Not my question. 

Also Ed Langdon didn't play on Friday night. 

 

Yes

Straight in. 

bye bye melky

No!

Yes.

Needs match fitness. If there's no VFL, then maybe. If the VFL is back after the bye, then he needs a week

Yes.

When he's fit, YES.

No, the mids are working as a unit, he needs to get his touch and match fitness at Casey

Is Viney an automatic inclusion? 
 

yes 

definitely 

absolutely 

Viney would have been but given Sparrow and Jordon are performing he may need a run at VFL.

Not even a question.

The only question is who makes way.

I don’t think anyone is an automatic inclusion.

 

Except when it’s Jack Viney. 

After re-watching the '87 elimination final last night I'd also bring in Todd, but as a medical sub.

Edited June 6, 20214 yr by bush demon

Viney is a lock! 

I hope they can map out a program that has him ready to run through brick walls in the prelim. What that looks like with his foot I'm not sure but it looks like he might struggle to play all games so give him the Clark Keating (triple premiership player for the Lions who only played about 10 home and away games) treatment.

While Harmes is doing his job he possibly isn't needed and it's also good to get games into Sparrow, but of course Jack Viney makes us a better side.

Without a doubt he is. He’s our vice captain. 
However he will surely need some match fitness. How he gets that with no VFL I am not too sure. 

You mean is the player who has for years been in the top 20 percent of players in the comp across 80 percent of the vital statistics get a game with us? Obviously not. 

Edited June 6, 20214 yr by Queanbeyan Demon
Typo

Of course he is. I love what sparrow is starting to do though 

Think Harmes would be furiously sticking pins into his Viney voodoo doll. Not sure what roll James would have once Jack is back. 

No free passes.

Make em earn it

51 minutes ago, layzie said:

I don’t think anyone is an automatic inclusion.

 

Except when it’s Jack Viney. 

As well as Gawny, Clarry, Trac, Lingers, Maysie, Lever, TMac, 

Yes 100%

If it was 2 or 3 weeks then yes an automatic selection. He has missed a few more than that so I would bring him back via Casey.