How many weeks will sylvia get?

[dees189227 11,131]

That hit sylvia put on brennan looked like a player who was frustrated and didnt want to be there.

I reckon he is looking at 2-3

[Gorgoroth 12,369]

3 down to 2 with early plea, does he have carry over points?

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Damn he was in Brownlow medal form too.

I am staggered anyone views him as a "leader" in this club.

I really could not give a stuff about him. He will be gone at year end.

[Dr. Mubutu 694]

Put in AT TIMES today. Completely over him. Could not care less if he ever plays in the red and blue again.

If true justice were to be meted out, however, there would be 'insufficient footage to place a charge'.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Having just seen the replay I would say 4-6.

Off the ball.

High impact.

High contact.

Intentional.

Dog act.

[michael collins 49]

Tha AFL definition of "off the ball" seems to vary considerably, and his victim was up and walking a few minutes later, so I'm not sure about high impact - fair enough with the rest.

Mis-placed aggression and frustration. You can sort of understand it, but geez it'll cost us.

[DeeSpencer 23,539]

High impact? why cause Brennan is soft? He ended up on the bench and fine and I don't think he was really knocked out more just very sore

Off the ball? No it was in play to stop the run. That's why he was using his arms as a blocking motion. Just didn't expect Brennan to try and duck under him.

High contact, yes.

Intentional? No. People don't hit people with strange two handed elbows to the side of the head. If he wanted to hit him he would've punched him. Reckless

Dog act? Not really. When did this go so far from a mans game. Was it clean? No. Should be hung and quartered? No way!

At the end of the day it was very silly. It reminds me a lot of the Kosi hit on Elliot. No way did Kosi mean to smash him. But everyone left right and centre was having a go at Kosi.

2-3 weeks is plenty. Think about Barry Hall getting 7 for punching a guy clean off the ball if you think this deserves 6. Also it certainly wasn't an action to line up and drill a guy to knock them out or attempt to break their necks.

[Mydee 288]

At least he had a go If only half the team had a quarter hid\s passion we would be far better off!

[Chook 14,616]

It's no worse than Jettas which got 2 weeks. So...2 weeks is my prediction.

Edited May 12, 2013 by Chook

[Swampfox 190]

Don't care how many

Sylvia is all about potential and its unfortunate he has never got past that level since he was recruited

Also proves why he is not leadership material

Edited May 12, 2013 by Swampfox

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,654]

Having just seen the replay I would say 4-6.

Off the ball.

High impact.

High contact.

Intentional.

Dog act.

Easily the dirtiest act of the year (go to Huns website, footage there). Will be surprised if he gets away with less than 4.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/UeDmsaLhOSM" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Edited May 12, 2013 by Rod Grinter Riot Squad

[spirit of norm smith 13,525]

3 weeks. Poor decision, based on frustration.

Colin actually was one of our better players (against those who say he is a downhill skier). His ability and skill to kick the left foot goal was an example of his talent.

[bluey 897]

See him out the door, good riddance.

[rjay 24,096]

2

[Grimseyisgod 378]

are you serious.

along with 3-4 players today was the only one who did something

[DeeSpencer 23,539]

Sometimes doing nothing is more efficient than the something Sylvia does. If Sylvia won the ball and ran like Matt Jones or Evans he'd be twice the player.

In some ways he's trying. But he's still miles off his potential.

Edited May 12, 2013 by the master

[Demon Jack 6,396]

If Sylvia's out for 3-4 weeks then it might give us a chance to give Taggert a go. Or even better, Magner.

[rolling fog 1,160]

4 down to 3.

If Sylvia's out for 3-4 weeks then it might give us a chance to give Taggert a go. Or even better, Magner.

An enforced holiday won't be the worst thing - every cloud.

Richmond could get real ugly though.

[Retrospective 104]

Frustration written all over that.... I can understand.

He is playing with a lot more accountability and conviction this season.

To those who think we should get rid of him, who do you think we'd recruit to replace him? This is the same issue as we've seen. Rivers effectively "traded" for Gillies, Moloney for no other inside Mid.

[RickyJ45 392]

3 weeks max didn't look too bad and wasn't going for his head, rather was a bit late

Brennan hitting his head on the ground didn't help him concussion wise either.

[angrydee 842]

3-4 with a guilty plea.

[baysidedave 246]

That hit sylvia put on brennan looked like a player who was frustrated and didnt want to be there.

I reckon he is looking at 2-3

yeah 2-3, pity because he's been pretty good the last month or so.

[fuchsia 37]

sylvia wants a " 15 game ban " !!!!

bleeding obvious..!!

[monoccular 16,495]

Having just seen the replay I would say 4-6.

Off the ball.

High impact.

High contact.

Intentional.

Dog act.

. You forgot the "MFC multiplier factor" so more likely 8.

[Undeeterred 2,889]

He barely even hit him.

2 weeks for mine.

And I don't care what people say, he's in our best 3 this year.