The Trade/Draft Rumour Mill

[RalphiusMaximus 6,012]

I really think this sort of persecution complex does not get us anywhere, but sadly is so prevalent on this site. The trigger for me is the word "Vlad" (referring to the CEO of the AFL), which has all the connotations of racism and anti-elitism.

Face it folks, the MFC has only itself to blame for its incompetence in the last five years. Before that, it was more than competitive.

A Demitriou led board of the AFL has been a the forefront of rescuing the MFC from its own incompetence. We should rejoice we have such professional administrators at the AFL. We would be on our way to NZ without them.

Sadly so many MFC supporters prefer to think of themselves as persecuted, rather than how we can get ourselves out of this mess. I've noticed also, so often those who complain about persecution, are also the ones who are most critical of the AFL Head.

The AFL have been responsible for putting Peter Jackson into the MFC, indirectly recruiting Roos, and supplying the funds to rescue us from oblivion. Admittedly, they also knew without the MFC they would not have a viable competition, but they could have sent us to Hobart and we could not have done a blind thing about it.

Be careful what you wish for.......

Actually, the last time the AFL re-wrote the rules after allowing something like this was when Geelong were looking at putting together a third-party package to offer Ablett on top of his playing wage. The AFL declared that although they had approved the multiple deals Carlton had made in the same manner, from this point forward they were going to ban them. This call was made pretty much for the sole purpose of preventing Geelong from keeping Ablett away from GC because they needed the star power to move up there. This really has nothing to do with us, but is a classic example of the AFL pushing their agenda before any considerations of fairness or an even competition. The same applies to the Franklin move. The AFL need Sydney to be a strong marketable side if they are to maintain their toehold in NSW, therefore they will get more room to bend the rules than other clubs might. Ideally they would have liked him to go to GWS, but anywhere in Sydney is a good result for them.

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

If he is really the 1 in 1000 player, how could you let him go?

because our team sucks now - we need experience in the middle now otherwise 2014 could be as poor as 2013

IMO it's pretty simple - recruite some experience and get more competitive with some additional natural development - or continue to rebuild and hope fo 2 - 5 wins in 2014

I've started an argument I am not committed to keep up - but we can't keep relying on young blokes to lift the load of an entire team, even 1 in 1000 players will struggle at the Dees ATM (GWS anyone??)

Edited October 8, 2013 by Unleash Hell

[beelzebub 23,198]

because our team sucks now - we need experience in the middle now otherwise 2014 could be as poor as 2013

IMO it's pretty simple - recruite some experience and get more competitive with some additional natural development - or continue to rebuild and hope fo 2 - 5 wins in 2014

I've started an argument I am not committed to keep up - but we can't keep relying on young blokes to lift the load of an entire team, even 1 in 1000 players will struggle at the Dees ATM (GWS anyone??)

I actually dont mind this line of thinking. There will always be kids coming along. Its more akin to panicking to think you have to take someone this year. Theres nothing that amazing about 2013. 2014 and 15 and 16 will all deliver potential players. what we need is to seriously bolster our mid stocks NOW. They dont need to be necessarily abetted by an A grade kid who might make it one day . 2-3 decent B graders will have far more effect right now. A kid who might be brilliant in 3 years time doesnt really add much to todays equation. We arent likely to contend September action for a few years yet. We have time to still recruit over the coming years.

Kids wont advance us, mature bodies will.Kids are an icing for a cake we dont have. Lets get a cake first

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,423]

dees very quiet on recruitment. seems not many clubs interested in pick 2, I reckon improvement next year will come from current list and roos input...thoughts???

Possibly buy my mail was that two clubs were very interested although offers haven't been that great thus far.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,423]

The content on this thread is hilarious - first of all people expecting trades to be done in the first two days of a long and drawn out period of negotiation - people taking every statement from club, player or agent as gospel (Shuey comes to mind) and definitive evidence that they are not for sale or their club wont for the right deal trade them.

As Demon2014 put it you start with an ridiculous offer and work down to ground that both parties agree on. Maybe Tom Rockliff/Rory Sloane/Luke Shuey were those ridiculous initial offers but anything less for mine we should just go to the draft. The player we pick up will be only a few years younger than the average of our list. It would be ok.

We wont probably hear much for a while. Unless an obvious and unopposed deal gets pushed through to get it out of the way.

I think we will end up because of where we are at paying overs for a midfield star and wed be better off drafting a few for mine and filling up with second tiers for low trades.

[Deecisive 1,709]

Not a lot of trading being done so far, everyone is taking a cautious approach. I would not expect any club to put their best offer to MFC for the 2nd pick until later on in the piece, and if they dont do better we will get the 2nd draft pick. there could be a lot of players who are being Hawked around at the moment for a trade being delisted in the end to make room for new blood. I am sure our trading team will find an odd diamond or two in the rough by the end.

[Gorgoroth 12,701]

I don't think a lot will start to warm up til wed next week

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Interesting line here from Ralphy in the HUN:

"Adelaide’s Bernie Vince was a quality midfielder shopped around by the Crows in Monday’s talks, a rare talented onballer available to rival clubs."

Wonder if we could work a deal with them over the coming weeks that included Vince and something else for our Pick 2...?

[Hannibal 5,814]

Interesting line here from Ralphy in the HUN:

"Adelaide’s Bernie Vince was a quality midfielder shopped around by the Crows in Monday’s talks, a rare talented onballer available to rival clubs."

Wonder if we could work a deal with them over the coming weeks that included Vince and something else for our Pick 2...?

He's 28. He won't be involved in any discussions regarding pick 2.

[Demoneyes 562]

Patience people. Think of it as a marathon. First ten klms people are just finding their pace, next ten they try to sort the men out from the boys, next ten the stragglers are left behind and in the last 10 the rewards come for those that have made their move! Just so long as we don't fall over in the last 2!

[Wiseblood 24,637]

He's 28. He won't be involved in any discussions regarding pick 2.

Fair point.

[dazzledavey36 52,734]

Kane Lucas from Carlton been put up for trade.

Thoughts??

[Demoneyes 562]

Wiseblood, on 08 Oct 2013 - 8:28 PM, said:

Interesting line here from Ralphy in the HUN:

"Adelaide’s Bernie Vince was a quality midfielder shopped around by the Crows in Monday’s talks, a rare talented onballer available to rival clubs."

Wonder if we could work a deal with them over the coming weeks that included Vince and something else for our Pick 2...?

I have said all along that I thought we had our best chance with adelaide. Yes we would need more than Vince, but MFC did say intially they would swap for a player or group of players. I wonder if that means Vince, McKernan etc from the Crows?

[jumbo returns 6,703]

Pick 2 doesn't get traded? Pffftt.

What's the worst thing that can happen? Boyd or Aish? Not bad.

[DeeSpencer 24,699]

Kane Lucas from Carlton been put up for trade.

Thoughts??

Was glad we drafted Gysberts and not Lucas.

4 seasons later and I still am. Lucas can't kick and is a pea heart. He also brought the super out on the full back in to fashion. If Mick Malthouse doesn't want him then neither should we.

[beelzebub 23,198]

wasnt it Lucas that had some things to say about us not so long ago ? (or someone else )

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,654]

Can't let this line go unchallenged.

Show us a quote, as all I've seen or read of Chip wanting to leave are from hysterical posters here. Have been to training a lot this year and watched him, seen him at numerous Casey games supporting his mates, have seen nothing to suggest he wants to leave.

Now feel free to back up this line or is it just made up?

Still waiting, did Frawley say he wants to leave or are you just being a [censored] and making up things about one of our best players?

[RalphiusMaximus 6,012]

Still waiting, did Frawley say he wants to leave or are you just being a [censored] and making up things about one of our best players?

I seem to recall him saying he bleeds red and blue. Does that help at all?

[spirit of norm smith 15,117]

2- James Aish

21- Zac Jones ... call me sentimental. The kid can play.

22- (Sylvia compo) MFC trade to HFC for Savage

38- MFC trade to HFC for Sewell

54- MFC trade to Freo for Viv Michie

+ Hogan (upgrade), Daniel Cross (delist FA), and Jeremy Laidler (delist FA).

Rookies: Clisby (2nd year) Stark (2nd year) + add Chris Michaelides (Sandringham VFL), Mitch Gent (Casey VFL)

That's Aish, Jones, Savage, Sewell, Michie, Cross, Laidler & the wonder child Jesse Hogan.

Terlich, McDonald, Garland

Clisby, Frawley, Grimes

Michie, Viney, Toumpas

Howe, Dawes, Trengove

Savage, Clark, Hogan

Gawn, Sewell, Jones

Jones, Aish, Cross sub.Kent

emerg: Laidler, Blease, the Fitz

[whatwhat say what 22,117]

if savage comes to us it's not to be as a small forward option; it's to be as a pure mid.

other than that, i like yr trade ins, although laidler i'm not sure about.

[ThreeOneSix 954]

Savage ain't worth 22.

The bloke ain't that good.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

I like this Spirit.

Being greedy though, it'd be good to secure Myers as well. Somehow.

[Yossarian 1,820]

2- James Aish

21- Zac Jones ... call me sentimental. The kid can play.

22- (Sylvia compo) MFC trade to HFC for Savage

38- MFC trade to HFC for Sewell

54- MFC trade to Freo for Viv Michie

+ Hogan (upgrade), Daniel Cross (delist FA), and Jeremy Laidler (delist FA).

Rookies: Clisby (2nd year) Stark (2nd year) + add Chris Michaelides (Sandringham VFL), Mitch Gent (Casey VFL)

That's Aish, Jones, Savage, Sewell, Michie, Cross, Laidler & the wonder child Jesse Hogan.

Terlich, McDonald, Garland

Clisby, Frawley, Grimes

Michie, Viney, Toumpas

Howe, Dawes, Trengove

Savage, Clark, Hogan

Gawn, Sewell, Jones

Jones, Aish, Cross sub.Kent

emerg: Laidler, Blease, the Fitz

Distinct lack of class in that line-up.

[spirit of norm smith 15,117]

Grunt - Sewell, Viney, Jones, Cross, Savage, Frawley, Clisby

Class- Aish, Toumpas, Grimes, Howe AND JESSE HOGAN

No more classy types like Morton. No one will push us aside with Sewell, Viney and Jones in the mix

Edited October 8, 2013 by spirit of norm smith

[whatwhat say what 22,117]

probably, but there's a hell of a lot more work rate than there is currently with the addition of savage, sewell, another jones who looks as tenacious as his brother, and class and application in hogan.