6.  Harmes

5.  Salem

4.  Clarry

3.  Big M

2.  Lockhart

1.  Hibb

6 Harmes

5 Gawn

4 Salem

3 Oliver

2 Lockhart

1 Hibberd

Harmes and Gawn were huge today.

Honourable mentions to Frost and Hore

Harmes

Gawn

Oliver

Salem

Jones

Hibberd

HM Lockhart/Hunt/Frost/Hore

6 Harmes

5 Gawn

4 Salem

3 Oliver

2 Lockhart

1 Hibberd

6 - Harmes

5 - Gawn

4 - Salem

3 - Oliver

2 - Lockhart 

1 - Hibberd

6- Harmes

5- Gawn

4- Hibberd

3- Oliver

2- Salem

1- Hunt

 

 

Just re watched some of the games. Harmes BOG by a mile. A serious game by him. Well done lad!

Easy 

6- Salem

5- Gawn

4- Harmes

3- Oliver

2- Lockhart 

1- Frost 

apologies to Hibberd

6. Harmes

5. Oliver

4. Gawn

3. Hibberd

2. Salem

1. Lockhart

Mentions - Brayshaw, Hunt 

The Age votes by John Pierik, who actually is a pretty decent journo and watches the game:

8 Gawn

8 Harmes

7 Oliver

7 Salem

7 Shiels

Hard to argue with. 

6: Salem

5: Harmes

4: Gawn

3: Oliver

2: Lockhart

1: Hunt

 

6.Harmes

5.Hibberd

4. Gawn.

3. Salem

2. Clarrie

1. Lockhart

 

6. Harmes

5. Max

4. Salem

3. Oliver 

2.  Hibberd 

1. Patracca (asides from that shank shot for goal, I thought Trac did pleanty of hard contested work and set up a number of goals with some really good vision and well executed passes).

Edited May 4, 20196 yr by Rodney (Balls) Grinter

6. Harmes 

5. Gawn

4. Salem

3. Oliver 

2. Hibberd 

1. Lockhart —— His best game, would have given him one for that diving mark anyway.

6 - Harmes

5 - Salem

4 - Gawn

3 - Oliver

2 - Hunt

1 - Lockhart

Salem is having is great season.

6 Harmes

5 Gawn

4 Hunt

3 Oliver

2 Hibberd

1 Petracca

 

8 hours ago, Swooper1987 said:

The Age votes by John Pierik, who actually is a pretty decent journo and watches the game:

8 Gawn

8 Harmes

7 Oliver

7 Salem

7 Shiels

Hard to argue with. 

Good judge.

Edited May 4, 20196 yr by ProperDee

6 -  Harmes  -  made mince meat out of O meara

5 -  Gawn  -   toyed with McEvoy

4 -  Salem -   his skills stand out so much.  Best and fairest possibility

3 - Hunt -   Goodwin has made some nice positional changes the last 2 games, but Hunt playing out of the goal square yesterday is the most exciting.   Hes unstoppable on the lead and was in everything.  Feels similar to what the Cats are doing with Gary Rohan,.

2 - Hibberd  -  Best game in quite  a while,  finally found a lot of the ball

1 - Lockhart -  a revelation, and to think he wasnt on the list 8 weeks ago.  Another tick for Goodwin for using him as a forward from day 1 when he was a defender at Casey

Edited May 4, 20196 yr by Petraccattack

6. James Harmes  

5. Max Gawn  

4. Michael Hibberd  

3. Christian Salem  

2. Clayton Oliver  

1. Jay Lockhart   

6 Harmes

5 Gawn

4 Hibberd

3 Salem

2 Oliver

1 Jones

6. Harmes

5. Gawn

4. Oliver

3. Salem

2. Lockhart

1. Hunt

6- Harmes

5 - Max

4 - Salem

3 - Clarry

2 - Frost

1 - Lockhart

 

6 - Harmes.  Even with the two 50m penalties, he shut down the Rolls Royce and has 31 disposals and a goal of his own. 

5 - Gawn.  Dominated the ruck against a good opponent and his contested marking and defensive positioning were superb. 

4 - Oliver.  Was a bit messy in the first half, but once again he came on strong and dominated in the second half. 

3 - Petracca.  He made scores happen.  His ability to impact a contest and get the ball to a teammate is phenomenal.  If he could kick set shots as well he'd be dominating. 

2 - Frost.  Relished being the free defender.  He was able to use his pace and power to full advantage.  I think he's well ahead of Oscar at this point. 

1 - Salem - Continues his great year.  Could easily have been higher. 

6: Harmes

5: Gawn

4: Salem

3: Oliver

2: Petracca

1: Hibberd.