WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - JACK VINEY

[spirit of norm smith 13,204]

Smoke and mirrors from Neeld, Harrington and young Jack etc.

We are playing politics to warn GCS and GWS that if they nominate Jack Viney to make us have to use Pick 3 then they can have JV  i.e. and miss out on Whitfield, Grundy or Toumpas.

MFC WILL GET JACK VINEY.  IF THEY DON'T, MINE AND MANY OTHER MEMBERSHIPS WILL BURN.  

This is a culture destroying call if we don't get Jack.

We have :

1. the son of a champion

2. he wants to play for MFC

3. we have invested 2 years and PR into Jack

4. he is tough, aggressive, physically ready and has the makings of a future STAR

Use Pick 3, if we have to. 

 Low Draft picks are not guaranteed champions. Look at Watts, Morton etc.

[Dockett 32 1,213]

If we had Pick 1 we would use it on Viney! That's where we rate him.

Thought the same thing last year and still do. Being BOG in the underage comp as a 17 year old was moderatley impressive. This years lot are a year and other attributes behind.

[keep13alive 78]

Listening to Hutchy, Dr Turf and some other bloke this morning they said the following:

They will walk from melbourne to Sydney if the Dees dont take Viney. Everyone in the AFL knows they will take him and Hutchie suggested that Melbourne had over played their hand with this one and were starting to look stupid in similar terms. He said they should just get it done already - make an unofficial deal with gold coast and gws and get the deal done before it causes more damage to our brand....

And they said he was rated by most in the top 5 by most recruiters not 8-10...

If the MFC stuff this up I will end a 50 year association, mostly miserable on my behalf,with brief highlights Re:Flower and the Northy years..This kid means more to the MFC then squabbling about a arbitrary position of 1 -10.

His Brand to the MFC is as important as a sponsor

[Deecisive 1,658]

Melbourne has repeatedly stated they know his worth, meaning yes we will take him first if we have to, but maybe, just maybe we may not therefore creating a very small doubt in the GC's mind. That small doubt in GC's mind will determine if we get three top 5 picks or two, so who wouldnt try to keep that doubt alive until 10:05 Monday morning.

[RalphiusMaximus 5,993]

Listening to Hutchy, Dr Turf and some other bloke this morning they said the following:

They will walk from melbourne to Sydney if the Dees dont take Viney. Everyone in the AFL knows they will take him and Hutchie suggested that Melbourne had over played their hand with this one and were starting to look stupid in similar terms. He said they should just get it done already - make an unofficial deal with gold coast and gws and get the deal done before it causes more damage to our brand....

And they said he was rated by most in the top 5 by most recruiters not 8-10...

And this just shows what a Spud of a journalist Hutchy really is. The AFL has repeatedly said they will come down like a ton of bricks on anyone making deals about bidding or not bidding on certain players in the Father Son auction. It will be classified as draft tampering and penalties will be harsh. No way in hell is the club going to risk that.

[picket fence 15,414]

Jack Viney

A man for all seasons it seems

Summer: Ivor Warne Smith/Checker Hughes

Autumn: Ron Barassi

Winter: Norm Smith

Spring: Robert Flower

Pick whilst still fresh and in harvest!! Methinks

Fence!

[The Demon 2565 28]

If GWS or GC bid for Viney..... MFC will pass.... Pick 2 & 3 in this years draft is to good to pass up..... MFC want Grundy, as a replacement for Martin..... I'm shattered because I was looking forward to watching young Viney next year....

Try re-reading what you have just written. If pick 2 and 3 are as you say too good to pass up in this years draft then what are the chances of gcs 'throwing away' pick 2 on jack, using the assumption that he is not worth it

JV is bona fide top 10, probably top 5 (definitely so to a team lacking ferocious in and under ball extractors). Does it really merit 40 pages of whining that we might not pull off the bargain of the century by getting him in the 2nd round?

[Redleg 37,909]

Mate there's 38 pages do you really think I'm going to read them all

I suggest you read at least a couple of them and then you might not be so confused as you claim.

[olisik 4,060]

Love the way all these "supporters" here are saying they will burn their membership if we dont take viney

Imo u guys should just fcuk off now as u obviously dont have enough faith in the club and its decisions to be saying things like that. The MFC has an onus to take the best available players at pick 3 + 4.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Love the way all these "supporters" here are saying they will burn their membership if we dont take viney

Imo u guys should just fcuk off now as u obviously dont have enough faith in the club and its decisions to be saying things like that. The MFC has an onus to take the best available players at pick 3 + 4.

When our recent top five draft selections have included Morton, Watts and Scully, there is good reason to be sceptical.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Love the way all these "supporters" here are saying they will burn their membership if we dont take viney

Imo u guys should just fcuk off now as u obviously dont have enough faith in the club and its decisions to be saying things like that. The MFC has an onus to take the best available players at pick 3 + 4.

I hate you.

[DemonOX 8,541]

Listening to Hutchy, Dr Turf and some other bloke this morning they said the following:

They will walk from melbourne to Sydney if the Dees dont take Viney. Everyone in the AFL knows they will take him and Hutchie suggested that Melbourne had over played their hand with this one and were starting to look stupid in similar terms. He said they should just get it done already - make an unofficial deal with gold coast and gws and get the deal done before it causes more damage to our brand....

And they said he was rated by most in the top 5 by most recruiters not 8-10...

Liam Pickering was the "other bloke" on the show.

Pickering was the one who said he would walk from Melbourne to Perth if the Dees did not take JV as FS.

Hutchy had nothing positive (suprise suprise) to say about the Dees and basically said we would go further backwards next year cause we have no leaders or senior players. He questioned why we got SB from the Cats and why we got rid of Moloney, Green, Bruce etc blah blah

Hutchy was pissing all over the Dees and to my suprise Pickering was defending us and said that Hutchy's ears were painted on when he didn't listen to what he was saying.

My opion of Hutchy prior to hearing this was low, now its even lower.

[rpfc 27,591]

I hate you.

I lol'd.

Really starting to think we will do some deals and all three clubs have played this really well from a 'no underhand deals here' point of view.

Just a vibe I am getting...

[Dee Fan 3,247]

I hate you.

Passion there.

I don't disagree

[DemonOX 8,541]

The MFC has an onus to take the best available players at pick 3 + 4.

Yeah no reason to worry cause our past picks have been outstanding.

[Axis of Bob 10,310]

One of the things about Viney that impresses me is that, even at under 18 level, where everyone is playing to get themselves drafted, he throws himself into laying a shepherd or creating space for a team mate. This isn't just someone who does the team things because he's told to, this is someone who lives winning. Someone who instinctively plays the game to win. A competitor.

Some people learn to be winners. Others just are. I feel a bit like Ben-Hur speaking about this, but for Viney it is true. He's someone who just finds a way. \

I love it.

[Freddy Fuschia 666]

The word I have is that GC Suns don't rate Jack very highly. Won't be nominating him.

[olisik 4,060]

I hate you.

Cool story

If anyone wants to burn their membership over who we pick then they should just walk away now.

We will pick who we pick. I don't know why these Viney threads are so big.

Just have faith our boys know what they are doing ffs. We either take him or we don't, and then we get on with it.

[rjay 23,970]

Liam Pickering was the "other bloke" on the show.

I wouldn't take much notice of what Hutchy has to say about the game of football. He was the one that had GC making the 8 this year and us top 4 last year, not a great judge of the game is our Hutchy. The politics of the game and stirring up a bit of trouble is more his go.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

These Viney threads are so big because there are usually arguments about what the kid is worth between logical, rational people- and people like you Olisdik

[Hannibal 5,814]

The word I have is that GC Suns don't rate Jack very highly. Won't be nominating him.

You may be right.

Scotty Clayton rated Cale equal no. 1 in his draft year and loves the outside types. Or your source could be dodgy.

[baysidedave 246]

If the MFC stuff this up I will end a 50 year association, mostly miserable on my behalf,with brief highlights Re:Flower and the Northy years..This kid means more to the MFC then squabbling about a arbitrary position of 1 -10.

His Brand to the MFC is as important as a sponsor

agree totally, if they don't have Jack on there list next year they can forget it, will cancel membership

[baysidedave 246]

Cool story

If anyone wants to burn their membership over who we pick then they should just walk away now.

We will pick who we pick. I don't know why these Viney threads are so big.

Just have faith our boys know what they are doing ffs. We either take him or we don't, and then we get on with it.

Had faith for a long time and they haven't delivered. They had better pick up Jack.

[ILLDieADemon 804]

Hasn't anyone realised that we're bluffing just so the SUNs and GWS don't bid on him?

They're going to take him whereever they have to to get him. We have put to much time into Viney to get him ready for round 1 not to take me.

We would just prefer to take him a pick 20 so we get 3 top picks instead of 2.

[wattsup 470]

The two of us

Good article about Viney and Ollie Wines. You can see they would both love to be at the Dees next year and I hope it's true. I really rate Wines.