Post Match Discussion - Round 4

[Dr.D 1,771]

what did you guys expect! we played terrible against Brisbane and north but we accept mediocre performances. Even some of these demonlanders who say 'a wins a win' is the attitude that leads to these losses. 

 

[jnrmac 20,276]

We have a team full of dumb footballers with zero leadership.

Our defence is amateur hour. Hawks had 15 entries for 12 shots at goal Not sure what the finished total was but this is the identical issue to that we faced against Geelong when they had 20 shots at goal from 24 entries in the first half!

Coupled with our unbelievable inefficiency going fwd and the game was gone. 1 goal in 3 quarters of football from plenty of entries says it all.

Goodwin can't coach. There, I have said it. We are fuckered

 

[demonique 314]

So many times a heap of our team were scrabbling about attempting to pick a wet and slippery ball and the Hawk players just toe poked it out into an open field full of Hawk players ,,,, goal . How many times this occurred ? T

[deestar 159]

Should have kicked 7 in the first quarter. Should coulda would. Repeat entries continually going Super wide to the pocket.

Probably should have snagged at least 2 or 3 in the second and kept them honest.

Hawks stayed in it with cheap goals over the back (5 I counted) .... Then the second half was one of the worst I can recall in a number of years ! 8 points to 67 with out a single Yelp is just not acceptable.

Jake Lever ...???.... Wtf .... He's looking like a liability at this point in time. He panics !! I thought we were bring in a cool head to really strength or back line.

I'm a little perplexed at present. Not slashing my wrists but I see zero growth and improvement this year and after today that is not a performance of a top with side.

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,297]

19 minutes ago, Clintosaurus said:

We will be 12th in around 10 minutes.

Lol.... We were 3rd on Friday night,  not many teams could pull that off! 

[DV8 2,271]

14 minutes ago, pitmaster said:

I cannot fathom why we can't at least try to adapt our game to the conditions, but trying to play precise, highly skilled football in the wet is a recipe for disasters like today.

Once your choked on pressure; an individual or a team, its really almost the end of the session.

 

We as a club turn on our own, adding to the amount of pressure of today's Hawks side applies. They sacrificed their first Qtr, to focus defensively on us, mostly.

 

We started to react to that pressure clearly in the 2nd Qtr.   And then midway thru, the Hawks started to play their game. 

We were lost in our own plans from that time on, and we were playing catch-up footy, mentally.

 

I'm glad that if this had to happen to us, that it was so close to the start of the season.  We have time to regroup as a team.

 

its going to take a bit of work to get back that belief in our direction. thats not the coaches fault.

 

Its a Mfc club issue, which we have had for decades.  Even in the late 80's it was still hanging around in the crevices.

 

I think it must have started back in the 60's and 70's, when we had become the easybeat's of the competition.

 

Successive coaches and admins have failed to rid us of this nightmare.. . add the Hawks (our modern day Nemesis) to this issue, and there we are today.

 

We must start to change off the field as supporters, when the pressure is on.

.... and we have to aim our fear/anger & our Venom at the opposition...... rather than our own players during the games.

 

This may start to help a little.

.

[Demonsone 2,050]

Not sure what to say or think ..  very frustrated as to why professional footballers would play such dumb dry weather footy in wet conditions! 

Would love to hear from Goodwin & the leaders as why they continued to do so for 3qtrs..  

[Soidee 1,496]

This is the Gold medal team in the AFL for disappointing its supporters and I can only say that I still cannot trust this club to do it right.  They put the cue in the rack without any fight today.  That in itself is putrid in my book.  Posted for years and still cannot see us as a serious team.  They rip your heart out!

[beelzebub 23,390]

22 minutes ago, Nasher said:

Not saying I was thrilled with it bb, just wasn't worried yet. We were still getting enough of the ball at that stage and I've seen us have low scoring quarters before, correct it and come away with a win. 

I fess i was less than happy when they strolled to an opening goal. Somewhat relieved when we started playing. Got a bit worried when wed already gone off boil by qtr time. Missing opportunity and gifting theirs wasnt a goid indication. 

Goal less in 2nd quarter had me upping worry to concern.

Another qtr without a major had me scornful of the box...

Full time....yep... gunna be another year of rubbish.

[Soidee 1,496]

12 years of misery and we still are waiting.  Meanwhile professional clubs and players continue to march on while we accept putrid mediocrity.

[ding 5,126]

After all these years...............

Countless rebuilds...........

Multiple coaches........

Several false dawns......

So many game plans i cant remember them all.............,

here we are in yet another post match thread discussing a right royal flogging by the Hawks.  

The same Hawks who won 3 premierships on the trot just a few years ago, bottomed out and rebuilt. 

How THE ACTUAL [censored] can we keep coming up with performances like today ? This is a game we had every right to expect a victory in. We are on the rise after all... /sarc

Goodwin is the most Vanilla coach i have ever seen. Dont reckon i have ever seen him display passion during games OR interviews. You want a team that is "resilient and humble" Goody? How bout you make us a team that can play consistent football? The players need someone to inspire them as they cant seem to do it for themselves. Goodwin is so flat and boring i doubt he has it in him.

FFS i am fuming after todays surrender.

2-2 and looking at a huge loss next Tuesday, it suddenly becomes extremely hard to make finals.  Our percentage might also be terrible if we repeat what happened today. The veil of negativity is well deserved.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

5 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

We have a team full of dumb footballers with zero leadership.

Our defence is amateur hour. Hawks had 15 entries for 12 shots at goal Not sure what the finished total was but this is the identical issue to that we faced against Geelong when they had 20 shots at goal from 24 entries in the first half!

Coupled with our unbelievable inefficiency going fwd and the game was gone. 1 goal in 3 quarters of football from plenty of entries says it all.

Goodwin can't coach. There, I have said it. We are fuckered

 

This is the big one for me.  I won't go over the top with it like your last line, but the above needs to be addressed by the club.

Goodwin said in his press conference this evening that we need to get back to playing to our 'strengths' and that today we didn't play our sort of football.  That's all well and good, but what you mentioned above has happened in pretty much every game we've played in this season.  We have 6-7 repeat entries for maybe 1 goal, then they'll run it off half back and score.  It's hard to watch and must be deflating for the players.

Something needs to be done about this as we won't get anywhere near finals if this continues.

[DV8 2,271]

40 minutes ago, DeeZee said:

That loss against Collingwood in the final  round last year had nothing to do with our mental application ,Collingwood are simply better than us, so are Geelong, even with out Danger, and Hawthorn.

We have done nothing to prove we are a good side, beside beat mediocre teams.

Our coach is as wooden as they come, and for some reason ditched our backline coach in Rawlings, for a rookie in Chaplin.

I think Rawlings chose to move into the new role.   As a further extension to his coaching career abilities.

[buck_nekkid 6,068]

That was truly awful.  What can Goodie say in the presser?

Lever was honestly putrid.  Just Putrid.

beaten all over, except for Max.  

Need changes in attitude, structure and application.

[Skuit 10,031]

Clarkson is such a coaching mastermind that he managed to induce a collective PTSD by plonking Frawley in Melbourne's defensive 50. 

[DubDee 26,306]

When you have a small fwd line WHY KICK IT LONG AND HIGH EVERYTIME!?!?

[DV8 2,271]

2 minutes ago, DubDee said:

When you have a small fwd line WHY KICK IT LONG AND HIGH EVERYTIME!?!?

Under the pump.

The same as when a team overuses the ball in-close, when under pressure.

 

The Hawks/Clarko worked us over, Mentally.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Hawthorn have such a well-drilled system that even with injuries they still function.

We rely on sheer grunt and effort, but if it drops off even slightly we are doomed.

You can’t be all system or all grunt, you need a balance, ours is way off.

Edited April 15, 2018 by Clint Bizkit

[DV8 2,271]

7 minutes ago, buck_nekkid said:

That was truly awful.  What can Goodie say in the presser?

Lever was honestly putrid.  Just Putrid.

beaten all over, except for Max.  

Need changes in attitude, structure and application.

When you see a couple of our defenders over run the ball that's on the ground, leaving it behind them, then it's obvious, the players were way under Pressure today.

I know its no good, I was feeling sick later in the game yelling at the TV.

On both channels, while the netballers played the last minute, and lost the gold.

 

We need to learn to handle pressure better, and to do the little things to help one another, in these situations. even off the field guys, in the seats.

[defuture15 900]

What happened to play tight tackling footy in the wet?

They should not have had space and time to score heavily after half time?

Where is the team defence?

[Demon Dynasty 17,130]

1 hour ago, McQueen said:

But let’s concentrate on being a ‘Melbourne Person’ whatever the feck that is.

What a pathetic excuse for a football ad campaign that is.  What idiot came up with that carp.  There is no Demon in the advertising/marketing and name of the club and there is no Demonic effort on the field either whenever we come up against a serious contender.  The Demon has been left out of all aspects of this club and is now almost a memory only.

Edited April 15, 2018 by Rusty Nails

[Coq au vin 755]

Hawthorn are an awesome team again. We are not. Yet...

[Soidee 1,496]

Back where we belong around the 10 to 12 mark on the ladder.  Any higher and we are out of our comfort zone.  Richmond and Essendon will rip us new ones and that will be our 2018!  All talk, no serious advancement.  Story of a MFC supporters lot.

[leave it to deever 17,591]

1 hour ago, Wiseblood said:

1 hour ago, big_red_fire_engine said:

Anzac eve. 

I'm with you, red.  It's a very, very disappointing loss that we have to swallow today, but I'm very interested in what Goodwin and the players do from here.  While much lies at the feet of Goodwin, some of the players have to take responsibility for their performances as well.

A big 8 days lie ahead.

Man I wish I could be as calm as you.

The really frustrating thing for me was this was a chance to make a real stand.

We did nothing but.

I know its early days but I cant help be concerned if not angry.

i tell myself its just a game but a flag or a flag like team wouldn't hurt. Today points to no flag this year despite the hype. Maybe therein lies the problem. We were favorites and I think this team can drink its own bath water. Many supporters have........especially me.

Tigers game will determine our season.

[Bonkers 994]

43 minutes ago, DemonAndrew said:

I tend to agree

Chappy is a lovely fella but his history in backlines - Port, Richmond and now us - leaves a lot to be desired

Our whole game plan is predicated on winning contested ball; we absolutely failed at that for an extended period today

We have failed at it in patches of games but today we really stunk it up at our core game plan

We win enough of the ball and our structures were ok for 1.5 qtrs today. But we are inefficient moving the ball forward. We are getting more of the ball and more inside 50s most weeks yet fail to do anything with them. Some are saying we are a good team/ have good players but I beg to differ. We have some good players but a lot of our players skills under pressure are ordinary and or theyre getting coached to bomb the ball vs hitting up a target. Our spread / running was non existent today after the 1st qtr. Is that laziness I'm not sure?

Defensively our structure has massive holes in it due to our running and positional set up. We get scored on too easily whilst at the other end we are fighting for every score. The game plan is inefficient and it relies on us winning the clearances. We aren't that good around the ground using space. Clarkson pulled our game plan apart in this area. For the latter part of the game it looked like they were feeding off Max Gawns taps as well.

Most supporters can see it unfolding in front of us. If the coaches don't make changes I can't see us playing finals. Hopefully this is a lesson for Goodwin.