NAB Challenge 1 - Richmond v Melbourne

[binman 43,895]

I can see the defence being borrowed from. Also there's a tall on the centre line that may have to shift fwd. Will Roos ressist?

He won't put Watts forward. I could see Dunn going forward but even so the main focus of this match is for people to practice their position and role and gell as units (eg mids, backs) so i would not be surprised if he just keeps everyone, bar Pedo, in the nominal positions.

[PJ_12345 1,098]

Most teams would kill to have Jeremy Howe as their full forward

THis week we will see him there for a full game hopefully

Probably would rather Clark, Hogan, Dawes, Cameron, Cloak, Schultz, Tippett, Franklin, Roughead, Pavlich... you get the picture.

Howe won't be good as a FF as he would draw their #1 defender.

He is best where he is most dangerous; in the forward pocket, with their #3/#4 defender.

[old dee 23,874]

He won't put Watts forward. I could see Dunn going forward but even so the main focus of this match is for people to practice their position and role and gell as units (eg mids, backs) so i would not be surprised if he just keeps everyone, bar Pedo, in the nominal positions.

I agree binman

After all pop guns nominal spot is Casey

[binman 43,895]

I agree binman

After all pop guns nominal spot is Casey

You are probably right od but because i'm often ridiculously optimistic i'm hopeful Roos can get a big improvement out of the pop gun. FOr me he was another player who looked mentally frozen last year and dead set fearful of making mistakes (which of course led to lots of them). He's a confidence player in my book (as i guess most are when all said and done) and perhaps Roos can free him up. I have similar thought about Strauss.

[old dee 23,874]

You are probably right od but because i'm often ridiculously optimistic i'm hopeful Roos can get a big improvement out of the pop gun. FOr me he was another player who looked mentally frozen last year and dead set fearful of making mistakes (which of course led to lots of them). He's a confidence player in my book (as i guess most are when all said and done) and perhaps Roos can free him up. I have similar thought about Strauss.

I hope you are right but I think some things are even beyond Roos!

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

If nothing else Jeremy howe makes a painful match up deep forward,

[binman 43,895]

I hope you are right but I think some things are even beyond Roos!

Heresy!

Edited February 12, 2014 by binman

[Hannibal 5,814]

I'd go with

FB: Dunn Frawley Strauss

HB: Grimes McDonald Terlich

C: Vince Jones Watts

HF: Toumpas Pedersen Trengove

FF: Blease Howe JKH

Foll: Spencer Cross Tyson

Int: King, Michie, Georgiou, M. Jones, Clisby, McKenzie

Subs/Emer: Nicholson, Byrnes, Barry, Evans, Bail

Backline (Garland), Midfield (Viney) and small forwards (maybe Kent and Salem pushing for a spot) aren't far off full strength so I'd like to see some competitive signs there. Pressure for a round one spot should pretty much be on from now.

Tall forwards and rucks will have to do the best they can so good luck to them.

Interesting.

I prefer Clisby to both Strauss and Terlich.

Although he may not play, as he had a number of weeks on a modified program. I'll watch with interest those 3 this year.

Edited February 12, 2014 by Hannibal

[Bitter but optimistic 22,250]

I'd go with

FB: Dunn Frawley Strauss

HB: Grimes McDonald Terlich

C: Vince Jones Watts

HF: Toumpas Pedersen Trengove

FF: Blease Howe JKH

Foll: Spencer Cross Tyson

Int: King, Michie, Georgiou, M. Jones, Clisby, McKenzie

Subs/Emer: Nicholson, Byrnes, Barry, Evans, Bail

Backline (Garland), Midfield (Viney) and small forwards (maybe Kent and Salem pushing for a spot) aren't far off full strength so I'd like to see some competitive signs there. Pressure for a round one spot should pretty much be on from now.

Tall forwards and rucks will have to do the best they can so good luck to them.

I wouldn't be surprised if Byrnes gets a run - he's experienced and Roos may want to see what he has to offer. I'd stick Pederson at FF - he's not mobile enough for CHF but could take a mark in scoring range. Don't know if your interchange is in any sort of order but I reckon Jones M will be given plenty of opportunities.

[old dee 23,874]

Heresy!

That is a first binman

Never been called a heretic before.

Thanks

[The Reverend 1,736]

That is a first binman

Never been called a heretic before.

Thanks

The Reverend won't hear of OD being accused of heresy. Reality based pessimism perhaps but not hersy.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,244]

Howe/Pedo vs McBean/Vickery at the key forward posts. I am happy with our pair.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

If nothing else Jeremy howe makes a painful match up deep forward,

If the boy plays smart footy and stops other opposition players blocking his run at the mark.

Therein, lies the unique problem of our side for the last 5 to 7 years….not enough selfless, team oriented shepherding.

Bruise free outside runners.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Desperate?

Pragmatic.

[Carlos Danger 380]

It's all about looking at the midfield for mine.

Jones, Vince, Cross, Trengove, Toumpas, Tyson, Watts, Michie, McKenzie and Jones all named. Intrigued to see what Roos does here and how they all perform.

Edited February 12, 2014 by Carlos Danger

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Anyone know if the top 2 levels of etihad will be open. I don't want a repeat of the Kangaroos game were only standing room was available.

It'll be a lock in.

I'll be there with the boy (man) and leave the VCE kids behind me......

[SaberFang 7,151]

They probably understaff these games, hence the top levels are closed. Can't imagine they'd be expecting large crowds for this match.

[CHAMP 347]

Anyone know if the top 2 levels of etihad will be open. I don't want a repeat of the Kangaroos game were only standing room was available.

OMG fancy having to stand to watch some footy!

With the years it's become less of being a simple and happy spectator of a simple, manly contest and more of paying s'loads to watch a gormless "show". And most of us have lapped it up (but at least we have plastic seats). Sad really.

Edited February 12, 2014 by CHAMP

[Red and Bluebeard 2,101]

If we're talking about MFC in the trenches I'm pretty sure we're France..

More like Belgium. Some parts of France weren't walked over by everyone else ...

[CBDees 3,167]

A slight change on D26 by naming Lyden as an interchange player for this particular match. He is one of the few who can go forward or back wherever there is a need.

B: Alexis Georgiou James Frawley Mitch Clisby

HB: Jack Grimes Tom McDonald Dean Terlich

C: Jack Watts Nathan Jones Bernie Vince

HF: Jimmy Toumpas Cameron Pedersen Sam Blease

F: Max King Jeremy Howe Jay Kennedy-Harris

R: Jake Spencer Dom Tyson Jack Trengove

I: Daniel Cross Viv Michie Lynden Dunn James Strauss

S: Michael Evans Matt Jones

[Redleg 41,622]

Looked at the Tigers squad. I count 14 of their best 22 picked to play.

[monoccular 17,590]

If the boy plays smart footy and stops other opposition players blocking his run at the mark.

Therein, lies the unique problem of our side for the last 5 to 7 years….not enough selfless, team oriented shepherding.

Bruise free outside runners.

I agree re the problem: but do you think Mr Roos will tolerate selfish non-team orientated play??

[jumbo returns 6,741]

OMG fancy having to stand to watch some footy!

With the years it's become less of being a simple and happy spectator of manly contest and more of paying to watch a "show".

Sad really.

Oops...

[jumbo returns 6,741]

I agree re the problem: but do you think Mr Roos will tolerate selfish non-team orientated play??

No bloody way!

Can't wait to see some hardness in the team.

[Roger Mellie 4,128]

I''ve got long term leg problems from an accident.

I think the problem with your leg is the foot part of it is stuck in Champ's mouth