Farewell Brodie Grundy

[Gawndy the Great 7,475]

25 minutes ago, rpfc said:

 

You guys are just gearing yourselves up to be disappointed. We may be willing to keep the player. That is vastly different to being happy to keep him - we are not getting a first round pick and we will end up with something similar to what we paid so that Brodie can go somewhere he will play.

These are people with careers - we aren’t going Dodoro the situation, and he is certainly isn’t ‘a team player’ for meeting with other clubs in the bye week before a finals series he is highly unlikely to feature in. 

This is not the future we sold him and we will do what good clubs do.

When we took Grundy, we took him coming off a 12 month injury and there was speculation that he may never get right and Pies needed to get him off their books. Not suggesting we take a future 1st but it’s going to be more than what we paid for him given he is now fit, proved capable and is in good form and at 650K is a bargain. 

[Deebauched 1,219]

It seemed odd that Schache was given another contract. Doesnt seem so odd now . FFS.

Cant believe  Grundy is going  already. He's just got here ! 

We need JVR up forward not flopping about around the ground.

Tmac is almost done. What happens when Gawn gets injured????

Gawn  could get monstered next Thursday and we'll need Grundy to take over in the ruck especially if were playing week after.

Grundy must stay.

[Kent 2,588]

3 minutes ago, Deebauched said:

It seemed odd that Schache was given another contract. Doesnt seem so odd now . FFS.

Cant believe  Grundy is going  already. He's just got here ! 

We need JVR up forward not flopping about around the ground.

Tmac is almost done. What happens when Gawn gets injured????

Gawn  could get monstered next Thursday and we'll need Grundy to take over in the ruck especially if were playing week after.

Grundy must stay.

all valid points in my view

 

[Willmoy1947 3,790]

Port players must be ecstatic about how their team is totally inadequate before Finals have even started.

So they then decided to send two kids and the Coach to meet an Elite Ruckman from another side.

Sounds like amateur hour to me.

Edited September 2, 2023 by Willmoy1947
grammar

[Deebauched 1,219]

On 8/24/2023 at 4:27 PM, John Demonic said:

I've only ever heard Goldstein wanting to be a one club player in interviews. Seems more important to him than playing in finals, or maybe even playing again. He has a type of misplaced club loyalty that is to the detriment of maximising his individual potential and retiring a (league) great. He could've won a flag with Geelong. And could win a flag with another club, but he has chosen not to.

Robert Flower could have been a 4 x Premiership player had he signed with Carlton back around  1978. Chose loyalty over success.  Carlton were all over him. The pen and contract sat on their desk gathering dust.

Glad he stayed. Still a club legend with no flags.

Edited September 2, 2023 by Deebauched

[Deebauched 1,219]

4 minutes ago, Deebauched said:

 

 

Edited September 2, 2023 by Deebauched

[rpfc 27,501]

31 minutes ago, Gawndy the Great said:

When we took Grundy, we took him coming off a 12 month injury and there was speculation that he may never get right and Pies needed to get him off their books. Not suggesting we take a future 1st but it’s going to be more than what we paid for him given he is now fit, proved capable and is in good form and at 650K is a bargain. 

He’s not playing AFL and he is on $650k, if he was in good form he would be playing.

Im sorry but reality doesn’t see what you see.

[rpfc 27,501]

32 minutes ago, Deebauched said:

It seemed odd that Schache was given another contract. Doesnt seem so odd now . FFS.

Cant believe  Grundy is going  already. He's just got here ! 

We need JVR up forward not flopping about around the ground.

Tmac is almost done. What happens when Gawn gets injured????

Gawn  could get monstered next Thursday and we'll need Grundy to take over in the ruck especially if were playing week after.

Grundy must stay.

He’s not leaving next Monday FFS.

Gawn gets injured in QF, Grundy will play SF but Oct rolls around and he will move on, and we will move onto another back up ruck, hopefully one that can also play forward.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,489]

1 hour ago, old55 said:

Trade period runs 9-18 October, we could be playing on 30 September. When do you think it's a good date for him to start investigating his future?

Do you reckon we weren't talking to him until after Collingwood's GF last year?

True but Grundy was injured last year so was no hope of playing. A little different.

[old55 21,356]

Grundy going to one of our main competitors say either Port or Sydney over the next few years will result in a fair loss of IP. Of course Collingwood has rolled that same dice with us this year.

[Colm 1,477]

I think future first with pick 34 going back the other way would be about right. They will back themselves in to improve next year with him in the team and if they end up in the top 4 next year they would come out in front in terms of trade points but we would snare another first round pick. 

[Jaded No More 58,132]

If Grundy plays and wins a flag this year, would he still be out the door?

[layzie 28,935]

5 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

If Grundy plays and wins a flag this year, would he still be out the door?

[rpfc 27,501]

5 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

If Grundy plays and wins a flag this year, would he still be out the door?

Depends on how he plays - if he is playing first ruck which is the most likely way he plays - something unthinkable has happened to Gawn that may end his career. 

Then, yes, we will keep him…

Not worth thinking about tho.

[ElDiablo14 3,135]

It's going to be very interesting how the club manages the transition period of Gawn going into retirement.

I believe he's got two mere years in his contract?

Hard for me to see anything but an additional year for him.

We are still in a good position to try and develop a young ruckman. But time is running out.

Grundy was a good back up plan, but he is not willing to remain under Max's shadow.

[whatwhat say what 19,090]

25 minutes ago, ElDiablo14 said:

It's going to be very interesting how the club manages the transition period of Gawn going into retirement.

I believe he's got two mere years in his contract?

Hard for me to see anything but an additional year for him.

We are still in a good position to try and develop a young ruckman. But time is running out.

Grundy was a good back up plan, but he is not willing to remain under Max's shadow.

i see no reason why max can't be like sandilands and play til he's in his late 30s

he's still the best ruckman in the competition and has been for six years because if his incredible athletic and aerobic capacity - as long as he maintains that, he's not getting less skilled at his craft

[ElDiablo14 3,135]

3 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

i see no reason why max can't be like sandilands and play til he's in his late 30s

he's still the best ruckman in the competition and has been for six years because if his incredible athletic and aerobic capacity - as long as he maintains that, he's not getting less skilled at his craft

My main concern is if he sustains one more knee injury (touch wood).

At his age it could be hard to come back from that.

[Supreme_Demon 3,011]

2 hours ago, rpfc said:

 

You guys are just gearing yourselves up to be disappointed. We may be willing to keep the player. That is vastly different to being happy to keep him - we are not getting a first round pick and we will end up with something similar to what we paid so that Brodie can go somewhere he will play.

These are people with careers - we aren’t going Dodoro the situation, and he is certainly isn’t ‘a team player’ for meeting with other clubs in the bye week before a finals series he is highly unlikely to feature in. 

This is not the future we sold him and we will do what good clubs do.

I respectfully disagree.

We will do the right thing by Brodie Grundy. But we will also do what BENEFITS the Melbourne Football Club.

I reiterate that Brodie Grundy has signed a 4 year deal with us.

We have all the power. Don't forget that.

This means if Port Adelaide wish to obtain a trade for Brodie Grundy they need to come up with an attractive offer that is beneficial for both parties.

Otherwise, we simply say NO to Port Adelaide. We have all the bargaining power.

[mo64 5,209]

4 minutes ago, ElDiablo14 said:

My main concern is if he sustains one more knee injury (touch wood).

At his age it could be hard to come back from that.

Why are people surmising that Max may sustain an injury in his latter playing days, but Grundy won't? Grundy turns 30 next year, so I can never understand why people think he's an ideal successor when Max retires.

[ElDiablo14 3,135]

Just now, mo64 said:

Why are people surmising that Max may sustain an injury in his latter playing days, but Grundy won't? Grundy turns 30 next year, so I can never understand why people think he's an ideal successor when Max retires.

I am not inferring Grundy is the be all end all.

Just more of general thought on the way the club will transition in the post Max Gawn era, unfortunately the skipper is not eternal.

[mo64 5,209]

1 minute ago, ElDiablo14 said:

I am not inferring Grundy is the be all end all.

Just more of general thought on the way the club will transition in the post Max Gawn era, unfortunately the skipper is not eternal.

I agree, but his ideal successor would be someone in the 23 - 25 age bracket who may be happy to develop at Casey, or shows ability up forward. 

 

[picket fence 15,244]

5 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

But he has every chance of being in the team..

All it does is create extra unnecessary noise because now the media will be banging on about it if he isn't selected. 

Goody hates talking about it every single week and so he should because his primary focus should will be on the 22 that will be playing.

 

We are up to the ears in finals and a player with 16 games behind him and on a four year deal is meeting with another finals team contender re 2024?? FMD! On yer bike son!

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,246]

If he does leave, hopefully it’s a mature and professional departure where both parties are happy.

I’d rather not see 7 Brodie Grundy articles next year where he Cans the club at every opportunity.

[old55 21,356]

Max said on Gus and Gawny that he couldn't se himself making 250 games.

[Fat Tony 4,437]

This is going to be a challenging trade in the off season. Port only have picks #37 and #43 which will go out with bids etc and are also trying to lure Ratugolea and Zerk-Thatcher. We will also not want to put Paul Connors offside, but we need to make sure a fair price is paid.