MATCH PREVIEW AND TEAM SELECTION - Round 8

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,696]

I may have high expectations but expecting Weed to have a 22 possession, 14 mark, 5 goal game. I know he'll only be playing on the best full back in the league in Talia....but....

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Hogan out now makes this a real blowout danger. Sort of hoping we say screw the tall options and just put run in. Weed will get slaughtered by Talia. Real shame this.

[deelete my account 1,194]

Was it confirmed that Weidemann was injured in the game I think against Freo? He was jogging around with leg strapping. It's the only positive I can take from the situation of Hogan missing and perhaps Weideman playing a more fit and firing game than before.

Edited May 12, 2017 by DominatrixTyson

[daisycutter 28,730]

4 minutes ago, DominatrixTyson said:

Was it confirmed that Weidemann was injured in the game I think against Freo? He was jogging around with leg strapping. It's the only positive I can take from the situation of Hogan missing and perhaps Weideman playing a more fit and firing game than before.

we can all dream, dt

[Pennant St Dee 11,973]

23 minutes ago, binman said:

Source?

Me. Trust me on this all Demonlanders move on for now.

Respect his privacy 

[godees 726]

Weid and ANB travelled. Weid hasn't regained any form in VFL yet so it would be crazy to bring him in. 

Go small in forward line. Give ANB the tagging job on Laird. Watts leading up at CHF. Petracca from goal square. Hannan also deep-ish with Kent and Garlett hanging around. It would require a fairly significant change in the way we have been taking the ball into F50 (no long bombs) but our recent strategies have been working appallingly anyway.

On the Adelaide board on bigfooty they were worried about being too tall and slow in the forward line. Let's go for broke with a small and fast team, play with dash, take risks from defence. I think its the only way we can win. Oh, and tag Sloane with Vince!

[picket fence 15,857]

38 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

no chf, no ff, no ruckman, no 2nd ruckman. other than that, everything looks rosy

Change the Rosy to Roosy and maybe we would have won at least 2 of the games we lost. Not saying Goody isn't a good coach but just saying at selection and on match day who knows ?? A couple of results might have gone the other way! 

Agree season teetering on the Abyss!! Rotten luck plus lack of x factor a key!

[daisycutter 28,730]

looks like it is official

43 minutes ago

Hogan officially out

 

 

JESSE Hogan has officially been ruled out of Melbourne's clash against Adelaide at Adelaide Oval on Saturday night through illness.
 
Hogan missed training on Thursday and the Demons gave him until this morning to prove if he was fit to fly out to Adelaide.
 
However, the star forward was a no-show at Melbourne Airport on Friday morning and the club confirmed he would not play on Friday afternoon.
 
Half-forward Alex Neal-Bullen and tall forward Sam Weideman were the travelling emergencies and the Demons will make a decision on who comes into the line up before the game on Saturday night.

•  

ben.guthrie

 

[rjay 24,205]

5 minutes ago, Pennant St Dee said:

Me. Trust me on this all Demonlanders move on for now.

Respect his privacy 

Was going to click like on this but nothing to like here.

...and yes I always trust your mail 'Pennant', unfortunately on this occasion. 

Looks like being one of those years.

[rjay 24,205]

4 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Change the Rosy to Roosy and maybe we would have won at least 2 of the games we lost. Not saying Goody isn't a good coach but just saying at selection and on match day who knows ?? A couple of results might have gone the other way! 

Agree season teetering on the Abyss!! Rotten luck plus lack of x factor a key!

Not even close 'picket', last year we got smashed by the Cats with master coach Roos.

Goodwin had us well on the way when Max went down.

[The Chazz 4,077]

32 minutes ago, Dappa Dan said:

Hogan out now makes this a real blowout danger. Sort of hoping we say screw the tall options and just put run in. Weed will get slaughtered by Talia. Real shame this.

I would've presumed that Talia would go to Watts, then possibly to Petracca when Watts goes in to the ruck.

There's a reason why Rance went to Watts first when we played Richmond, and that's because teams know how important Watts is to a competitive Melbourne.

[greenmachine 21]

thinking we going to get smashed, playing crows at home after they had a loss without hogan

 

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

I reckon for Crows Talia gets the heaviest, best contested mark. Lever (if he were fit) is an intercept mark guy. I'm not sure of the stats, but I think Weed might already be heavier than Watts. Just checked... yup, he is by 1 keg. I reckon Weed is a bigger threat on the lead for the high ball. They'll know that.

I hope you're right though. Watts will go up the ground a lot. One thing about him this year, he's been able to shake a lot of close attention with his variety of roles. Hard to tag a guy when he goes into the centre circle for ruck taps.

[Glenn Molloy 494]

Even before Hogan was out, I felt like we were going to get poleaxed.  They have absolutely smashed all teams at Adelaide Oval this year (GWS, Rich, Ess) and controlled the Port game.  Now that Jesse is out, if we get within 7 goals we've done ok.

[Dee Zephyr 18,297]

Tomorrow night was always going to be difficult but I was hoping the effort would be there all day. I still think the boys will give it their all but what little air I had left has just been sucked out of me with Hogan missing. Can someone please make me feel better?

Edited May 12, 2017 by Demon77

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

1 minute ago, Demon77 said:

Tomorrow night was always going to be difficult but I was hoping the effort would be there all day. I still think the boys will give it their all but what little air I had left has just been sucked out of me with Hogan missing. Can someone please make me feel better?

In two days it'll be over.

[Upper Combukta West 48]

Could this be our  "against-the-odds-Hogan-out" win for the year........?

Geelong 2015

Hawthorn 2016

Adelaide 2017???

[Diamond_Jim 12,140]

1 minute ago, Upper Combukta West said:

Could this be our  "against-the-odds-Hogan-out" win for the year........?

Geelong 2015

Hawthorn 2016

Adelaide 2017???

nah

[Gorgoroth 12,447]

I keep telling myself "enjoy your weekend, dont watch the game"

7:20 will come along and I'll be in front of the tv getting angry... sigh

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Hogan out hurts, but this game will be won or lost in the midfield.  If we can move the ball like we did in the third term against the Hawks then we, at the very least, give ourselves a chance.  

I'm one who hopes we bring in ANB for the extra run, stick Petracca at full forward with Jeffy at his feet and let Kent, ANB and others do some damage with their pressure.  

If we start kicking it long to a contest all night then we are no chance as they'll pick it off every time.

[Dee Zephyr 18,297]

2 minutes ago, Upper Combukta West said:

Could this be our  "against-the-odds-Hogan-out" win for the year........?

Geelong 2015

Hawthorn 2016

Adelaide 2017???

Unlikely, Max was BOG in both 15 and 16.

[ding 5,126]

Is it too late to tip The Crows by 10 goals?

This will have to be our line-in-the-sand game if its to be much better than that.

[bing181 8,366]

Character-building stuff. 

[Diamond_Jim 12,140]

1 minute ago, Gorgoroth said:

I keep telling myself "enjoy your weekend, dont watch the game"

7:20 will come along and I'll be in front of the tv getting angry... sigh

shows you how interested I am in this game... thought it was in the afternoon... oh well at least we are not on FTA

In a perverse way I hope we lose by a respectable margin.. there is something in me that would not react well to a five point loss!

[MudDogs Gawn Win.. someday 499]

55 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

I may have high expectations but expecting Weed to have a 22 possession, 14 mark, 5 goal game. I know he'll only be playing on the best full back in the league in Talia....but....