Viney Dees Coach in 2012

[Redleg 41,427]

I have heard that MM will do one year as Pies Footy Coaching Director ( will do nothing ) receive $1million and then be free to go where he likes. If we appoint Viney for 1 year I would guess that we have done a deal for MM in 2013. He may have a behind the scenes influence in 2012. Viney can set up the game plan and develop the team and then hand over the reins in 2012. The one fly in the ointment could be the Blues but as I said earlier if Viney gets the nod for next year I think MM will be the Coach the next year. Time will tell. This will have Eddie saving face and then saving $2million for the Pies for years 2013 and 2014.

[beelzebub 23,383]

very interesting mail there Red.. .. has it real legs..or on someones wish list ?

[old dee 23,871]

Surely you are not suggesting we sit on our hands for another year!

Every time I hear Viney he keeps saying he does not want the job.

And how would it look for us to playing a waiting game for MM

He is either available for 2012 or we get someone to do a proper job for the next 3 -5 years.

[BAMF 4,385]

A year is a massive amount of time in football.

If Malthouse wants to coach us then he I want him to start now or not at all.

All this talk about Eddie suing is [censored]. I dont care if Eddie saves face.

Viney has stated that he doesn't want to be a senior coach a couple of times now.

Lets get the new coach in and give him a shot. A caretaker role for a whole year would do nothing to settle us.

[BAMF 4,385]

Surely you are not suggesting we sit on our hands for another year!

Every time I hear Viney he keeps saying he does not want the job.

And how would it look for us to playing a waiting game for MM

He is either available for 2012 or we get someone to do a proper job for the next 3 -5 years.

Beat me to it old dee.

[Old Man Rivers 326]

I have heard that MM will do one year as Pies Footy Coaching Director ( will do nothing ) receive $1million and then be free to go where he likes. If we appoint Viney for 1 year I would guess that we have done a deal for MM in 2013. He may have a behind the scenes influence in 2012. Viney can set up the game plan and develop the team and then hand over the reins in 2012. The one fly in the ointment could be the Blues but as I said earlier if Viney gets the nod for next year I think MM will be the Coach the next year. Time will tell. This will have Eddie saving face and then saving $2million for the Pies for years 2013 and 2014.

WOW - Massive News if True

[Tony Tea 2,809]

Julian De Stoop mentioned that on Fox Sports mid week.

[emubitter 0]

malthouse to carlton, ratten to melbourne. i like it!

[The Big Ticket 94]

After being told how popular he was as coach in Moama, I'm very worried.

[Old Man Rivers 326]

malthouse to carlton, ratten to melbourne. i like it!

Why do so many people continue to settle for 2nd best.

That would be a [censored] outcome

[beelzebub 23,383]

Not personally enamoured with the idea of Ratten.. Malthouse has its appeal. . Agree with you OMR.. lets play for keeps....not leftovers.

[dee-luded 2,959]

I have heard that MM will do one year as Pies Footy Coaching Director ( will do nothing ) receive $1million and then be free to go where he likes. If we appoint Viney for 1 year I would guess that we have done a deal for MM in 2013. He may have a behind the scenes influence in 2012. Viney can set up the game plan and develop the team and then hand over the reins in 2012. The one fly in the ointment could be the Blues but as I said earlier if Viney gets the nod for next year I think MM will be the Coach the next year. Time will tell. This will have Eddie saving face and then saving $2million for the Pies for years 2013 and 2014.

Eddie doesn't want MM going to a club that is 'IN the Window'... He could undo Buckleys Pies if he were @ the Bluebaggers the Sainters or the Hawks.

So E'd would rather he went to a club that has 3 or more years to Mature.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Surely you are not suggesting we sit on our hands for another year!

Every time I hear Viney he keeps saying he does not want the job.

And how would it look for us to playing a waiting game for MM

He is either available for 2012 or we get someone to do a proper job for the next 3 -5 years.

I'd rather we put Choco Williams, Eade or a Scott Burns/Sanderson, in for 2, or maybe 3, to carry on the development of our young Tyro's.

[Redleg 41,427]

Surely you are not suggesting we sit on our hands for another year!

Every time I hear Viney he keeps saying he does not want the job.

And how would it look for us to playing a waiting game for MM

He is either available for 2012 or we get someone to do a proper job for the next 3 -5 years.

I am not suggesting anything, merely relaying news I heard today. It was as close to from the horse's mouth as it could be. I am talking about the MM not coaching for one year and then being free part. The rest is my speculation.

[monoccular 17,573]

So our plans are dictated by the Collingwood President???

No wonder our club has no self esteem.

Get the best available and appoint for 5 years if we think he is really any good.

[Redleg 41,427]

So our plans are dictated by the Collingwood President???

No wonder our club has no self esteem.

Get the best available and appoint for 5 years if we think he is really any good.

At the races today and spoke to a Melbourne fan. He said that he knew the work of Brendan McCarthy and that he was brilliant. Architect of many of the new tactics at Geelong working with Defence and Mid Field. Only drawback being he is not a former AFL player. Widely acclaimed in AFL circles for his coaching. Would we go left field?

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

I have heard that MM will do one year as Pies Footy Coaching Director ( will do nothing ) receive $1million and then be free to go where he likes. If we appoint Viney for 1 year I would guess that we have done a deal for MM in 2013. He may have a behind the scenes influence in 2012. Viney can set up the game plan and develop the team and then hand over the reins in 2012. The one fly in the ointment could be the Blues but as I said earlier if Viney gets the nod for next year I think MM will be the Coach the next year. Time will tell. This will have Eddie saving face and then saving $2million for the Pies for years 2013 and 2014.

Seems plausible but only if both parties had something in place to ensure the transition IMO. Can't see the MFC/FD sitting on its hands for a whole season in hope that this might take place. Too risky.

In addition Mick made it clear on the Footy Show a while back that he wasn't just going to just sit around and not contribute in some significant way as Footy Director, and that this would need sorting. He wanted it to be a win/win for both him and the club.

This would smack in the face of the bolded point up there.

[Fork 'em 6,991]

Would we go left field?

We did that last coach .

Couldn't see it happening again .... Not that far left anyhoo .

Edited August 20, 2011 by Fork 'em

[Old Man Rivers 326]

At the races today and spoke to a Melbourne fan. He said that he knew the work of Brendan McCarthy and that he was brilliant. Architect of many of the new tactics at Geelong working with Defence and Mid Field. Only drawback being he is not a former AFL player. Widely acclaimed in AFL circles for his coaching. Would we go left field?

Bailey was left field.

IMO we where burn't badly by this option.

We simply can't risk Left Field again.

[tonatopia 278]

Mathews said on the radio today that his optimism about Melbourne stems from our ability to turn it on and win by a big margin. If he wants to coach us, it would be great. He is only in his 50's. A long way from retired.

[Deemort 28]

Mathews said on the radio today that his optimism about Melbourne stems from our ability to turn it on and win by a big margin. If he wants to coach us, it would be great. He is only in his 50's. A long way from retired.

59, does he even want to go back to coaching? I didn't think so.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

At the races today and spoke to a Melbourne fan. He said that he knew the work of Brendan McCarthy and that he was brilliant. Architect of many of the new tactics at Geelong working with Defence and Mid Field. Only drawback being he is not a former AFL player. Widely acclaimed in AFL circles for his coaching. Would we go left field?

Hasn't he just gone to Essendon with Bomba?

[BAMF 4,385]

Bailey was left field.

IMO we where burn't badly by this option.

We simply can't risk Left Field again.

We took applicants for the job. Weeded out the bad one's and made a shortlist.

We then extensively interviewed the people on the short list and got them to give us a presentation.

Bailey was deemed the best available by the selection panel.

Thinking about who was available at the time, how was he a left field option?

[Whispering_Jack 30,640]

I think the idea of extending Todd Viney's caretaker coaching role by another twelve months is fraught with danger. We desperately need someone to come in with a plan, not just for the present but also for the years to come.

We need to have someone in who will bring stability back to the club and not uncertainty and another change in a year's time. A stop gap measure would be a disaster for our young list which needs firm direction and a coach who can bring it into line with the most modern and up to date coaching methods - not another year of wondering what will happen next.

[GRUN DEE 69]

Mick Malthouse will be at the Dee's next season!

Bet my left & right one...

Mick aint saying nothing until the Pie's season is over. He will say what the Pie's want too hear.