Josh Mahoney on SEN 15 October 2015

[beelzebub 23,192]

You do understand how [censored] ing stupid that reads, yeah?

funny if he had only said 2017 !!

[dazzledavey36 52,709]

Club going all out for Prestia... Pick 3 would have sealed the deal. I understand the frustration.

Dees still very confident he will be in red and blue 2016.

Called this muppet out last year and got howled down for it. Glad some are starting to wake up to themselves and realize what a phony this guy is.

[stuie 7,374]

funny if he had only said 2017 !!

Technically the trade period is in 2016, so it would still be 2016. Thanks for playing.

[Willmoy1947 3,957]

I'll accept that GNF says it's still a possibility...

[The Hallowed Turf 95]

Maynard is a tough and skilled left footed half-back flanker whose father played for MFC.

De Goey is their Brayshaw and is worth way more than Howe.

Oxley is an inconsistent, flakey half-back and isn't worth what Howe is.

Marley Williams is a mental midget with issues.

Is this the Oxley that carved us up Queens birthday?

I agree with your assessment of De Goey but Williams DID have issues which seem to be in the past. Rated above average in the Prospectus.

Yeah you haven't convinced me on Maynard at all.

[Grand New Flag 3,227]

Pick 3, part of a larger complicated trade. Obviously not going back to GC.

[olisik 4,060]

Pick 3, part of a larger complicated trade. Obviously not going back to GC.

Poor save

[DSP 1,488]

He sounded pee'd off to me.

Whether thats from Howe back flipping to the Pies or whatever.

I certainly hope we dont get reamed on this trade. We need a win this trade season. So far its been anything but.

Edited October 15, 2015 by DSP

[reynolds46 1,048]

MFC at trade week

"c'mon help ol' Josh out here"

[Deecisive 1,709]

I think it has more to do with playing in prime time ón the big stage' so he can show off, his a show poney. only issue is will he make the team often enough to show off on the big stage. he will have a lot harder competition at Collingwood for a spot and they will not tolerate this laziness or turnovers they way we have.

[P-man 13,366]

MFC at trade week

"c'mon help ol' Josh out here"

"The wolves are at ol' Josh's door..."

[old dee 23,482]

He sounded pee'd off to me.

Whether thats from Howe back flipping to the Pies or whatever.

I certainly hope we dont get reamed on this trade. We need a win this trade season. So far its been anything but.

I would add "very"

[jackaub 1,402]

Best Pick they'll have will be 24 if they get that from St Kilda for Freeman.

And IF they dont??

[old dee 23,482]

And IF they dont??

Tell him it is GCS or try your luck in the draft.

[jackaub 1,402]

Tell him it is GCS or try your luck in the draft.

OD you and I have been around for a long long time do you really reckon MFC would have the Knackers to do that I know they should you know they should Will They?

[Alf Stewart 73]

We may as well force Howe into draft. And tell Kennedy to do the same and get him with our last pick rather than waste in on a earlier trade value. We will get him for nothin anyway. Show some balls dees. We get nothin for Howe either way, but we get Kennedy at last pick anyway.

[rjay 24,577]

Collingwood's 2016 First Rounder is going to GWS for Treloar as well. And we wouldn't get that anyway. They're not going to give 9-12 next year for Howe.

We need to go after a player on the Pies list that walks into our best 22. Not the fringe players they will offer us like Kennedy, Broomhead or Sinclair.

We don't seem to have any interest in Seedsman or Freeman, so I'd start by asking for Marley Williams or Tom Langdon, and I'd settle for Brayden Maynard.

Brayyyyyyyyyden Mayyyyyyyyyyynard

Posted something similar a few weeks back. I would like to get Maynard or Langdon...time for them to give up something decent.

[old dee 23,482]

OD you and I have been around for a long long time do you really reckon MFC would have the Knackers to do that I know they should you know they should Will They?

No of course not But I felt better saying it.

I think we will get a reasonable deal out of the Pies not as good as GCS perhaps but ok.

[wattsup 470]

If the deal about prestia was true tell Gold Coast to trade him for pick 6 and we let Howe slip to PSD Then they have a fair chance of grabbing him as they have pick 3, would need Carlton and lions not to obviously

[rpfc 28,045]

Pick 3, part of a larger complicated trade. Obviously not going back to GC.

So that complicated trade chip is still with one of the players in that complicated trade...

Look, either you are being sold something dodgy, or you're selling it.

[mo64 5,477]

Pick 3, part of a larger complicated trade. Obviously not going back to GC.

Seriously GNF, why raise something like this when we know that pick 3 is out of the equation?

[Brayshaw Self 847]

Is this the Oxley that carved us up Queens birthday?

I agree with your assessment of De Goey but Williams DID have issues which seem to be in the past. Rated above average in the Prospectus.

Yeah you haven't convinced me on Maynard at all.

Oxley has literally played 3 good games in his career and is 3 year older.

Maynard has played just as well and is tougher, better skilled, a better natural footballer and scope to play midfield. He is Hodge-like.

[old dee 23,482]

Another thing He said was there had been no talk to anyone about Dawes or Watts. ( excuse me if someone mentioned that earlier )

Edited October 15, 2015 by old dee

[HulkHogan 69]

If the deal about prestia was true tell Gold Coast to trade him for pick 6 and we let Howe slip to PSD Then they have a fair chance of grabbing him as they have pick 3, would need Carlton and lions not to obviously

I don't think he would be worth a top 10 pick let alone a top 3 where there are better players available

[hells bells 2,023]

Gut feel is JM is [censored] off because pick 3 was to be used for something big. Howe's change of mind has thrown other plans into disarray. No idea how Collingwood can better, let alone match what GC had offered. Particularly with Treloar and Aish in their plans.