My 3 word player analysis v West Coast

[joeboy 3,174]

N. Jones - prolific and brave

Dunn - excellent but overwhelmed

Hogan - little forward presence

Watts - in and out

Toumpas - devoid of confidence

Dawes - just occasional glimpses

Viney - just a game

Brayshaw - was desperately missed

Gawn - was not disgraced

Tyson - prolific but wasteful

Stretch - will be better

Cross - disposal from hell

Garland - tight and effective

Vince - successful tagging role

McDonald - overwhelmed and beaten

Neal-Bullen - enthusiastic and talented

Garlett - needed more involvement

Howe - league's most overrated

Bail - irrelevant and ineffective

M.Jones - same as Bail

Spencer - failed to impose

Jetta - was rarely noticed

[Return to Glory 8,453]

Bit tough on Garlett I would have thought.

[Bring-Back-Powell 15,240]

Garlett our best but I guess everyone sees the game differently.

[The Great One 99 125]

Viney was good. Howe was just behind Brayshaw in effectiveness.

[Grimes is Great 183]

I thought Viney tried hard to, some great tackles.

[praha 11,253]

N. Jones - Classic Jones game
Dunn - Costly brain farts
Hogan - Contested but frustrated
Watts - Silky yet unreliable
Toumpas - Classic Toumpas game
Dawes - Doesn't provide enough
Viney - Battled on throughout
Brayshaw - Sub created hole
Gawn - Work horse game
Tyson - Sighted but wasteful
Stretch - Punches above weight
Cross - Pressured and erratic
Garland - Reliable defensive warrior
Vince - Redefining tagging role
McDonald - A tough month
Neal-Bullen - Looks very dangerous
Garlett - Great forward pressure
Howe - Pack your bags
Bail - There's the door
M.Jones - See ya, champ!
Spencer - Needs a rest
Jetta - Outrun and beaten

Edited July 4, 2015 by praha

[dazzledavey36 55,853]

Garlet comment is ridicules.

Dunn - excellent but overwhelmed... WTF Dunn was pathetic. Gave away stupid free kicks and 50m penalty. He is lucky Kennedy didn't kick straight.

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

Garlett's urgency and willingness to chase, harass and tackle any opposition player was nothing short of phenomenal tonight. It directly resulted in goals and scoring shots for us and he kicked 1.2 with our ball movement going inside forward 50 being terrible again. He had 10 tackles. 10!

It's [censored] tiresome reading assessments like these when they can be so wrong. It's not a matter of opinion.

You're either blind or you have no idea.

He was pretty much our best player.

Edited July 4, 2015 by stevethemanjordan

[Demon Disciple 12,452]

Viney was good. Howe was just behind Brayshaw in effectiveness.

Brayshaw had more tackles in 5 minutes than Howe did for the entire game.

[whatwhat say what 23,418]

N. Jones - Never stops trying

Dunn - Had better days

Hogan - Fumbled and frustrated

Watts - Better second half

Toumpas - Constant mistakes, again

Dawes - Had limited opportunities

Viney - Kept putting in

Brayshaw - Massive blow early

Gawn - Big let down

Tyson - Much improved tonight

Stretch - Gonna be good

Cross - Effort and errors

Garland - played his role

Vince - Best tagger ever?

McDonald - still so young

Neal-Bullen - Impressive young player

Garlett - A tackling machine

Howe - Never ever chases

Bail - Too many errors

M.Jones - See directly above

Spencer - A mistaken selection

Jetta - Made some mistakes

Edited July 4, 2015 by DemonAndrew

[RalphiusMaximus 6,102]

Toumpas - Never Hand Pass.

[picket fence 17,964]

Toumpas - Never Hand Pass.

Mind made up!

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Neal-Bullen- get more ball

He knows where to run to score goals, now needs to work on getting to more contests and getting more possies. Looks promising, like a Grimes but more skilful.

Stretch was solid too i thought.

[Coup Cooper 610]

N. Jones - prolific and brave

Dunn - excellent but overwhelmed

Hogan - little forward presence

Watts - in and out

Toumpas - devoid of confidence

Dawes - just occasional glimpses

Viney - just a game

Brayshaw - was desperately missed

Gawn - was not disgraced

Tyson - prolific but wasteful

Stretch - will be better

Cross - disposal from hell

Garland - tight and effective

Vince - successful tagging role

McDonald - overwhelmed and beaten

Neal-Bullen - enthusiastic and talented

Garlett - needed more involvement

Howe - league's most overrated

Bail - irrelevant and ineffective

M.Jones - same as Bail

Spencer - failed to impose

Jetta - was rarely noticed

I don't know what game you watched but Cross was good

[xarronn 384]

Toumpas - Never Hand Pass.

What about his handpass into the goal square for a goal?

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Neal-Bullen- get more ball

He knows where to run to score goals, now needs to work on getting to more contests and getting more possies. Looks promising, like a Grimes but more skilful.

Stretch was solid too i thought.

And Dawes knows how to run into him when he does so.

[Adzman 2,154]

I didn't watch the game so I can't comment on any players. Based on the end result it looks like we were beaten in most parts of the ground.

A 10 goal belting should force 3 changes.

[Return to Glory 8,453]

Mind made up!

Now I'm going to go out on a limb here picket fence. It is based, however, on the 250 posts you have made on the topic. You don't rate Jimmy Toumpas. Just to reiterate, you do not rate Jimmy Toumpas. You are not a fan of the Toump. You've said it before and you'll say it again, the Toump must go. Get him out of the club. Cannot play. Kaputski. Am I right?

[daisycutter 29,891]

Now I'm going to go out on a limb here picket fence. It is based, however, on the 250 posts you have made on the topic. You don't rate Jimmy Toumpas. Just to reiterate, you do not rate Jimmy Toumpas. You are not a fan of the Toump. You've said it before and you'll say it again, the Toump must go. Get him out of the club. Cannot play. Kaputski. Am I right?

i'm struggling to understand what you are saying here rtg, but i think from the general gist of it, yeah, possibly, sort-of, in a manner of saying you're perhaps on the money

[monoccular 17,642]

Now I'm going to go out on a limb here picket fence. It is based, however, on the 250 posts you have made on the topic. You don't rate Jimmy Toumpas. Just to reiterate, you do not rate Jimmy Toumpas. You are not a fan of the Toump. You've said it before and you'll say it again, the Toump must go. Get him out of the club. Cannot play. Kaputski. Am I right?

i'm struggling to understand what you are saying here rtg, but i think from the general gist of it, yeah, possibly, sort-of, in a manner of saying you're perhaps on the money

Pathetic isn't it the way people like RTG just beat about the bush and don't say anything definite :-))

[titan_uranus 25,174]

Garlett's urgency and willingness to chase, harass and tackle any opposition player was nothing short of phenomenal tonight. It directly resulted in goals and scoring shots for us and he kicked 1.2 with our ball movement going inside forward 50 being terrible again. He had 10 tackles. 10!

It's [censored] tiresome reading assessments like these when they can be so wrong. It's not a matter of opinion.

You're either blind or you have no idea.

He was pretty much our best player.

He's been doing it most of the year, too.

Wonderful pick up for this club. Love his work.

[Dinosaur Rover 197]

Both bail and jones dropped chest marks in front of goal which I cant forgive

Garletts goal assists butchered pearls before swine

Beautiful ball delivery to leading forwsrds by wc - cut our defence some slack for that and our fwds would kick twice the goals with similar delivery

Stretch and anb impressed for young light players

[jackaub 1,402]

I didnt watch the game will watch tonight on replay

How was Garlands'game? Is there anything i should watch in particular?

[RalphiusMaximus 6,102]

I didnt watch the game will watch tonight on replay

How was Garlands'game? Is there anything i should watch in particular?

If you could keep a tally of free kicks not paid to Melbourne players that would be helpful. Also an analysis of which of those non-frees were followed by a WC goal. You know, if you're offering...

[Roger Mellie 4,173]

I didnt watch the game will watch tonight on replay

How was Garlands'game? Is there anything i should watch in particular?

Tip of the week:

Turn off television at 3/4 time.