Changes for next week v Geelong

[bandicoot 1,395]

Out - Lewis and hogan (suspension)

In - Vince and pederson 

like for like imo

[boydie 655]

Out: Hogan (if susp), Lewis (if susp), Brayshaw

In: Vince, Kent (Hogan), Bugg (Lewis)

I'm normally one that's happy to have Pedo back in the side, but Plapp has come out and stated that Bugg could do no more to warrant selection this week.

Might be worth going smaller and trying to run Geelong of their feet at Etihad.

[DeeSpencer 26,328]

1 hour ago, Redleg said:

We have enough poor skilled players in defence without adding another.

He can kick a goal, take a grab and is aggressive. He can apply defensive pressure as a forward.

Players like Jetta and Salem hardly waste a possession and are great coming out of the backline, setting up play.

Harmes is just not highly skilled and will leak goals as he did yesterday, if played down back.

He looked far more comfortable later in the game when he got the ball around midfield and created play running forward.

Unlike all those other defenders out of the side who have great skills? I'd rather Vince, Wagner and Hibberd but I think Harmes was our best option on the weekend. Now Bernie is back there's a decision to be made but Lewis out might fix that.

I can't recall what his 3 turnovers were that led directly to goals. 

What I loved about his game was his work ethic to stick on a man (and a fast one in Armfield) and lay some tackles. Too many of our other defenders - McDonald x 2 but more so Oscar, Melksham, Lewis and often Vince don't tackle. 

His best position is probably on the wing in a game that can see him run in to contests and push back and forward with the flight of the ball, but I'm not against using him as part of the backline rotation 

[P-man 13,366]

Not convinced on Melksham. Misses too many easy targets for a relatively senior player. Straight swap for Vince.

Won't happen. It'll be someone like Hannan or ANB unfortunately. I'm not much of a Harmes fan but you can't drop him after yesterday's effort. 

Pedo and Kent in for Hogan and Lewis, suspensions pending.

Gus had a poor day but that's the extent of it for me. He'll be right.

[poita 3,913]

Vince for Melksham is a no brainer for me. Jake may be more suited to playing up the ground, but there is no way he pushes out any of our current midfielders. His disposal is below poor, and I his lack of physicality concerns me.

If Lewis misses, Bugg can come in. If Hogan misses, Pedersen can come in.

Kent on stand by if Hannan is quiet again. Frost needs to come in shortly as well.

[Wunders 397]

In Vince for Lewis (like for like)

In Spencer for Hogan (like for like)

Then consider a Frost/Wagner for _____ & consider a Kent for a ______ (but in both cases i'm unsure who really).

I'd love to not play Spencer and go in small (Kent for Hogan and see if we can run Geelong off their feet, but now [and only now] would I be happy with a Spencer in). Spencer out next week for Hogan.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,049]

5 minutes ago, Wunders said:

In Vince for Lewis (like for like)

In Spencer for Hogan (like for like)

Then consider a Frost/Wagner for _____ & consider a Kent for a ______ (but in both cases i'm unsure who really).

I'd love to not play Spencer and go in small (Kent for Hogan and see if we can run Geelong off their feet, but now [and only now] would I be happy with a Spencer in). Spencer out next week for Hogan.

Never thought I would see the expression "Spencer for Hogan (like for like)" on Demonland. Or anywhere else.

[Demon Dynasty 17,135]

2 hours ago, bandicoot said:

Out - Lewis and hogan (suspension)

In - Vince and pederson 

like for like imo

I like your style bandicoot

[DistrACTION Jackson 10,251]

Now we know Lewis and Hogan are definitely out I'd like to see the following:

Outs: Lewis, Hogan

Ins: Vince, Spencer

This will allow Watts to play forward the entire match and also mean Gawn can spend less time in the ruck and try to stretch the Geelong defence.

[brendan 3,445]

I guess we will find out what we are made of for next few weeks, I hope everyone can rise to the challenge 

[whatwhat say what 23,479]

out: lewis, hogan, brayshaw
in: vince, frost, kent

i say we 'go small' against geelong and try and run them off their feet.

[Gator 17,975]

There's not a hope in hell Spencer comes in for Hogan.

[godees 892]

Frost only played a half for Casey - won't come in this week

[mo64 5,883]

7 minutes ago, DemonAndrew said:

out: lewis, hogan, brayshaw
in: vince, frost, kent

i say we 'go small' against geelong and try and run them off their feet.

I agree. With Lonergan, Taylor and Mackie in their backline, it's pointless trying to beat the Cats in the air or allow them to play an 8 man backline against our 6 forwards. As with the Saints, we need to lower our eyes and hit short leading targets. 

Playing Spencer would be utter stupidity. Petracca should start deeper, and used in a Hogan role. ANB tags Touhy, and the Cats don't have much run out of the backline. I watched the entire North game, and the Cats backline looked slow.

[Demon Dynasty 17,135]

25 minutes ago, DemonAndrew said:

out: lewis, hogan, brayshaw
in: vince, frost, kent

i say we 'go small' against geelong and try and run them off their feet.

 

5 minutes ago, mo64 said:

I agree. With Lonergan, Taylor and Mackie in their backline, it's pointless trying to beat the Cats in the air or allow them to play an 8 man backline against our 6 forwards. As with the Saints, we need to lower our eyes and hit short leading targets. 

Playing Spencer would be utter stupidity. Petracca should start deeper, and used in a Hogan role. ANB tags Touhy, and the Cats don't have much run out of the backline. I watched the entire North game, and the Cats backline looked slow.

I like the overall strategy and the changes here with the exception of Frost. Dont think he is ready just yet and with Vince returning in the back half pushing forward i would rather have his experience and pressure here.

Vince, Kent & Pedders. Pedders as the tall to replace Hoges who can also pinch hit in the ruck while Maxy rests forward. Need some tallness in the forward line for the quick long kicks out of the center or when under pressure up field.

[PaulRB 6,432]

Has Peders actually been playing for us at Casey? have heard nothing on him doing anything of note for months..?

 

[dazzledavey36 55,912]

Its obvious that Pedersen comes in. Plaus the ruck role alot better then Watts which then forces him to a forward role full time.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Vince should tag Dangerfield.

Dangerfield will just rove to Gawn all day.

[Deemented Are Go! 3,704]

3 hours ago, bandicoot said:

Out - Lewis and hogan (suspension)

In - Vince and pederson 

like for like imo

This. Simples. 

 

[old dee 24,005]

4 minutes ago, PaulRB said:

Has Peders actually been playing for us at Casey? have heard nothing on him doing anything of note for months..?

 

This from Melon in the Casey report

" Pederson - Better than last week and competed well in the air. "

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,049]

2 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Vince should tag Dangerfield.

Dangerfield will just rove to Gawn all day.

I'm not sure Vince has got the speed to go with Dangerfield. Admittedly, probably no-one has, but it appears to me that Vince has slowed considerably compared with what he showed in 2015. I'm not sure that "tagging" is in Goodwin's repertoire anyway.

Edit: Hunt would have the speed to go with Dangerfield, but I'd rather Hunt play the half-back role and let Geelong worry about him instead.

Edited April 3, 2017 by La Dee-vina Comedia

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

Wagner very underrated around here.

Not sure if there's a spot for him, maybe vince replaces lewy and wager for vinces role.

Harmes forward 

 

[dino rover 714]

Jeffy Clark and Hannan is a very fast bunch of small forwards vs a slow old cats defence

[Demon Dynasty 17,135]

11 minutes ago, PaulRB said:

Has Peders actually been playing for us at Casey? have heard nothing on him doing anything of note for months..?

 

If he isn't right then there's no other alternative. We need to call in .....THE BULL!!

Edited April 3, 2017 by Rusty Nails

[Demon Dynasty 17,135]

4 minutes ago, dino rover said:

Jeffy Clark and Hannan is a very fast bunch of small forwards vs a slow old cats defence

Hopefully we can add Kent for Brayshaw and add to that speed problem dino