Who Will Win The B&F (Poll)

[Demon Jack 6,336]

Who do you think will finish with the most votes at the end of Friday night?

Vote away and Go Dees!

[daisycutter 28,630]

colin garland, jack watts, angus brayshaw??

Edited September 7, 2015 by daisycutter

[Biffen 12,370]

The Jones boy.

Again.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,493]

Can anyone please enlighten me as to how the voting works? I remember that one year recently, every player was awarded votes from 1-7 for every game played resulting in the strange result that players who might have played just one poor game for the year still got votes. Is it still that system? if so, it makes it hard for players who missed multiple games with injury irrespective of how well they played when on the park (eg, Viney).

[Gorgoroth 12,331]

Bernardo

[jane02 3,382]

Bernie

[Ethan Tremblay 28,468]

McDonald could come close, was very good to round 8 or 9. Played some decent games in between and had a good game yesterday.

[Nasher 33,131]

Bernie. That patch of form was white hot. Best form I've seen at the MFC since Woewodin in 2000.

Jones and McDonald to round out the top 3. Viney to make a late charge to finish top 5, but will prove to have missed too many games to challenge the others.

Viney has been our most consistent performer this year IMO. Didn't have the real form slump that the top 3 had, at least not that I can recall.

[Pates 9,537]

Shocked that more people think Tommy Mac will win than Jonesy.

Vince

Jones

TMac

Viney

Hogan

[Maldonboy38 5,948]

Vince

N Jones

Tom McDonald will poll well early in the year

Viney wil poll very well late in the year.

Gawn's influence in games has been immense - may surprise with how well he polls.

[praha 10,294]

List lacks Jack Watts.

[Pennant St Dee 11,351]

Bernie will win it, he hit a patch late which will definitely rule him out of AA but he did go through a patch there where he was holding his won and beating the bets mids in the comp

1. Vince

2. Viney (missed a few but will finish very strongly

3. Cross

4. Jones

5. Tmac

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,493]

List lacks Jack Watts.

Jack Watts listless? In so many ways.

[Go the Biff 3,176]

I reckon at the halfway mark, McDonald would have had a bigger lead than Vo Rogue

He had an ordinary month or so but has finished pretty solidly> he was among our best in most of the woeful team performances of the last month

[Forest Demon 4,681]

The Jones boy.

Again.

Matt?

[Glenn Molloy 494]

Vince

daylight

T Mac

Jones

Cross

Hogan

[Dee-licious 1,859]

Wow - very one sided so far. Thought there would be more love for Tommy Mac. Thinking that Dunn will poll well as he does do the 'team' thing, and he did chop out TMac on a few occasions. Gawn to do well in the second half, but should be Vince, Tommy, Viney, Jones, Cross, Hogan pretty clearly.

[Glenn Molloy 494]

Tommy was undoubtedly our best in the first third of the year but he regressed from QB onward - unfortunately, too many of the brain fades and shocking disposals that blighted previous years. I do wonder if he started to try and do too much after Cloke got the chocolates against him, he does seem to beat himself up after a bad performance. He also wasn't helped by being shoved forward for a few games. He did ok there at times but he should only be tried there again as a pinch hit or in an emergency.

[Gator 16,893]

If Hogan isn't top 3 I'll be very surprised.

[DeeZee 6,779]

Top four will easily be

Vince

McDonald

Jones

Viney

[Gator 16,893]

Top four will easily be

Vince

McDonald

Jones

Viney

Viney missed 6 games, which will make it difficult for him to be top 4.

Tom McDonald has had some very ordinary games.

Nathan Jones stank from round 16. Round 23 is about the only decent game of the last 8.

[P-man 13,224]

Bernie somewhat comfortably I would think.

Hogan, Jonesy, T Mac, Viney to round out top five.

Edited September 7, 2015 by P-man

[DeeZee 6,779]

Hogan should be in the top five , it's just the order of the 3rd 4th and 5th out of Hoges, Jones and Viney,but Vince and Tmac will be top two in my opinion.

[Choko 493]

Top 3 in order:

- Vince

- Jones

- McDonald (Oscar's brother)

[Deespicable 2,553]

Can anyone please enlighten me as to how the voting works? I remember that one year recently, every player was awarded votes from 1-7 for every game played resulting in the strange result that players who might have played just one poor game for the year still got votes. Is it still that system? if so, it makes it hard for players who missed multiple games with injury irrespective of how well they played when on the park (eg, Viney).

I couldn't find anyone had answered this question so here's last year vote details.

The votes are cast by four members of Melbourne's match committee who give players a score from 0-10 for each game.

I'm afraid that description needs more detail from someone in the know because last year's top five scored between 238 and 311.

That would imply that Jones scored four out of 10 on average for each game last season - if he's scored that low then god help us.

1. Nathan Jones (311)

2. Dom Tyson (293)

3. Bernie Vince (270)

4. Lynden Dunn (264)

5. Daniel Cross (238)

But regardless of the system, it fair to say that we have a really even bunch this year with four players who could win it I think.

Tom Mc - brilliant early, poor middle, very good late

Vince - late start, very good middle part of year, poor finish once he got sick, except for last game.

Viney - injured Rds 2-8. Most consistent player since.

Jones - solid all year but not as spectacular as 2014.

You could also make a case for Jesse Hogan, but tin my view, he was too hot or cold - as all forwards are.