James Sellar

[boydie 655]

Anyone know how long is contract is?

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

Slowest player I've ever seen. When running he looks like he's wading through Port Phillip Bay with seaweed caught around his legs. Being slow in itself, while not desirable, would be OK if he compensated with deft tap work or strong contested marks. But he doesn't seem to have those skills, either.

Yeah all true - i wonder how long he will draw defenders because he doesnt look like he can do anything other than stand at this stage. He did do a few decent taps.

[Little Richard 6,265]

He seems to have some hunger - I've seen a few optimistic chases and uses his body well but as has been said, just way to slow. Crashes the packs well, wouldn't mind a mark now and then though!

[Nasher 33,617]

If he could mark he'd be a good player. As it is he's a less athletic Stefan Martin that wins less of the ball.

[Nasher 33,617]

Anyone know how long is contract is?

Came on a 1 year contract I believe.

[skills32 229]

Anyone know how long is contract is?

About 12 inches

by 8inches wide

[east gippsland demon 7]

move him on no good

[old dee 24,003]

If he could mark he'd be a good player. As it is he's a less athletic Stefan Martin that wins less of the ball.

Extremely good description Nasher

[dazzledavey36 55,888]

wheres all the love for this bloke!? pulled bellchambers and ryders pants down and took the game saving mark! cops a bit on here but boy jee he looked good down back! id give him first hand on cloke next week.

well done james you played a ripper!!

[stuie 7,374]

Was pretty good tonight, loved that Neeld had the balls to do what we've all wanted for 3 years, put Garland forward, and credit to Sellar for doing his job to make it work.

[Keepin up with the Joneses 48]

wheres all the love for this bloke!? pulled bellchambers and ryders pants down and took the game saving mark! cops a bit on here but boy jee he looked good down back! id give him first hand on cloke next week.

well done james you played a ripper!!

credit where credit is due!

thought he was huge!

[Maldonboy38 6,406]

Sellar was very good, and tonight he showed he can kick and run. I have to admit being very surprised but he definitely earned his place tonight.

[Jaded No More 68,975]

Defender or Casey. Now we know.

[Bad Demon Pun 15]

Gotta say he wasn't bad, not great but certainly not bad. Fingers crossed Frawley in for old Macdonald then next week.

[fired up 77]

His coming out game,was staunch.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Needs another good one next week.

Perspective says he's had one good match for the season so far.

Here's hoping he gains confidence and cements a spot in the side. Big body and has some talent.

And wasn't it great to see the joy and passion on Clarks face when the siren went! Only been in the club for a short time but wants us to win desperately. Copped a heavy knock in lower back early in the match.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Yeah Sellar has coped a bit hasn't he; good game tonight all he needs is a bit of confidence.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Needs another good one next week.

Perspective says he's had one good match for the season so far.

Here's hoping he gains confidence and cements a spot in the side. Big body and has some talent.

And wasn't it great to see the joy and passion on Clarks face when the siren went! Only been in the club for a short time but wants us to win desperately. Copped a heavy knock in lower back early in the match.

Clark looked like we had just won a flag, he seems rapt to be at Melbourne.

[monoccular 17,642]

Certainly will need another one like tonight next week with the gorilla Cloke. Fitted into the defence very well.

Poor Blease can't take a trick - did anyone see if it was a kick?

If Frawley is back it will allow Garland Another hit up forward vs the Filth.

Good coaching and selection.

[Forest Demon 4,681]

Said it before, but he spent all pre-season playing back and looked ok and then as soon as the real stuff starts he goes forward, looked completely lost and was just generally not up to it. Goes back tonight and plays a pearler.

Actually has a lot of good traits as a defender who can play on the resting ruckmen or gorilla forwards. Will watch with interest over the next few weeks, and hopefully he stays back.

[Sideshow Bob 2,462]

Why wasn't Sellar in the middle of the song with Clark and Magner? New boys first win I would have thought?

[Ron Burgundy 8,587]

Very good game tonight. Good pick up on tonight's form.

[JT9 104]

Yep hes a back, not a forward and gives us options with Garland

Would still like to see Tom Mac get the job on Cloke though

[Je Roos Salem 661]

He was far better as a defender than i've seen as a forward/ruck. He could hardly get a touch in that role and he got 18 possessions tonight and kept Ryder out of the game completely

[Bobby McKenzie 2,401]

Gotta say he wasn't bad, not great but certainly not bad. Fingers crossed Frawley in for old Macdonald then next week.

Nevertheless, Old MacDonald wasn't bad tonight was he?