to believe it's true.

Side note: God I hope we don't trade a first rounder for Dawes.

They usually bring out a source at some stage, still waiting for it though, will post when it arrives

[Demon Disciple 11,138]

Dawes and Rounds for pick 13 and Martin, lol...................lol.

Rounds is a nobody and i believe Martin for Dawes is a fair trade for both teams. So we just throw in pick 13??? yeah, no.

The filth can gagf, if they think they will pries pick 13 off us now that Wellingham is out of the equation.

[PaulRB 6,041]

Rounds is a pick 46 who played 1 game for the pies this year...

I really should have just ignored this.

[Josh 1,420]

Alot of talk about hard decicions and not taking short cuts. I dont keep an eye on the young talent so some other people might be able to comment futher. But if Viney isnt the 3rd best young talent avilable when we take our pick we should not take him simple as that. Pick number 3 means we get the third best player in the draft.

Is Viney the third best?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Is Viney the third best?

Well if Gold Coast choose to bid they rate him as second best.

Again, it's not about how he is rated now, it's how he is rated in a few years time.

[rjay 24,046]

Alot of talk about hard decicions and not taking short cuts. I dont keep an eye on the young talent so some other people might be able to comment futher. But if Viney isnt the 3rd best young talent avilable when we take our pick we should not take him simple as that. Pick number 3 means we get the third best player in the draft.

Is Viney the third best?

Think Dustin Martin v Tom Scully and you get similar to Whitfield v Viney (I know Martin is taller), it's Viney for us.

Is he 3rd best, well I guess that's the debate or part of the debate on here. It would seem there are a group of players similarly rated in top 10 throw up the cards and see which way they land.

Great if we can get him in the 2nd round but on pure player value we lose nothing taking him at 3.

[hardtack 10,158]

Pick number 3 means we get the third best player in the draft.

Is Viney the third best?

Well, I suppose it depends on what the club is after. Midfielders that are ready to go seem to be one of our requirements, and you would have to think Viney fits the bill... so yes, for us, he may well be the 3rd best player in the draft.

We've gone for what were widely considered 1st (and 2nd) best a couple of times in recent drafts... care to reflect on how that has gone for us?

Edited October 5, 2012 by hardtack

[bing181 8,228]

I think this is attempting to make up for the mess we got ourselves in when we announced we'd committed to him all those years ago - we've now got to show ourselves as distant and non-commital to the kid.

The only mess we got ourselves into was the one that came about through only winning 4 games and finishing 3rd bottom. Had we finished 8th, everyone would have been over the moon at getting Viney at pick 14 or whatever.

[spirit of norm smith 13,437]

If we need to use pick #3 for Jack Viney, then YES YES YES YES.

Jack Viney must come to us. He is exactly what we need. Tough. Gets the footy. No backward steps. Jones and Viney would be a start to a tough inside mid group.

Celebrate & welcome Jack aboard. He is NOT going to GWS or GC ... NOT MATTER WHAT.

[Arrow 1,257]

When was the last draft in which the rankings afforded but 'Draft Experts'and the clubs themselves held firm?

There is not a single year in which the top 5 players drafted turned out to the the top 5 players immemorial.

This is exactly right.

Top 5 selecting is not an exact science as sadly we are all too familiar with.

So when a born-leader, son of a club legend who is tough as nails you can take with a dibs on him you'd be stupid not too. Melbourne know what they need to do, and they will.

[bing181 8,228]

Pick number 3 means we get the third best player in the draft.

No it doesn't. All clubs have different needs and perspectives, different game plans, are at different stages in their development etc. etc. One club's pick 3 could be another club's pick 10.

Viney is definitely our pick 3.

[beelzebub 22,350]

tic toc tic toc

not long now folks..just three more sleeps; not that some will

at about 10.30 the rest of trading can resume and then we'll knwo what we're playing with.

Are we holding Jacks...or an Ace up our sleeve

tic toc

[DeeVoted 582]

Cant wait for when the day comes the AFL affilates with ebay

J.Viney as new pick 2 or best offer Paypal only accepted

B.Moloney used but in good nick best offer Cheques accepted or any form of payment ok

bids start at a round 3

Good luck bidding, will ship oveseas.

[monoccular 16,412]

Just about every other father/son pick up at other clubs seem to go through with little fuss and relative cost. I just wonder what the hell Todd Viney is doing or has been doing in his various roles the club for the past few years.

It is nothing to do with anything that Todd has or hasn't done; it is a change in the rules by AFL, introduced unfortunately after Geelong got Scarlett and Hawkins so ridiculously cheaply.

[monoccular 16,412]

No it doesn't. All clubs have different needs and perspectives, different game plans, are at different stages in their development etc. etc. One club's pick 3 could be another club's pick 10.

Viney is definitely our pick 3.

But apparently some think that we don't need a tough, ball hungry, totally aggressive inside mid who has already played against men and acquitted himself well; they must be the ones who feel we should just let him go for another unproven (against men) young 'gun'.

[wattsup 470]

so how did viney go at draft combine he wasnt in the top of any results did he compete surely GC are taking the [censored] saying they will take him

[Jerry Lundergard 392]

so how did viney go at draft combine he wasnt in the top of any results did he compete surely GC are taking the [censored] saying they will take him

Why don't you go back over all the draft combine Top-10 results and come back to us with a list of superstars who are in there.

Then I will counter it with a list of champion footballers that are not.....

[Jack7 463]

It's Viney at pick 3,DONE!

Only the MFC could [censored] this up.

Cale Morton won the Larke Medal and he's been $hitting himself ever since at AFL level.

We need Viney at ANY cost to show our peaheart mids (bar Jones) what tough contested footy is.

[Grimseyisgod 378]

its becoming very clear to me that we are going to take him.. we cannot pass this one up.

[Fox in a box 3]

Off topic, nice avatar Jack 7

If I am not mistaken, that is the 50ft Italian cruiser' Aqua Bay'. A magnificent cruiser I have had the pleasure of enjoying.

Ever been on it yourself?

Fox

[Nineteen 159]

Viney has been assessed as 8^th best buy professional analysts.

If u think he is better - that’s a separate argument.

A hard negotiator would make the Suns aware that the MFC won’t be using #3 to recover Viney, if they select him at #2.

The Suns would then know that they would be using their valuable No 2 pick on an 8^th ranked player.

The Suns hierarchy later would go ballistic if they find their recruiters have taken an 8th best player at No 2. The net result would be that they pass on the 2^nd best ranked player & we probably pick him up. Then the late 2014 threat that Viney goes to the draft after 2 years. The Suns are facing a lose/lose option IF WE HAVE THE FORTITUDE TO PLAY HARD BALL(?).

And if the Suns genuinely believe we won’t activate the F&S rule they CAN NOT SELECT Viney unless they really want him over however is No 2..

Our recruiter/selectors are duty bound to pick the best available player by taking a hard cold approach.

Football is way too serious for heart to rule head on this one. Take the small risk.

[ILLDieADemon 804]

I'm over reading about this, they will pick him where have to.

[Axis of Bob 10,379]

Viney has been assessed as 8^th best buy professional analysts.

Says who? Your entire post is based on that assumption. Back it up.

[TheoX 1,218]

Says who? Your entire post is based on that assumption. Back it up.

There was an article a few weeks ago saying several AFL recruiters rated him 6-8 in the draft, must be what's referred to i think