Harley Reid

[Want a Flag 46]

27 minutes ago, Stiff Arm said:

Many commentators have claimed knowledge of Grundy going to Port Adelaide.

Wasn't he from SA originally?

Yes he is originally from SA but is settled in Melbourne and wanted to stay in Victoria. That may have changed now but who knows.

As an aside he recently moved into the suburb where I live and he has been around quite a bit naturally. Stating the obvious but he is absolutely huge as all these guys are when you see them up close. 

Edited August 3, 2023 by Want a Flag
Woops another typo - guys

[Lord Travis 10,184]

14 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Interesting news if true.

I'm a big Gresham fan and truly believe his development has been stunted due to St Kilda's poor development over the years.

His numbers as a midfield forward certainly stacks up well and could add some genuine X factor to our side.

I’d be keen on Gresham if he didn’t cost much since he’s on the outer this year under Lyon. It wasn’t that long ago he was basically Saints best player or close to. I had him in a work supercoach league competition and kept a close eye on him. He’s a good forward mid whose past year or two have been derailed by injury and clashing with Lyon as a coach. If his body is right, change of scenery could see him return to his best. When healthy and in form, he’s an upgrade on Nibbler, Chandler, Spargo etc. Will listen with interest. 

[dazzledavey36 48,912]

2 minutes ago, Lord Travis said:

I’d be keen on Gresham if he didn’t cost much since he’s on the outer this year under Lyon. It wasn’t that long ago he was basically Saints best player or close to. I had him in a work supercoach league competition and kept a close eye on him. He’s a good forward mid whose past year or two have been derailed by injury and clashing with Lyon as a coach. If his body is right, change of scenery could see him return to his best. When healthy and in form, he’s an upgrade on Nibbler, Chandler, Spargo etc. Will listen with interest. 

100% agree.

[whatwhat say what 19,144]

1 hour ago, Want a Flag said:

Yes you are correct. I was careless in typing. They believe Gresham will end up at Melbourne as part of the whole wash up. How they come to that conclusion I don't know.

However I think them wanting Grundy makes sense from their point of view.

what role would he play for us? he doesn't have the running capacity of anb as an example, and i don't see him as a gut-running wingman a la langdon or hunter

i'm not convinced his ball use is that good either, as per @DistrACTION Jackson's stats above

[MrFreeze 1,400]

2 hours ago, Redleg said:

I would have thought that they are one club that don’t need him with Motlop, Owies, Durdin, Cunningham, Fogarty etc.

I think he's a better mid-forward than the rest. But he would join the one too many ball butchers club for them however.

[Deemania since 56 6,180]

On 7/23/2023 at 10:48 AM, old55 said:

Jason Taylor has an impeccable record with mids, not just the players we've drafted but the ones he has coveted e.g. Butters, Humphrey. I have total faith he'll have a definite view on Reid and other possibilities like Duursma.  We will actually be in a position to execute on his plan with the Freo pick.

It will be interesting to see where Curtin is expected to fall and that will influence WC. North have a lot of mids and he may appeal to them more than say McKercher, especially if they succeed in their bid for Sanders. They may have two picks before our Freo pick too via McKay.

Duursma - smokey No.1 - talent to learn, versatility to apply to several roles, good footballing blood. 

[John Demonic 4,830]

If I'm stkilda I'm wanting Carlton to make the contract offer a 800k size one to Gresham to take it to tier 1, so my compo will be straight after my first round pick at what I think will be pick around pick 9 or 10. Might be the condition that they don't match, as he's RESTRICTED FA

Then I'm offering those two picks and next year's 1st for Reid in the Reid-stakes.

LOL.

Bringing this thread back on topic people!!!!

 

Edited August 3, 2023 by John Demonic

[Gorgoroth 12,331]

Gresham would be nice, 70/30 fwd to mid, Trac the opposite. Upgrade on a lot of our smalls. Wouldn’t give up much for him tho. Great if free.

[Mach5 4,482]

Gresham would spell trouble for Bill Laurie. 

Questionable disposal at times & has exhibited some very selfish behaviour at times (or self-preserving) but his agility & evasion can be elite.

I think he’d cost more than we’d want to pay however.

[rjay 23,927]

1 hour ago, Mach5 said:

Gresham would spell trouble for Bill Laurie. 

Questionable disposal at times & has exhibited some very selfish behaviour at times (or self-preserving) but his agility & evasion can be elite.

I think he’d cost more than we’d want to pay however.

Reading between some not too subtle lines I think they're trying to get rid of him 'Mach'...

Probably for some of the reasons you've mentioned above.

I that case would we be interested, not sure he's a Goody type.

[dee-tox 4,827]

5 hours ago, rjay said:

Reading between some not too subtle lines I think they're trying to get rid of him 'Mach'...

Probably for some of the reasons you've mentioned above.

I that case would we be interested, not sure he's a Goody type.

Think money is the issue rjay. Apparently wants more than is being offered.

[Travy14 1,508]

20 hours ago, Want a Flag said:

Word I am hearing is the Saints will make a play for Grundy so Marshall can spend more time forward. They want to send Gresham to us as part of the trade.

Whilst I see this, do you think Grundy would go for that pitch again?

[Travy14 1,508]

Gresham is a hack, we should avoid big time!

If Grundy goes to Port they have a Collingwood (ironically) 2nd round pick which would be good or I would be interested in Georgiades if they take on Grundy's full contract!!

[Nascent 7,340]

champ highlights

 

[Redleg 37,780]

1 hour ago, Nascent said:

champ highlights

 

If we can get him without selling the farm, it is going to be very hard for JT to not do the deal.

Noted the comments in his last senior country game of the the other teams’ coach. “Harley  destroyed us on his own and won the game for his team”.

Then you read that a couple of AFL recruiters are saying he is the best kid they have seen.

I can see a very busy DL post season, hopefully with us as Premiers.

 

[binman 38,588]

1 hour ago, Nascent said:

champ highlights

 

Blimey.

I thought he was a forward?

Looks like the bont with his skills in the middle.

[Binmans PA 26,261]

He can do it all I reckon.

Some of those fend offs feel more like Trac fend offs than Dusty fend offs. They're less about simply bullocking through a contest, but giving himself time to cleanly feed off by hand.

He's a smooth mover though and looks super dangerous one out in the forward half. That to me is very Trac, and even very Dangerfield.

Imagine our team with Reid. Wowee.

[demoncat 642]

1 hour ago, Redleg said:

If we can get him without selling the farm, it is going to be very hard for JT to not do the deal.

Noted the comments in his last senior country game of the the other teams’ coach. “Harley  destroyed us on his own and won the game for his team”.

Then you read that a couple of AFL recruiters are saying he is the best kid they have seen.

I can see a very busy DL post season, hopefully with us as Premiers.

 

I’m almost of the opinion that he’s worth it even if we do sell the farm 👀

Elite talent wins you flags and if Reid is truly a cut above the rest of the draft crop, I’d rather go all in on trying to get pick 1 than trying to nab multiple players who - albeit may be very good - are less likely to be that next Dusty, Trac, Bont type of player that contenders are built around 

All depends how JT rates him though!

[Edm 91]

The other thing I like about Reid is his versatility 

Got a bit of Luke hodge about him being able to play different positions and dominate wherever 

[John Demonic 4,830]

1 hour ago, binman said:

Blimey.

I thought he was a forward?

Looks like the bont with his skills in the middle.

The more I see, the less likely I feel like we can get this done.

 

[binman 38,588]

18 minutes ago, John Demonic said:

The more I see, the less likely I feel like we can get this done.

 

Because he looks so good?

I'm clueless about all the draft and trading machinations, but one advantage we might have is the suggestion he has told the Eagles he will do a Horne Francis if they draft him (which apparently his manager has flatly denied)

The Eagles have pick one and of course will want him. But if they are worried he might bail after two seasons, then perhaps they might figure a couple of first rounders, say pick 4 and 15, and a decent player might be of more value to them - particularly because they will be in a rebuild phase and they need to be bring in multiple quality players (which is where we landed when we decided to go with Hunt and Salo rather Josh Kelly)

[Colm 1,477]

I was already of the opinion that we must recruit a quality key defender via trade or the draft and that was before Petty’s breakout game at the weekend. 
If he can continue to play well we’ll up front then I think the need is even greater. 
I know we have Disco and Adam’s in the twos but are they going to provide the quality we need to replace May and Petty. Tommo has done ok since he came in but he’s close to the end and rumoured to be looking for a trade. A case could be made that we need to bring in a couple of Key defenders. 
 

If we trade for Reid I think we still have to have enough capital to snag a very talented key defender as well. So we either need Tim Lamb to works some serious magic to secure both or we need JT to be able to pick one up a bit later in the draft like he did with Petty. 

[Roost it far 6,235]

Just get him, he's Trac MK 2. The 2023 upgrade. We'll win so many Premiership Cups we'll need a new trophy cabinet.

[Redleg 37,780]

5 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

Just get him, he's Trac MK 2. The 2023 upgrade. We'll win so many Premiership Cups we'll need a new trophy cabinet.

I would happily pay for the cabinet.

[Lord Travis 10,184]

2 hours ago, Redleg said:

If we can get him without selling the farm, it is going to be very hard for JT to not do the deal.

You have to sell the farm to get him, and on evidence it would be worth it.

2 hours ago, binman said:

Blimey.

I thought he was a forward?

Looks like the bont with his skills in the middle.

He’s a dominant inside/outside midfielder who’s played half back and up forward. He played more forward this year due to a head knock and easing back into it post concussion. He dominated everywhere and showed great marking and kicking skills to add the contested side and decision making. I said it a few pages back, but he’s the next Trac. To get him and have him learn from Trac and interchange the two between midfield and forward would be a devastating combo.

Sell the farm!