Potential Trades [Warning: Reading this thread may self-destruct]

[CBDees 3,167]

Little has been said on Demonland in relation to Wright but he could be even more imposing in the forward line as well as a good acquisition to our ruck stocks!

Whoops wrong thread!

[McQueen 17,864]

Ok, so Port are struggling to appease the bummers for Paddy Ryder.

Piece of cake..

Dees pick 3 to Port

Wines to Dees

Pick 3 to the Bummers.

Apologies in advance to P-man if this is more suited to the 'Whines Lounge".

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

When you think aboit clubs were midfield talent might be open to a trade, id reckon the sun, crows, bombers might be the biggest candidates due to losing coach.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

He had a very interrupted season, if they took the highlights from his underage year you would get a much better picture of his upside.

I'm not sure how anyone else sees this but pretty much all the highlight packages have been underwhelming this year, is it a directive to give a broader view of the player or is this a really poor draft year. 'Chaser', you watch a bit of this level what are your thoughts?

Back to McCartin, our recruiters should have a good read on him, can he reach the potential of last year or is this year a better gauge.

Remember Jack Darling had a poor last year at junior level and everyone here was complaining about us missing out on him when we had the chance to pick him up.

Thanks rjay but not basing it on the highlights but on what I have seen and heard.

He is a solid and smart player.

[SaberFang 7,151]

Geez, Cats are desperate to ditch this guy:

Varcoe may join Collingwood in three-way deal

Geelong premiership player Travis Varcoe could become a Collingwood player, by becoming the missing link in a three-way trade with Melbourne and Geelong involving Heritier Lumumba and Mitch Clark.

The Magpies arepursuing the dynamic Cats wingman, who could form the third part of a triangular deal for Lumumba to move to Melbourne and Clark to resume his AFL career as a Cat.

North Melbourne retains a keen interest in Varcoe and it is not a fait-accompli that Varcoe could complete a neat three-way trade for the players. Collingwood would need to come to satisfactory terms with Varcoe, but it is understood the speedy midfielder is open to moving to the Magpies or North Melbourne.

Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/varcoe-may-join-collingwood-in-threeway-deal-20141007-10rld6.html#ixzz3FTLQNkxs

Either way, I'm glad we're sticking fat with both Collingwood and Geelong. Not giving up our second rounder for Lamumba is a good start, and getting more off Geelong (albeit heading to Collingwood) isn't bad either. Still think Geelong are the biggest winners in that trade; would really prefer to get more than just Lamumba, like Geelong's 3rd rounder.

Geelong - Clark

Melbourne - Lamumba

Collingwood - Pick 33 and Varcoe

[dee-tox 4,835]

Toby Greene or Shiel can still play a big role here despite it all being quiet on the Greater Western Front.

[Demoneyes 562]

First you say we are getting Dangerfield and then you say Toumpas wants a trade. I hope for your sake there is some truth to what you are saying about Shiel or else your credibility will be smashed....

Sorry, I thought the trade period was still going? And besides that, we can only post hear what we hear. Nothing concrete!

[Demoneyes 562]

I also said we were going hard at Dangerfield, not that we were getting him!

[buck_nekkid 5,858]

Geez, Cats are desperate to ditch this guy:

Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/varcoe-may-join-collingwood-in-threeway-deal-20141007-10rld6.html#ixzz3FTLQNkxs

Either way, I'm glad we're sticking fat with both Collingwood and Geelong. Not giving up our second rounder for Lamumba is a good start, and getting more off Geelong (albeit heading to Collingwood) isn't bad either. Still think Geelong are the biggest winners in that trade; would really prefer to get more than just Lamumba, like Geelong's 3rd rounder.

Geelong - ClarkMelbourne - LamumbaCollingwood - Pick 33 and Varcoe

This is terrible for us. This assumes that Clark has almost the least value of the three. I would want extra from Geelong to make this work, say even swapping our late pick for their second rounder. Geelong are paying way unders for Clark unless more is happening.

[ChaserJ 5,089]

He had a very interrupted season, if they took the highlights from his underage year you would get a much better picture of his upside.

I'm not sure how anyone else sees this but pretty much all the highlight packages have been underwhelming this year, is it a directive to give a broader view of the player or is this a really poor draft year. 'Chaser', you watch a bit of this level what are your thoughts?

Back to McCartin, our recruiters should have a good read on him, can he reach the potential of last year or is this year a better gauge.

Remember Jack Darling had a poor last year at junior level and everyone here was complaining about us missing out on him when we had the chance to pick him up.

McCartin's had some dominant games this year, but his Champs were interrupted by injury, which is where most of the highlight packages tend to come from.

He has the most advanced game (in terms of forward play) of all the talls this this year, hence the high ranking. McCartin has good running patterns to go with his strength and strong hands, but at his 193, McCartin's not at the taller end of the key position spectrum. Also, he's very much a stay at home ff, and clubs are looking more and more for versatility in their falls.

I'd be happy enough to take him and be confident he'd be a good player, but not so bullish about his ceiling. I'd have him a rung, maybe two, below Hogan, Boyd & Patton at the same stage.

Heard that we like Jake Lever more than McCartin and could well go with Lever if we take both picks to the draft.

[rjay 24,917]

McCartin's had some dominant games this year, but his Champs were interrupted by injury, which is where most of the highlight packages tend to come from.

He has the most advanced game (in terms of forward play) of all the talls this this year, hence the high ranking. McCartin has good running patterns to go with his strength and strong hands, but at his 193, McCartin's not at the taller end of the key position spectrum. Also, he's very much a stay at home ff, and clubs are looking more and more for versatility in their falls.

I'd be happy enough to take him and be confident he'd be a good player, but not so bullish about his ceiling. I'd have him a rung, maybe two, below Hogan, Boyd & Patton at the same stage.

Heard that we like Jake Lever more than McCartin and could well go with Lever if we take both picks to the draft.

Thanks 'Chaser', just listening to Lever on the radio this morning and he sounds very impressive. Could of sworn he was a coach or 300 game veteran the way he spoke. These kids are well trained not just in football skills.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Surprised but not surprised to read that Roos has been chasing after him for weeks, and he'd already met with senior players at the MFC.

Roos is running a very tight ship.

Was the loyal country boy, Chip Frawley, one of those senior players?

[DemonOX 8,791]

Hey is anyone else having trouble with the SEN app?

Cheers

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

Thanks 'Chaser', just listening to Lever on the radio this morning and he sounds very impressive. Could of sworn he was a coach or 300 game veteran the way he spoke. These kids are well trained not just in football skills.

I think this about pretty much every player who is picked up to the AFL system, especially after listening to NRL players speak at the grandfinal

[Demon3 2,541]

I just ran into a Melbourne person who is employed at the club, know him very well, there is nothing happening behind the scenes. Players we targeted have not wanted to move, and at this stage a sit stands, we are taking 2 & 3 to the draft. He did say, there are still 5 days to go, but its all very quiet at the moment.

Just passing on.

[tilly18 289]

Hey is anyone else having trouble with the SEN app?

Cheers

Yep all morning.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

This is terrible for us. This assumes that Clark has almost the least value of the three. I would want extra from Geelong to make this work, say even swapping our late pick for their second rounder. Geelong are paying way unders for Clark unless more is happening.

We get H for Clark. The rest of it means nothing to us.

If we can keep our 3rd and 4th rounders for Garlett and Frost and use 23 in the draft or even in a later trade then that is a win.

[Damo 3,355]

Im warming to any mix of the top 3. My druthers are Brayshaw and McCartin. Smoke em if you got em.

[watchtheeyes 1,420]

I just ran into a Melbourne person who is employed at the club, know him very well, there is nothing happening behind the scenes. Players we targeted have not wanted to move, and at this stage a sit stands, we are taking 2 & 3 to the draft. He did say, there are still 5 days to go, but its all very quiet at the moment.

Just passing on.

While it would've been nice to pick up a ready made, midfield star, if we bring in Lamumba, Garlett, & Frost then go to the draft for any 2 of Brayshaw, Petracca, McCartin then I'd be happy (I prefer Brayshaw and Petracca).

[watchtheeyes 1,420]

I should add that if we then show meaningful improvement next year, then we'll be in a far better position to attract that gun in the next trade/FA period (Danger, Sloane, Tex etc)

[Machsy 2,858]

Thanks 'Chaser', just listening to Lever on the radio this morning and he sounds very impressive. Could of sworn he was a coach or 300 game veteran the way he spoke. These kids are well trained not just in football skills.

If we used picks 2 & 3, is be much happier with Lever and Brayshaw than most other combos.

Don't want McCartin, personally.

[Machsy 2,858]

Hey is anyone else having trouble with the SEN app?

Cheers

They have launched and are migrating to a new mobile site.

They have been flogging it 24/7 for weeks.

App may not be live anymore.

[poita 3,902]

So much for Roos being the master list builder. To date he has lost our number 1 forward and number 1 defender, and the best he might be able to do in return is Lumumba and Garlett, both unwanted by their current clubs. Perhaps he should cancel his holiday and work on bringing some established midfielders to the club.

The two win season we are heading for next year will be fun to watch.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

You're joking, right?

[Lucifers Hero 39,751]

So much for Roos being the master list builder. To date he has lost our number 1 forward and number 1 defender, and the best he might be able to do in return is Lumumba and Garlett, both unwanted by their current clubs. Perhaps he should cancel his holiday and work on bringing some established midfielders to the club.

The two win season we are heading for next year will be fun to watch.

Troll?????