Apparently has been put on the trade table by the pies.

24 year old with 82 games under his belt.

 

Just feels like we need to focus on the other end of the ground now though.

Not against it, but only if he was dirt cheap.

 

Would’ve preferred Jamie Elliott.

 

He's the sort of player you would be excited about if you got him for a 4th or 5th round pick.

 

Nah, only kidding. I can't think of any pick that would make me excited.

He’s turned out to be a better player but he reminds me of Toumpas. Amongst other things both are/were timid when it comes to contact. 

1 minute ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

He’s turned out to be a better player but he reminds me of Toumpas. Amongst other things both are/were timid when it comes to contact. 

Yep, too soft for my liking.

I saw a report Tom Phillips is also on the table... Wish we got him instead of Tomlinson

23 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Apparently has been put on the trade table by the pies.

24 year old with 82 games under his belt.

 

No Dazz squib!! We already have a couple on our own list NO

Edited October 13, 20196 yr by picket fence

18 minutes ago, Collar-Jazz-Knee said:

I saw a report Tom Phillips is also on the table... Wish we got him instead of Tomlinson

That is surprising.

Aish has not been able to cut it now at two clubs.

No Thanks!

Edited October 13, 20196 yr by old dee

Have we not learnt....don't trust Collingwood! 

If someone is on offer, it is either bluff ( Elliot) or they are just no good.

??????

list clogger.

No thanks.  I'd prefer to take a punt on an 'unknown' with potential, rather than a known quantity who has fallen a long way short of expectations. 

St Kilda will probably sign him.

1 minute ago, Deeoldfart said:

No thanks.  I'd prefer to take a punt on an 'unknown' with potential, rather than a known quantity who has fallen a long way short of expectations. 

Could not agree more.

Toumpas 2.0

If we had any interest, which I would think we didn't, the only positive would be that the Pies are probably more than willing to get rid of him quickly and cheaply, so we could get him for next to nothing.

However, I don't think he's even close to what we need.  Strikes me as someone the Crows might chase as he's an SA boy.

Pass.

1 hour ago, Collar-Jazz-Knee said:

I saw a report Tom Phillips is also on the table... Wish we got him instead of Tomlinson

If Phillips is on the table we should still go after him...

100% yes on Phillips. only consideration is what they want in return. 

Big Pass.

I wonder if the crows would welcome him with open arms given the number of players headed out the door.

 

Nah, we need to improve, not get the pies nqr player/players.?

Bit of a wAisht of list spaisht

10 hours ago, picket fence said:

No Dazz squib!! We already have a couple on our own list NO

Shocking comment. Takes a lot of courage playing this game. Who squibs on our list?