Goodwin's Law?

[CBDees 3,162]

Any idea why the club would have held off..?

Maybe so that Adelaide could announce the sacking of their coach first? It certainly enhances our position going into the trade period, not only for people like Dangerfield but also others from Adelaide or Essendon, GWS etc. I wonder who Adelaide have up their sleeve? Ron Barassi?

[Jarka 767]

Well it looks like PartyBoy will live to write another day.

Irrelevant now, but it wouldn't have been announced today had it not been for the Adelaide AND impending Gold Coast Fiasco.

You have just his legendary status at demonland, enjoy the responses.

What's happening at the GCS?

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Better work out or it will be then end of us.

I've heard that one before. Usually before we do stuff that that doesn't work out

[Binmans PA 26,576]

I didnt think he looked nervous - I thought he looked measured and calm. Two things you probably wouldnt have said about some of our previous coaches. This appointment also gives time to Viney and co to rebuild our list properly.

A mate tells me that Goodwin is as close to Jnr MacDonald a player could be without actually being Jnr MacDonald.

Im happy. Now we need a list.

Don't get me wrong, it doesn't mean he can't coach. TBH, I'm pretty happy about this. If Roos and PJ are happy, I am. But the way he was stumbling over words, suggests to me he was pretty nervous. : ) Each to their own.

Edited September 18, 2014 by AdamFarr

[Gorgoroth 12,369]

Bassett might end up back at the Crows.

[Deestroy All 14,262]

Could be a handy link if we're thinking of luring any want-away bombers.

In fact, he'd have some pretty good intel into which ones were susceptible to being lured away.

Just a thought.

Wouldn't sneeze at Carlisle.

Leroy Jetta, anyone?

Kidding!

I'd take Leroy if they threw in Carlisle as a sweetener, probably.

[TGR 1,367]

Neeld had poor oratory skills. This guy aint that much better.

Roos and Jeans are/were A grade.

I hope his footy brain, and communication ability, and stake-holder massaging ability is better than his oratory skills.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

As long as he doesnt say:

'It is what it is' or 'its a rebuild of a rebuild'

[chook fowler 18,452]

At least he doesn't come recommended by Malthouse.

[Watts Jurrah Dunn? 735]

I must admit I have never liked the successor obsession given the chances a Ross Lyon or Alistair Clarkson will be available in 2 years time when Roos is done, but good luck to Simon.

If nothing else I am happy that Tyson, Salem, Viney, Toumpas and perhaps Petracca or Brayshaw will be working with a coach who was an elite midfielder himself and isn't too long out of the game. They're not going to be learning their craft from a half back flanker.

Fingers crossed Goodwin has an exceptional relationship with Carlisle and might be able to get in his ear as well.

[RickyJ45 392]

Want to retract this one now, mate? Haha!

yeah I've copped my deserved fair whack!!

But from //www.afl.com.au/news/2014-09-18/goodwin-joins-the-demons

Goodwin admitted there was some part of him that flirted with the idea of returning to the Crows.

"Of course it does (cross you mind). The Adelaide footy club is a big part of my life, but coaching's a completely different caper and I'm really settled in Melbourne," he said,

"and after reading Demonland I was convinced coaching melbourne is the only right thing to do" (redacted)

[DubDee 21,490]

Looks like we've been Goodwin Hunting

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,534]

I must admit I have never liked the successor obsession given the chances a Ross Lyon or Alistair Clarkson will be available in 2 years time when Roos is done, but good luck to Simon.

If nothing else I am happy that Tyson, Salem, Viney, Toumpas and perhaps Petracca or Brayshaw will be working with a coach who was an elite midfielder himself and isn't too long out of the game. They're not going to be learning their craft from a half back flanker.

Fingers crossed Goodwin has an exceptional relationship with Carlisle and might be able to get in his ear as well.

Really? I thought Goodwin was primarily a half back flanker. (No, that's not rhyming slang).

I've always been a fan of the principle of succession planning. The execution is as important as the principle, though. Collingwood's succession plan wasn't handled well due to Malthouse's unwillingness to move on.

I hope we also see something similar occur with the CEO's position, although it doesn't have to be pursued as publicly as the coach succession process.

[Lucifers Hero 37,386]

Don't mind a backman as coach.

Backmen as recent premiership coaches: Sheedy, Malthouse, Roos, Clarkson, C Scott. Worsfold. Any others?

Good pedigree being a backman-turned-coach

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Don't mind a backman as coach.

Backmen as recent premiership coaches: Sheedy, Malthouse, Roos, Clarkson, C Scott. Worsfold. Any others?

Good pedigree being a backman-turned-coach

I agree, although Clarkson spent the majority of his career as a midfielder. But it bodes well for Goodwin's appointment at any rate.

[Deetective Sgt. Taggert 380]

It is hard to get particularly excited about this appointment when I and many others were hoping Roos would decide to stay on and take us to that elusive 13th flag.

But one thing that strikes me is that although its easy to think that Goodwin's involvement in the Essendrug saga leaves his a bit tainted, I think it also means he is at least better prepared to deal with the alleged psychology issues at Melbourne, given that despite all that went down the Bombers still managed to make the finals last year (only to be disqualified) and weren't too far off the mark this year. Given the wraps that Goodwins seems to be getting as a very personable bloke, surely he must have played a role in keeping the players focused as best they could.

[Demoneyes 562]

The guy who predicted Roos to Dees, Tony Sheahan, just said on twitter that Goodwin to Crows is a done deal?

He's batting now at 50% average

!

Ricciuto is calling the shots, Goodwin is the new Crows coach you can back that one in.

They couldn't afford to let him go to Melbourne, he's a favourite son like Buckley.

Glad I didn't!

haha this shows up the real kinda guy Goodwin is ....

no loss here!!!!

Used us as bait to get the job he really was after at the crows.

Just like he texted to Dank : "Get me the good stuff"

Goodwin - Get ya good medicine and go and get stuffed you self absorbed [censored]

Turn in your membership then? Or I guess you will love him soon enough

Oh how i would love for him to sign up as Roos' successor now!

I believe it is a great get. Huge bomber fans of mine said he is a big loss to them. A very stabilising influence, calm in a crisis and if anyone is similar to our PRoos he is. Be thankful that we have PJ and PR in charge! Glory days ahead

[Demoneyes 562]

Playing golf with a MFC man today. He got text while we were on 4th hole (f..ed my game after that!). He also said "Danger" is a done deal too. Will believe when I see it.

[Demoneyes 562]

Also said that Trengove, Toumpas and early pick part of the deal. I reckon that is too much... or is it?

[Biffen 12,441]

This is the first Goodwin we have had in quite some time.

[Deetective Sgt. Taggert 380]

Vince on twitter - "Absolutely wrapped to have my old captain/mentor/mate Simon Goodwin coaching at the Dees. #gun! Really excited about 2015 and beyond!!"

[DemonOX 8,551]

Also said that Trengove, Toumpas and early pick part of the deal. I reckon that is too much... or is it?

Early pick + Toump should suffice.

I would like to keep trengove especially now he will be injury free hopefully and ready to start preseason.

[Biffen 12,441]

Playing golf with a MFC man today. He got text while we were on 4th hole (f..ed my game after that!). He also said "Danger" is a done deal too. Will believe when I see it.

We might need a few dollars more...

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

Playing golf with a MFC man today. He got text while we were on 4th hole (f..ed my game after that!). He also said "Danger" is a done deal too. Will believe when I see it.

[Deetective Sgt. Taggert 380]

Also said that Trengove, Toumpas and early pick part of the deal. I reckon that is too much... or is it?

I would personally be really disappointing to lose Trengove, even if he doesn't become a gun like we hoped he could still be a very valuable contributor to the 22 and I'll never forget the faith he showed after the 186 debacle