Paul Seedsman

[MadAsHell 4,095]

So appears Collingwood are front runners for Aish & Treloar acording to this article.

http://www.news.com.au/sport/breaking-news/collingwood-is-hopeful-of-securing-adam-treloar-and-james-aish-during-afl-trade-period/story-fnect155-1227479263831

And I note that Paul Seedsman's name was thrown up, however Brisbane wouldn't accept him in a straight swap for Aish.

Maybe Melbourne can get involved here? Maybe Collingwood can throw Seedsman to us with Howe then going to Brisbane. Maybe a swap of Collingwood's 2nd round pick for our 3rd also?

I rate Seedsman, played really well v us on Queen's Birthday last year. 23 years old, 190cm, 87kg, nearly 50 games experience averaging 16-17 possesions a game. Outside wing/half back with pace and a long penetrating kick. Exactly what we need. http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/player-profile/paul-seedsman

We may not be able to land the likes of Dangerfield, Treloar, Prestia this year. But players like Seedsman could be the exact type that could help take us forward.

The likes Paul Seedsman, Andrew Moore & Daniel Gorringe could be more valuable then people think.

[poita 3,792]

Trade for Lumumba?

[whatwhat say what 21,133]

He's more of the same tho - another mid-tall half back flanker.

We already have Garland, Howe, Grimes, Lumumba and Cross playing that role - do we need another?

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

He's more of the same tho - another mid-tall half back flanker.

We already have Garland, Howe, Grimes, Lumumba and Cross playing that role - do we need another?

I think you mean to say we have players who play the HB flanker position.

Garland, Howe, Grimes and Cross are hardly line-breaking hard running flankers.

Lamumba was supposed to be one but for various reasons we haven't seen it this year.

Seedsman is a quick line breaker with a long and penetrating kick but not overly accurate or damaging kick so I'd say we don't need him because we have Lamumba who hopefully next year will have a better year. I'm sure Collingwood saw Seedsman as a direct replacement for Lamumba positionally speaking but he hasn't come on this year.

Looking at what our backline needs, it's clear we lack composure and skill back there. Garland again was back to his old ways on the weekend, consistently butchering the ball/throwing it straight on the boot when there's a handball on and covering the ground like a wounded elephant. Always looks [censored] when he's playing.

We have really missed Salem back there this year and I hope we target another lethal left-footer who is either a really good runner or a great contested player. Both would be preferable.

We're a one-dimensional unit back there and it needs addressing this off-season.

Edited August 13, 2015 by stevethemanjordan

[DubDee 22,788]

Seedsman is being put up for trade as he is massively inconsistent. plays a terrific game and then gets dropped after going missing.

maybe that will come with maturity - I thought he was younger than 23?

worth a look. if his attitude is good. we def need speed and skill off half back

[stinga81 210]

He lives and breathes Collingwood (grandfather was former player and President (IIRC), I doubt they'd move him on.

It'd be like us putting up Viney for trade.

[rjay 24,290]

He lives and breathes Collingwood (grandfather was former player and President (IIRC), I doubt they'd move him on.

It'd be like us putting up Viney for trade.

or a Kennedy leaving Hawthorn???

[rjay 24,290]

I think Mitch White could develop into a better player going forward.

[stinga81 210]

or a Kennedy leaving Hawthorn???

Through lack of opportunity Kennedy left, anyway just an opinion.

[Members' Wing 1,106]

I'd be setting our sights higher than going after blokes who can't get a game for their current clubs or are right on the fringes, unless they fill a really obvious gap in the list.

For every Josh Kennedy there's 100 Ben Newton, Viv Michie, Aidan Riley's.

[chook fowler 18,873]

has a few spud risk factors. Next.

[daisycutter 28,782]

wouldn't trust anything from the filth

[Deeoldfart 7,922]

If we are chasing a back flanker who breaks lines and kicks well, I hope we set our sights higher than Seedsman.

[Demon Jack 6,550]

I remember watching the ANZAC day game where he was best on ground which was followed by him being subbed off the next week.

He's a ok player but I hope we're looking at something better.

[monoccular 16,916]

wouldn't trust anything from the filth

I was about to say - when did we last get a trade (or raid) from Collingwood who actually delivered on his promise?

I must say, off hand, I can't remember one since the father of that young tall who was supposed to take us apart a couple of weeks ago. (Some doomsayers here had him down for a 10 goal bag as I remember).

[picket fence 16,014]

Seedsman & Yarran !??

Now just before ya shoot me down

Did you all see how Hawks speculative picks as appeared in todays' Hun, have turned out sensationally!??

Lets be bold and if we pay slightly overs ..... so be it!

Gotta be better than Bail, Skills, M Jones,( That other bloke who I won't name) Fitzy,Terlich and one or two others!??

[Ted Lasso 17,483]

I reckon seedsman can play abit

[M C 221]

Zero accountability defensively, would be more suited to a team like Hawthorn where his deficiencies don't stand out as much

Has never really had a proper preseason though which may explain the inconsistency

Collingwood have several similar players so he could go cheap

[Roger Mellie 3,763]

Agree on Seedsman. You can see brilliance and spud in the same game.

Wasn't he subbed off against us as well?

[grazman 6,864]

If we are chasing a back flanker who breaks lines and kicks well, I hope we set our sights higher than Seedsman.

Agree, I'm surprised there's some love for him, most Pies supporters aren't overly concerned to lose him... apparently a little soft as well.

[Moonshadow 16,939]

Paul Seedsman.... Someone plant the thought in Taylor's mind so he can become part of out young crop coming through.

[Grimes is Great 183]

Blokes a dud

[Biffen 12,616]

Just don't call him Lessy near H.

[Harry Plopper 105]

No, no and no. Went to school with him and is the biggest D***head I've ever met. Attitude is shocking, expects everything given to him on a sliver platter. Wouldn't touch with a 10 foot pole!

[Roger Mellie 3,763]

When he was good he was very, very good

When he was bad he was horrid.

Has requested a trade according to Ch 7

Thoughts, vitriol etc