Some serious questions asked about Paul Roos ...

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,024]

David King has written the equivalent of a "DOG BITES MAN" article. ZZZZZZZZ

They came bounding over.

[Slartibartfast 16,128]

No need to read in between the lines, simply read the lines...

You've always been happier with that approach and it certainly makes life simpler. But your record on these matters is poor.

Each to their own. My view is that now the foundation is in place we should implement Goodwin immediately. In a sense Roos is a lame duck and if Goodwin is there for 3 years post 2016 he should be calling the shots.

Surely he would be deciding game plans and player movements. It makes no sense for Roos to be in charge.

[chook fowler 18,595]

Yeah but who invented the back door?

Cue Benny Hill theme.

Boy George

[daisycutter 28,727]

Yeah but who invented the back door?

Cue Benny Hill theme.

my money says some greek dude about 3,000 or so years ago

[Sir Why You Little 35,322]

You've always been happier with that approach and it certainly makes life simpler. But your record on these matters is poor.

Each to their own. My view is that now the foundation is in place we should implement Goodwin immediately. In a sense Roos is a lame duck and if Goodwin is there for 3 years post 2016 he should be calling the shots.

Surely he would be deciding game plans and player movements. It makes no sense for Roos to be in charge.

Paul Roos a lame duck?

Gimme a break.

Watch last night's game again. These kids still need to learn more of the defensive side of the game, otherwise the club will never challenge past week one of September.

Roos has a 3rd year as Senior Coach. Goodwin continues to grow into the role.

Paul Roos a lame duck. I will tell him that next time i see him walking his dog

[Biffen 12,567]

If he hands over a year early he can hand back the $1.5 mill for 2016 as well.

[Hulett Packard III 166]

Stick to the plan, I say.

We have a contract with Roos which runs out at the end of next year. The succession plan allows him to work in injunction with Goodwin. I think that's working. There's no need to change that at all.

[rpfc 27,692]

This is what was promised - this is what he experienced with Longmire and got the MFC to emulate.

To abandon the plan now doesn't seem sensible nor something that Jackson would entertain.

Goodwin gets to own a bit more and Roos will pick up the flack still.

What a great introduction to 2017 and his first year as head coach of the MFC.

[Dr. Mubutu 697]

If he hands over a year early he can hand back the $1.5 mill for 2016 as well.

He'll hand over the reins, but still be in the front seat. Think of it as $1.5m spent by the AFL to keep a healthy 18-team competition (as that's basically what it is).

I realise that that's quite an indictment on the club, but it's the reality of where we were at.

[Chook 14,702]

This is what was promised - this is what he experienced with Longmire and got the MFC to emulate.

To abandon the plan now doesn't seem sensible nor something that Jackson would entertain.

Goodwin gets to own a bit more and Roos will pick up the flack still.

What a great introduction to 2017 and his first year as head coach of the MFC.

I think this is something people underestimate. It isn’t some misguided force-out scenario like what happened at Collingwood; this is a planned, structured transition orchestrated by someone who has done exactly this in the past—to premiership winning effect no less.

[deanox 9,006]

If we hand to Goodwin fully now and don't improve out of sight we will be hounded by the media. In 2017 when we are 4 and 8 at round 12 media pressure could result in a turnover of coaches again.

Roos status as no.1 in 2016 takes all the pressure off Goodwin as he finds his feat.

But more importantly, it gives the footy dept. an extra 12 months stability to turn over the list, develop the kids, rebuild the culture etc. before the preformed becomes Goodwins responsibility.

If we ate a bit flat in 2016, Roos takes the heat plus we get to have a 4th list turn over under the same footy department before Goodwin gets a couple of years to build a premiership side.

Replacing him earlier than planned just gets rid of all the time that we need to get better that we bought ourselves with the succession plan.

[deanox 9,006]

If anything, I'd like Roos to sign for a4th year, as a "Director of Coaching" or "Youth Development Coach" or "Player Welfare Coach" or "Culture/Leadership Director" or similar and hang around to provide guidance, mentoring and keep supporting the leadership group but keeping out of Goodwins way, to further ease the transition.

Edited September 19, 2015 by deanox

[Binmans PA 26,735]

If anything, I'd like Roos to sign for a4th year, as a "Director of Coaching" or "Youth Development Coach" or "Player Welfare Coach" or "Culture/Leadership Director" or similar and hang around to provide guidance, mentoring and keep supporting the leadership group but keeping out of Goodwins way, to further ease the transition.

Well, some will say he would get in Goodwin's way here, but he headed up the academy at Sydney and didn't seem to step on Longmire's toes there. No reason why it couldn't work again. I agree with this idea. I want him around for a 4th year.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,024]

2016 should mark the end of mass player movements. In 2017 there should be no more than 4-5 as we tweak our list.

[Fork 'em 6,630]

"Your greatest appeal as a coach is to ensure that you've got spirit," - Alastair Clarkson

Roos fails.
Hope Goodwin is better.

[Yossarian 1,808]

"Your greatest appeal as a coach is to ensure that you've got spirit," - Alastair Clarkson

Roos fails.

Hope Goodwin is better.

[Uncle Fester 2,843]

"Your greatest appeal as a coach is to ensure that you've got spirit," - Alastair Clarkson

Roos fails.

Hope Goodwin is better.

"Your greatest appeal as a coach is to ensure that you've got decent players," - Me

I think Roos is doing a good job with that one (but, of course, only time will really tell)

[Middymalt 244]

Paul's the mouthpiece next year I would think Simon would have alot more on his plate next season, Roos has been great for media exposure eg afl 360 and IMO has been worth every cent, we should've really won 9 games this year and that's a pass considering the footy that was dished up only a couple of seasons ago

[stuie 7,374]

Paul's the mouthpiece next year I would think Simon would have alot more on his plate next season, Roos has been great for media exposure eg afl 360 and IMO has been worth every cent, we should've really won 9 games this year and that's a pass considering the footy that was dished up only a couple of seasons ago

Wait, so how many games we "should've really won" is what we base our season on now?

[DemonOX 8,578]

If anything, I'd like Roos to sign for a4th year, as a "Director of Coaching" or "Youth Development Coach" or "Player Welfare Coach" or "Culture/Leadership Director" or similar and hang around to provide guidance, mentoring and keep supporting the leadership group but keeping out of Goodwins way, to further ease the transition.

I think this is what BM was hired to do.

[rpfc 27,692]

"Your greatest appeal as a coach is to ensure that you've got spirit," - Alastair Clarkson

Roos fails.

Hope Goodwin is better.

[felixdacat 459]

Roos's persona in the Media (Burgo included) is exactly what i would like from a senior coach considered and thoughtful. Occasionally you see his passion but as long as he is able to keep the team motivated to keep on pushing themselves then he is doing a fine job. The boys that are driving this teams improvement have been on display all year and the effort is evident compared to recent years. If you want instant success you are dreaming! We are coming from a long way back!

[Demon trucker 1,800]

So roost

"Your greatest appeal as a coach is to ensure that you've got spirit," - Alastair Clarkson

Roos fails.

Hope Goodwin is better.

so roos should punch more walls and smash more phones

[Ted Lasso 17,318]

I wonder if this transition will see Macca move to the coaches box rather than the bench next year?

[Wiseblood 24,636]

The off season for us is a few weeks old and we're already getting rubbish like this:

"Your greatest appeal as a coach is to ensure that you've got spirit," - Alastair Clarkson

Roos fails.
Hope Goodwin is better.

Good grief this off season is going to be long...