Let's be frank about GWS

[McQueen 17,867]

Roos does his best to whack the Giants from as many angles as possible in this article. Although veiled, it's obvious to me that there's some real resentment from Roos on the expansion club and how they came into being - that from a man who prides himself on leadership and being mindful to me smacks of a little bit of hypocrisy.

I think Sheedy's dig about Roos being a single premiership coach (a few months ago) did sting quite a bit and Roos has gone some way to delivering some level of public defence in this regard.

Still nice to read Roos talking about being a Melbourne supporter.

Let's be frank about GWS

 

[biggestred 5,243]

Well the afl basically [censored] fitzroy in the ass then created this monstrosity and have been pouring money in ever since. 

Id be bitter too

[homsar 431]

[censored] that. I love Roosy. 

[Lucifers Hero 40,524]

I think Roos' love of the Dees is genuine:  "This is my fourth year back in Melbourne, I grew up in Melbourne, I barrack for Melbourne, go to Melbourne games with a Melbourne scarf on when I’m not working..."

He spent his football life batting for the underdog and finally won a Swans flag but only after resurrecting the 'The Bloods' spirit from the perennial underdog; South Melbourne.

So it is not surprising that the creation of a silver tail team (Giants) would not cut the mustard with him.

Roos will always be my hero especially after reading this:  "....If they (GWS) were to win a premiership, fine. I’d rather Melbourne win it

 

[deebug 1,754]

I hate gws sooo much, they should NOT be an AFL side. If those f wits get a Grand Final spot it will be the first time in VFL/AFL history i will not even bother about watching any of it at all

[deelete my account 1,194]

Do people actually care about GWS winning the premiership beyond a 5 second outburst of annoyance and a 20 minute feeling of dread once the result is inevitable? I've lived through a Hawthorn 3peat, who cares. Switch the TV off and do something else and re-start the season. Go Dees. If they can win it, so be it. If they can't, so be it. idgaf about externals. Sydney's 15 year finals streak is evidence of the manufactured nature of AFL, so i won't get too [censored] off about the Dees not overcoming the mountain just yet. They're up against a lot.

Edited September 21, 2017 by Deeprived Childhood

[DubDee 26,306]

hard to see GWS not winning 3 from the next 5 flags now that Kelly and whitfield etc have signed

they were smashed by injuries this year and still made the prelim at least

the next best teams around are Crows/Geelong/Tigers/sydney.  no other power teams around

Love Roosy by the way

[Diamond_Jim 12,692]

Have no problems with GWS as I have absolutely no emotional (good or bad) interest in the team or its players. I am however very interested in them as a team.

They are like a Fantasy football team or as others have called it a "science experiment." The perfect test of a team of champions against a champion teams and all those other cliches.

When Bulldogs won last year I was gutted as it just emphasised how bad MFC has been for so many years. Nothing like that with a GWS win.

Go the Orange Men !!

[Ethan Tremblay 31,243]

GWS winning the Grand Final would be the equivalent of McDonalds buying itself a Michelin Star.

[Tony Tea 2,814]

I don't like GWS, I don't even think they should have been started, but I hope they beat Richmond.

[Ethan Tremblay 31,243]

1 minute ago, Tony Tea said:

I don't like GWS, I don't even think they should have been started, but I hope they beat Richmond.

Would you not prefer to see Richmond make the GF then get thumped? 

[Tony Tea 2,814]

1 hour ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Would you not prefer to see Richmond make the GF then get thumped? 

I'd prefer to see the Tiges beaten in the Prelim. after the siren.

[McQueen 17,867]

I would like to think that if GWS wins the flag, most of the crowd vacates the G in disgust.

I know I won't be watching any celebration from the oompa loompas.

[Sir Why You Little 37,311]

Too all those CEO's who with an AFL Gun pointed at their collective skulls and who "unanimously" voted for GW$ to be created and steal all of the countries young Talent. 

Your moment has arrived. 

Cameron Schwab as a Richmond man must be so nervous today. 

He was in the original GW$ think tank

[Jibroni 5,035]

3 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Would you not prefer to see Richmond make the GF then get thumped? 

The scary part is I think they might beat Adelaide as its at the G. For one time only I wouldnt mind a Giants win.

[Pennant St Dee 13,403]

I hate GWS they and the Suns are not football clubs. I was away on a dads and lads weekend last week surrounded by 20 odd Meth Coast supporters. Myself my boy and 2 of the other young lads were cheering for the Giants but this week I hope the Tigers belt the bejesus out of them

[beelzebub 23,390]

Let's be ..

 

[Ungarie boy 233]

My boy was involved in the GWS academy this year and consequently I have had a lot more exposure to them.  I'll be cheering loudly for them now, for they have done more for the Canberra and Southern NSW region in the last couple of years than the AFL and all other fly by clubs (North, Sydney, Dee's) put together.  If this then equates to more AFL players in the region, meaning more teams, stronger competitions and then greater opportunity for our kids (hopefully my youngest would benefit from all this) to develop, then that's an even better reason.  Being  involved in coaching and I can categorically state it is so much more difficult for talented players in the Canberra/NSW Region (excluding Murray) to make it - for you don't develop the necessary AFL skills my beating up on consistently weaker opponents.

As to the money, well the AFL will only find another way to spend it. Probably by help building a summer training centre for the Magpies; or maybe taking over the Netball competition; or maybe giving it to the clubs who will promptly spend it all on one elite player, another dozen coaches and (for some) a suspect medical program harvesting cows!!!!

Besides seeing the tigers get there with there easy draw, or having any team coached by a  Scott being involved; is more gut churdling than Coke mixed with 10 day old milk that has been left in the Queensland sun on a fly infested pig farm.

 

Edited September 22, 2017 by Ungarie boy

[H_T 3,049]

What I like about it is he doesn't mince words and as he said, he's not re-writing history. GWS was born as a result of North not going to Gold Coast and the AFL having to go "bang bang" in adding a 17th and 18th team to the competition. 

He paints a very true picture of the shenanigans the Giants played up in NSW and the insults that followed. 

And Sheedy can GAGF.

[Sir Why You Little 37,311]

20 minutes ago, Ungarie boy said:

My boy was involved in the GWS academy this year and consequently I have had a lot more exposure to them.  I'll be cheering loudly for them now, for they have done more for the Canberra and Southern NSW region in the last couple of years than the AFL and all other fly by clubs (North, Sydney, Dee's) put together.  If this then equates to more AFL players in the region, meaning more teams, stronger competitions and then greater opportunity for our kids (hopefully my youngest would benefit from all this) to develop, then that's an even better reason.  Being  involved in coaching and I can categorically state it is so much more difficult for talented players in the Canberra/NSW Region (excluding Murray) to make it - for you don't develop the necessary AFL skills my beating up on consistently weaker opponents.

As to the money, well the AFL will only find another way to spend it. Probably by help building a summer training centre for the Magpies; or maybe taking over the Netball competition; or maybe giving it to the clubs who will promptly spend it all on one elite player, another dozen coaches and (for some) a suspect medical program harvesting cows!!!!

Besides seeing the tigers get there with there easy draw, or having any team coached by a  Scott being involved; is more gut churdling than Coke mixed with 10 day old milk that has been left in the Queensland sun on a fly infested pig farm.

 

Sounds like you will be a GW$ Member soon

Do enjoy the plastic club

[beelzebub 23,390]

12 minutes ago, H_T said:

And Sheedy can GAGF.

You had me @ 

[FireInTheBennelly 4,101]

Who's Frank, and does he want to return to Victoria? Carlton bound for sure.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

I'd like to see GWS beat Adelaide in the GF. Would be lucky to get 75,000 there, most of whom would be corporate or allocated tickets. GWS winning would raise a lot of resentment and questions from the broader football community. While Ungarie boy raises some interesting points, I doubt there is transparency with regards to $ spent on and by GWS, certainly not much fairness compared to other clubs. I don't know how they have any chance of sustaining themselves with so few members and WW1 crowds. If they are always to be propped up, there seems little point. I get that clubs have down patches (as we have), but it's hard to sustain a club that so few follow

However, i definitely would be happy for Rich and Geelong to get a hiding, especially the tigers.

Edited September 22, 2017 by Moonshadow

[Ungarie boy 233]

1 hour ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Sounds like you will be a GW$ Member soon

Do enjoy the plastic club

That won't happen.  Red and Blue through and through.

Though I know many who are taking out GWS membership, as it pretty much guarantees a Grand Final ticket should GWS make it - as when ballots are held for the two grand final team members, they have about a 99 in 100 chance of getting selected!

[DubDee 26,306]

You can be frank all you like,

Once I can be earnest