Post game discussion - Round 10

[bush demon 1,927]

1 hour ago, Soidee said:

This club, the players, supporters and media need to realise we are not top 8 material YET, any talk of it is just plain dumb.  We have a dearth of young talent still developing.  At best we are 10th - 14th, any other talk is rubbish.

my grizzle is aimed at senior players who do not lead when it is needed, it is an old chestnut but it is an accurate one.  

If anyone can tell me what the hell (apart from money) this club has gained by selling home games over the past10 years, I am happy to listen.  Screw selling home games, it should stop forthwith as soon as last contract ends.  The quality of all these games is poor and frankly worse than watching VFL.  I cannot see what benefit it is to developing players to be dragged to Alice Springs each year to get beaten.  It is a gift to Port Adelaide, and it was always a gift to Brisbane in the past. I'm over it!!!  

OUR HOME IS MCG!!!! 

Esssendon Richmond  'dreamtime' being promoted as the game of the day today on ABC today sums it up. both teams playing on our home ground whilst we play our home game thousands of miles away. both melbourne and port placed above rich/essendon on the ladder. 

[leave it to deever 16,550]

1 hour ago, dees189227 said:

There is no way port are a 7 better goal team than us. Its the same stuff as it awlys is when we lose. Don't man up hard enough, the opp players get the ball to easily, to many easy goals in there 50 today they just had loose players there all the time to get the ball over the back. At times we couldn't even hit a player 30 metres out on the chest, poor handballing and missing easy shots at goal. 

Spot on. We are better than we played today and it why it is so annoying.

Why were we so slow to get to contests? Why didnt our tackles stick?

Melb was like the sound on my foxtel play which arrived 5 seconds after the action

Yes the defence was under pressure but it needs to do better. That's their job. Cant give them a pass for being under the pump.

[Kumamoto_Ken 1,531]

54 minutes ago, waynewussell said:

We looked mediocre, we played mediocre, we're placed mediocre, we seem happy with mediocre. There was never a time today when a player, or players, looked [censored] off about being mediocre!

Hogan looked [censored] off after a couple of his mediocre misses.

Edited May 28, 2016 by Kumamoto_Ken

[special robert 438]

Garland back to the Magoos....Frost and Dunn to the backline.

[leave it to deever 16,550]

Roos: We were terrible defensively. Young guys get energised by scoring but top defensive teams win premiership #afldeespower

 

 

[jacey 333]

42 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

BS, been available for a few games and you have made that assessment? Rising Star last week. McCartin has played 10 games in nearly one and a half seasons.

 

Petracca has played 5 in a year and half so not sure what point you're making. We dont count mccartins injury to petraccas? 

Paddy is strong, good contested mark and looks more promising as a future star.

Didn't say Trac is a dud but saints got it right and got the better player. 

[Return to Glory 7,846]

2 minutes ago, jacey said:

 

Petracca has played 5 in a year and half so not sure what point you're making. We dont count mccartins injury to petraccas? 

Paddy is strong, good contested mark and looks more promising as a future star.

Didn't say Trac is a dud but saints got it right and got the better player. 

Horseshite.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Just now, jacey said:

 

Petracca has played 5 in a year and half so not sure what point you're making. We dont count mccartins injury to petraccas? 

Paddy is strong, good contested mark and looks more promising as a future star.

Didn't say Trac is a dud but saints got it right and got the better player. 

So McCartin clunks a few and he's the better player?

I'll remind myself in future not to read your tripe as you clearly have no idea about football.

[Binmans PA 26,659]

16 minutes ago, jacey said:

 

Petracca has played 5 in a year and half so not sure what point you're making. We dont count mccartins injury to petraccas? 

Paddy is strong, good contested mark and looks more promising as a future star.

Didn't say Trac is a dud but saints got it right and got the better player. 

Even if this were the case, they had the first pick... what's the point you're making? That St Kilda didn't [censored] it up when they had the first pick?

[Ethan Tremblay 28,776]

14 minutes ago, jacey said:

 

Petracca has played 5 in a year and half so not sure what point you're making. We dont count mccartins injury to petraccas? 

Paddy is strong, good contested mark and looks more promising as a future star.

Didn't say Trac is a dud but saints got it right and got the better player. 

I recommend taking a full day to recover after a loss before posting.

[dazzledavey36 49,735]

16 minutes ago, jacey said:

 

Petracca has played 5 in a year and half so not sure what point you're making. We dont count mccartins injury to petraccas? 

Paddy is strong, good contested mark and looks more promising as a future star.

Didn't say Trac is a dud but saints got it right and got the better player. 

By far the worst post i have ever read.

 

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Just now, dazzledavey36 said:

By far the worst post i have ever read.

 

Give it a few more hours mate.  After a loss we seemingly have plenty of these sorts of posts.  It makes for excruciating reading.

[The Stigga 974]

2 hours ago, Wiseblood said:

Give it a few more hours mate.  After a loss we seemingly have plenty of these sorts of posts.  It makes for excruciating reading.

 

Geez WB, you're turning into Saty mark II.

 

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Just now, The Stigga said:

 

Geez WB, you're turning into Saty mark II.

 

And you're turning in to a stalker.

[dazzledavey36 49,735]

Glad i played footy and did not have to watch any of the rubbish dished up. 

Makes going to bed alot easier rather then being angry.

[spirit of norm smith 13,574]

Who have we beaten?? I think we caught GWS in round 1 (no Jeremy Cameron, Dees played one quarter, Giants inaccurate)

Tigers, Magpies, Lions, Suns only.

[bjDee 1,249]

Just so disappointed after watching that.  So much like watching games of the past several years.  And there's no VFL this weekend to go and watch to lift the spirits.

Despite the calls that players of the likes of Dunn, Frost, Pederson and Dawes wouldn't have made a difference because of the over the back play, I disagree.  So many of our attacking (and poorly directed) 'bombs' to the forward line were to a 1-on-2 out-contested Hogan as the only decent stay at home forward.  But at least they usually made it to a contest, so usually the bombs had a chance.  But there was NO OTHER forward as a target.  NONE.  SAME DEFICIENCY AS LAST WEEK.   FFS when your 3rd forward, Watts, has to go and spend time in the ruck, leaving the whole front half basically dependent on one young guy in Hogan still learning his craft, what the F are the selection committee thinking????  We needed another forward / ruck in this team.  It would have helped our structure no end.

If those entries into the fwd 50 had been better handled, there would have been far fewer rebounds for Port to run, carry and kick over the back for their goals.

Edited May 28, 2016 by bjDee
spelling

[Sir Why You Little 35,318]

39 minutes ago, jacey said:

 

Petracca has played 5 in a year and half so not sure what point you're making. We dont count mccartins injury to petraccas? 

Paddy is strong, good contested mark and looks more promising as a future star.

Didn't say Trac is a dud but saints got it right and got the better player. 

Very Big Call to make around here...

People remember Big Calls

[Ethan Tremblay 28,776]

Just now, Sir Why You Little said:

Very Big Call to make around here...

People remember Big Calls

And stupid ones.

[Fork 'em 6,616]

29 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

By far the worst post i have ever read.

 

Lol .... yeah right.

I've read worse from you.

 

[olisik 4,060]

Kent consistently does nothing in first half of games.

[Pipefitter 2,081]

Our game plan requires 100% effort from all players on the ground. Our forwards were shocking. How many times did they waltz it out from defence. Kent, harmes, Garlett did jack.

[Moonshadow 16,572]

56 minutes ago, jacey said:

 

Petracca has played 5 in a year and half so not sure what point you're making. We dont count mccartins injury to petraccas? 

Paddy is strong, good contested mark and looks more promising as a future star.

Didn't say Trac is a dud but saints got it right and got the better player. 

Rubbish. Tracc has only been injury free from about round 2, unless you are claiming he should've played last year on one leg. 

Dumb logic.

 

[KingDingAling 3,681]

1 hour ago, jacey said:

Saints made the right call. 

Mccartin > petracca

I think they made the wrong call. I reckon Brayshaw will be better than both of them.

[Fork 'em 6,616]

If he can stop getting knocked out.