The old dark navy blues! ;)

[Mazer Rackham 14,970]

My 2 cents in regards to replacement coaches.

Guy McKenna or Brendan Bolton.

Thoughts?

Maybe Rocket if they wait another couple of weeks.

[daisycutter 28,639]

Well usually I don't, but this was his opinion of Malthouse as a person... and as someone who has no doubt had plenty of contact with him, I suppose it has to be worth something. That's why I wondered whether that could explain the blues poor performances.

look i don't particularly like malthouse myself, always thought he was divisive, self serving, hypocritical and basically a nutter at times

but there again, this could be said of many coaches including successful ones

but i don't think he was a bad person per se. he has often been seen to get the best out of his players (but also managed to get a few off side too)

never thought he was the right person for carlton given where they were at. always saw it blowing up in their faces

carlton should never have got rid of ratten, he was moving them along quite nicely, but the board and stakeholders were typically too impatient

as for slobbo being a judge of someone's character.....what a hypocrite

Edited May 26, 2015 by daisycutter

[hardtack 10,127]

Blues will meet at midday today to decide whether to sack Malthouse.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/sack-or-reappoint-me-mick-malthouse-on-future-as-carlton-blues-coach/story-fni5f5nx-1227369211781

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

Maybe Rocket if they wait another couple of weeks.

lol.

Very good.

[daisycutter 28,639]

Blues will meet at midday today to decide whether to sack Malthouse.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/sack-or-reappoint-me-mick-malthouse-on-future-as-carlton-blues-coach/story-fni5f5nx-1227369211781

are they holding the meeting at the herald sun offices - lol

[hardtack 10,127]

look i don't particularly like malthouse myself, always thought he was divisive, self serving, hypocritical and basically a nutter at times

but there again, this could be said of many coaches including successful ones

but i don't think he was a bad person per se. he has often been seen to get the best out of his players (but also managed to get a few off side too)

never thought he was the right person for carlton given where they were at. always saw it blowing up in their faces

carlton should never have got rid of ratten, he was moving them along quite nicely, but the board and stakeholders were typically too impatient

as for slobbo being a judge of someone's character.....what a hypocrite

Fair point

[monoccular 16,290]

My 2 cents in regards to replacement coaches.

Guy McKenna or Brendan Bolton.

Thoughts?

Would either be so stupid? Seriously, CFC will have serious problems getting anyone to take on the job.

And as an aside, will Daisy hang around without his mentor?

Edited May 26, 2015 by monoccular

[dee-luded 2,958]

Can't feel too much sympathy for MM. He's one of the biggest c-nuts in the game.

But Carlton ... why oh why did you hire this guy? He can coach, no doubt.

But they thought in their folly that they were going to add him as the icing on the cake and land them a flag within 3 years.

Malthouse doesn't do that. Didn't do it at the Dogs, at the Weagles, or the Pies.

He takes around 3 years to mould the team to his "way" and then shoots for flags.

They were at cross purposes from day one.

What can they possibly gain from sacking him now that couldn't be achieved at the end of the year?

Fetch the popcorn.

that's because at Carlton they've lost which way is up.... drowning in their own laundering machine. paper bags don't like getting wet.

[dee-luded 2,958]

are they holding the meeting at the herald sun offices - lol

the blues have a new nickname, 'cardboard boxes', lucky it'll make micks moveout that much easier.

[rjay 23,970]

Do Carlton fire him and pay him out - which Mick clearly wants, or do they save some money and continue their downward spiral? Makes the Schwab, Connolly and McLardy sagas seem tame by comparison.

Not really...we were much worse than this.

If they bring in Mark McLure to overview the football department and appoint the next coach then they will be close to par.

[hemingway 7,601]

Carlton may be the current club that looks dysfunctional but look at the MFC going all the way back to Norm Smith. It is the way. It is the way when clubs are performing badly. Boards are made up of business types and professionals who like to use their power and influence. I suspect that they often conduct themselves in a different way than the way they would conduct themselves in their own businesses. They come from different backgrounds than the Coaches and those in the Football Departments. Running a football club is not the same as running their own business. Board members also are influenced by outside pressures and the perceived need to be seen to be acting in a decisive manner and are influenced by the short term pressures and demands just as many Boards in the business world. They don't want to be seen to be doing nothing, particularly when the club is performing poorly on the field. We live in a world that demands instant success and a world that does not like to wait. One that has no patience. Also Coaches have egos and pride and their own way. They are often idiosyncratic. Coaches and Boards never have easy relationships and often success just papers over the cracks for a short period before tensions arise. Norm Smith is the best example, although MM is the current example.

[old dee 22,951]

Yes Ernie that covers it.

I know we all want to be in the top four but in any comp there will be someone at the top and someone at the bottom.

The trick is have a competition that ensures no team is stuck permanently in the bottom couple.

The MFC Management / Board performed so poorly they ensured we were down for way longer than we should have been.

Carlton over the last few years have put in train a similar effort.

This latest lot have just increased the speed of the decline.

[Seraph 1,714]

Carlton have been dysfunctional for 15 years.

Salary cap cheating, tanking (not saying we didn't, but come on), dodgy payment deals for players (Judd) and sacking the only coach that looked good after they missed the finals once during his tenure.

[Whispering_Jack 28,024]

I wonder if there's a way in which us Melbourne fans can get together and brainstorm some ideas to help a fellow club out in its time of need?

Perhaps we can organise some player trades to improve their lists or some other act of kindness?

[ManDee 7,091]

I wonder if there's a way in which us Melbourne fans can get together and brainstorm some ideas to help a fellow club out in its time of need?

Perhaps we can organise some player trades to improve their lists or some other act of kindness?

We could trade Bail and McKenzie for Gibbs & Murphy, is that the help you had in mind?

[old dee 22,951]

I wonder if there's a way in which us Melbourne fans can get together and brainstorm some ideas to help a fellow club out in its time of need?

Perhaps we can organise some player trades to improve their lists or some other act of kindness?

Hmm do I detect a note of sarcasm there WJ

[old dee 22,951]

Would either be so stupid? Seriously, CFC will have serious problems getting anyone to take on the job.

And as an aside, will Daisy hang around without his mentor?

There will be a queue Mono there are plenty of assistants who will put their hand up.

Daisy will be there the pay is too good and he will never get that money anywhere else in fact would probably struggle to get a third of his Carlton pay cheque.

[Moonshadow 16,347]

GAWWWWWWNNNNN!!!!

[dee-luded 2,958]

Carlton may be the current club that looks dysfunctional but look at the MFC going all the way back to Norm Smith. It is the way. It is the way when clubs are performing badly. Boards are made up of business types and professionals who like to use their power and influence. I suspect that they often conduct themselves in a different way than the way they would conduct themselves in their own businesses. They come from different backgrounds than the Coaches and those in the Football Departments. Running a football club is not the same as running their own business. Board members also are influenced by outside pressures and the perceived need to be seen to be acting in a decisive manner and are influenced by the short term pressures and demands just as many Boards in the business world. They don't want to be seen to be doing nothing, particularly when the club is performing poorly on the field. We live in a world that demands instant success and a world that does not like to wait. One that has no patience. Also Coaches have egos and pride and their own way. They are often idiosyncratic. Coaches and Boards never have easy relationships and often success just papers over the cracks for a short period before tensions arise. Norm Smith is the best example, although MM is the current example.

and this is why we have failed since before 'the Red Fox' was sacked, because the people elected to board come from an environment were they pump warm air in one anothers ears, & say your turn to have a go.

time to stop taking our board members from that environment, & start to get a better healthier mix of business acumen that does not come from those elbow rubbing in the safe confines of the Olympic stand... this has brought us nothing but fails & years of pain, whilst other clubs that have their offices based away from the 'g' have a toughness thru the decades, & the success that comes with it.

our 'bad-luck' is bad management, & ours comes ingrown from within. & from a dwindling support base that has been kept out in the cold.

[dee-luded 2,958]

We could trade Bail and McKenzie for Gibbs & Murphy, is that the help you had in mind?

gibbs & murphy no thanks

hendo & yarran, but pay more than Ba & McK

[old dee 22,951]

We could trade Bail and McKenzie for Gibbs & Murphy, is that the help you had in mind?

Wow mandee I think you are a bit high on the offer.

M Jones and McKenzie would be more appropriate

[Jaded No More 58,675]

Some of our supporters complain that Roos isn't in the job for the long haul and took the role for all the wrong reasons....

They must be confusing Roos with Mick Malthouse.

Nobody has ever succeeded doing anything out of spite.

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

Looks like it's all happening now.

Mick in a meeting with bosses.

Carlton staff told not to leave the building.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/crisis-at-carlton-blues-set-to-sack-mick-malthouse-20150526-gh9qof.html

[What 18,810]

He's been sacked.

What a disaster of an appointment that was.

[MadAsHell 4,088]

He's been sacked.

What a disaster of an appointment that was.

Confirmation?